Should you kill gatekeeper gostoc?
The answer to the question of whether you should kill gatekeeper gostoc in Elden Ring is subjective and depends on your gameplay style and preferences. Killing gostoc will not lock you out of Nepheli Loux and Kenneth Haight’s quest as it can still be completed without him. However, there are consequences to killing him. You will miss out on the Ancient Dragon Smithing Stone and won’t be able to buy it from the Twin Maiden Husks even if you gave them his bell bearing.
That being said, many players choose to kill gostoc for various reasons. Some players prefer to have more freedom in the game and not rely on gostoc to open the gate for them. By killing him, you can avoid having to go through the gates from the other side later on. This gives you more flexibility and allows you to explore the game world at your own pace.
Another reason why players choose to kill gostoc is to obtain the Ancient Dragon Smithing Stone. If gostoc is alive, he will sell this valuable item in his shop. However, by killing him, you can acquire the stone directly from him. This can be beneficial if you want to enhance your weapons and armor with the Ancient Dragon Smithing Stone.
Additionally, some players enjoy the challenge and satisfaction of defeating gostoc in combat. He will lock you in a room with a Banished Knight if you choose his suggested path and die. By killing him, you can avoid this situation and keep your runes safe.
Overall, the decision to kill gostoc in Elden Ring is a personal one. It is not necessary for completing the quest, but it does come with its own benefits. Consider your playstyle and goals in the game before making a decision.
Frequently Asked Questions:
1. What happens if you kill the gatekeeper gostoc?
When you kill gatekeeper gostoc, you will acquire his bell bearing and miss out on the Ancient Dragon Smithing Stone. You won’t be able to purchase the stone from the Twin Maiden Husks even if you gave them his bell bearing.
2. Should I keep gatekeeper gostoc alive?
Initially, you can refuse gostoc’s suggestion and ask him to open the gate. This saves you from doing it from the other side later and gives you more freedom in the game. However, gostoc will lock you in a room with a Banished Knight and steal some of your runes if you die.
3. What happens if you kill the Fire Keeper?
The Fire Keeper can be killed, but she will respawn when the area is reloaded. You can spend souls to level up with her assistance, and she can ‘heal’ the Dark Sigils located in your inventory.
4. Does Gostoc need to be alive to complete the quest?
No, Gostoc is not required to complete his quest. He gives one Ancient Dragon Smithing Stone, and if he is alive, he will be available at his shop selling another Ancient Dragon Smithing Stone.
5. Do you get your runes back if you kill Gostoc?
You only get back what you lost from Gostoc’s death tax. However, if you want to hold off on killing him to get your runes back, it must be done before you beat Godrick. After defeating Godrick, Gostoc will no longer drop the runes.
6. Why should you defeat Gatekeeper Gostoc immediately?
Defeating Gostoc immediately eliminates the risk of him locking you in a room with a Banished Knight and stealing your runes. It is a safer option for players who want to avoid this situation.
7. When should you kill Gostoc?
It is best to kill Gostoc as soon as you can. He will drop his bell bearing, which you can give to the merchant at Roundtable Hold. Additionally, killing him will prevent him from locking you in a room with a Banished Knight.
8. How do I stop Gostoc from stealing my runes?
In order to stop Gostoc from stealing your runes, talk to him at the listed locations and then return to his location at the gatehouse. After this, he will no longer steal any runes from you.
9. What does Gostoc give you?
Once all three NPCs have moved to the throne room, Gostoc will reopen his shop and you can buy an Ancient Dragon Smithing Stone from him.
10. Should you go through the main gate of Stormveil Castle?
According to an NPC in Elden Ring, you shouldn’t walk through the main gate of Stormveil Castle as it is filled with soldiers. Instead, it is advised to walk through a hole in the wall to explore the castle undetected.