Is Sekiro a Souls Game? A Look at the Controversy Surrounding FromSoftware’s New Game
FromSoftware’s Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice was released in 2019, leaving players and critics alike wondering: is this game a Souls game? FromSoftware is known for its notorious dark fantasy series, Dark Souls and Demon’s Souls, which have a unique challenging gameplay mechanic and a steep difficulty curve. Sekiro’s difficulty was compared to the Souls games by many reviewers and players, leading to debates and discussions about whether the new game belongs to the same family. In this article, we will analyze the factors that make Sekiro similar or dissimilar to a traditional Souls game, providing a comprehensive answer to this pressing question.
Direct Answer
Before we dive into the comparisons and analyses, let’s provide a straightforward answer: no, Sekiro is not a traditional Souls game. Dark Souls 3, a title in the Souls series, serves as the closest comparison to Sekiro’s style, but even then, they share differences in gameplay, art design, and tone. Sekiro was heavily influenced by Japanese history, fiction, and folklore, which sets it apart from the traditional Souls games.
Comparative Analysis
Here’s a comprehensive list of similarities and differences that have sparked the debate:
- Difficult gameplay mechanics: Sekiro shares many difficult-to-master mechanics from the Souls series, such as precise dodging, timed attacks, and strategy-focused boss battles.
- Combat emphasis: Sekiro’s combat mechanics have similarities with the Souls series, using strategies, timing, and placement of attacks to defeat enemies. Sekiro introduces new mechanics, like using the prosthetic limb’s various tools, which expand its combat repertoire.
- Exploration-based progression: Both Sekiro and the Souls series feature exploration-heavy progressions, where players must guide the character through an interconnected world, completing optional side quests and discovering new items, paths, and secrets.
- World-building and atmosphere: Although distinct from the Souls series in setting and design, Sekiro retains elements of dark fantasy atmosphere, exploration, and mystery from FromSoftware’s previous works.
- Permadeath and limited resurrection system: Sekiro allows death and resurrection, a familiar aspect for Souls fans, but Sekiro introduces a limited resurrection mechanic. Sekiro’s system relies on checkpoints, which are accessible throughout the world, whereas the Souls series primarily features bonfires ( checkpoint stations).
Differences That Separate Sekiro from the Souls Series
Now, let’s highlight key elements that differentiate Sekiro:
- Steeped in historical authenticity: Sekiro is set during Japan’s Sengoku period and was deeply inspired by Japanese history and fiction.
- New protagonist mechanics: Protagonist Wolf and his prosthetic arm expand Sekiro’s combat, platforming, and exploration mechanics. The prosthetic offers alternative uses, such as distracting or attacking enemies, which distinguish the combat.
- Linear design and world structure: Sekiro has a much more linear design compared to the open worlds in the Souls series. Exploration, however, remains crucial for finding important resources, story clues, and combat tactics.
- Tone and atmosphere: While both series share dark atmospheres, Sekiro’s tone and color palette are more vibrant, owing to the feudal Japan setting, emphasizing feudal society and the world around the protagonist.
Conclusion: Understanding the Debate
Many similarities exist between Sekiro and the Souls series, including challenging gameplay and strategic exploration-based progression. However, Sekiro deviates from the classic Souls design, incorporating new gameplay elements, art styles, and an exploration experience that is distinct but influenced by FromSoftware’s other titles. Fans of the Souls series appreciate this deviation, as it keeps Sekiro fresh and exciting within FromSoftware’s universe.
8 Frequently Asked Questions and Answers
- Q: Is Sekiro easy for beginners?
A: Yes, if you’re familiar with Dark Souls-style games. FromSoftware includes a gentle learning curve to aid newcomers. - Q: Do I need to have played Dark Souls before starting Sekiro?
A: Not necessary. Sekiro serves as a standalone experience; though familiarities with Souls’ games will enhance your understanding and challenge enjoyment. - Q: Will my past Dark Souls experience apply directly to Sekiro’s challenges?
A: Partially, with adaptability. Sekiro uses some similar mechanics, but your preconceptions might need adjusting; understand new mechanics and strategies specifically developed for Sekiro. - Q: Will there be DLC expansions or sequels?
A: Unannounced as of our knowledge cutoff. FromSoftware generally waits until the game has achieved long-term success before considering such development paths. - Q: Will my game crashes/hangs be more severe in Sekiro than the Souls series?
A: Fewer reported issues than expected, according to player feedback; patches and updates have continued to maintain stability. - Q: Do online multiplayer features exist?
A: No, Sekiro features only single-player experiences and asynchronous interactions through certain boss fights. - Q: Do both console and PC versions have 16:9 aspect ratio support?
A: PC version only has the 16:9 support as an option; for those seeking a more nostalgic Dark Souls experience. - Q: Was FromSoftware influenced by external works or inspirations, in particular for Sekiro’s mechanics or design?
A: Samurai Westerns, Dark Age fiction, and Japanese art are a few influences on the design, as well as gameplay adjustments and innovations.
While not a traditional Souls game, Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice is an excellent addition to the series family tree. FromSoftware took bold steps to create something innovative yet familiar, catering to old and new fans alike.