Does it Matter Who I Give Embers to in DS1?

In the world of Dark Souls, giving embers to the right blacksmith is crucial for weapon ascension, and it indeed matters who you give them to, as each ember is specifically designed for a particular blacksmith. The correct assignment of embers allows players to unlock various weapon upgrades, such as divine, fire, or crystal infusions, which can significantly impact gameplay and strategy.

Understanding Embers and Blacksmiths

Embers are special items found throughout the Dark Souls universe that enable blacksmiths to ascend and modify weapons. Each ember is tailored to a specific blacksmith, and attempting to give an ember to the wrong blacksmith will result in refusal. This system emphasizes the importance of identifying the correct blacksmith for each ember to maximize weapon upgrades and enhancements.

Ember and Blacksmith Pairings

To navigate this complex system, players must understand which embers can be given to which blacksmiths. For instance, the Large Ember is meant for Andre, the blacksmith in Undead Parish, and allows him to upgrade standard weapons from +5 to +10. Similarly, the Divine Ember is also given to Andre, enabling the creation of divine weapons. This precise matching is crucial for accessing higher levels of weapon ascension.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Below are answers to common questions related to embers and blacksmiths in Dark Souls, providing further insight into this intricate mechanic.

1. Who should I give the Large Ember to in DS1? The Large Ember should be given to Andre, the blacksmith in Undead Parish, to enable him to upgrade standard weapons from +5 to +10.

2. Should I give all my embers to Andre? While Andre can use several types of embers, such as the Large Ember and the Divine Ember, not all embers are meant for him. Players should ensure they are giving each ember to its corresponding blacksmith.

3. Who should I give the Crystal Ember to? The Crystal Ember should be given to the Giant Blacksmith in Anor Londo, allowing him to ascend standard weapons down the crystal path.

4. Who do you give the Magic Ember to in DS1? The Magic Ember is given to Rickert, enabling him to ascend weapons to enchanted.

5. How do you get a weapon to +10 in DS1? To upgrade a weapon to +10, players must first give the Large Ember to Andre, then use “Modify Equipment” at Andre to boost from +5 to +6, and finally use “Reinforce Weapon” to upgrade from +6 to +10.

6. Should I give the Divine Ember to the blacksmith in Dark Souls Remastered? Yes, give the Divine Ember to Andre, as it allows him to ascend +5 normal weapons to +0 divine with a green titanite shard and some souls.

7. What happens if you give Andre the Very Large Ember? Giving Andre the Very Large Ember enables him to ascend a standard weapon from +10 to +11, allowing for further standard weapon reinforcement from +11 to +15.

8. Do embers reset in DS1? All embers are reset after defeating the final boss, as the enemies in the last area have a 100% chance to drop chunks of all colors, making it advisable to upgrade what you want before the final battle.

9. Who is the best blacksmith in Dark Souls? Andre is considered the best blacksmith due to his ability to ascend weapons down the Standard, Raw, Divine, and Occult paths, provided he has been given the proper embers.

10. What ember is needed to make boss weapons? To create boss weapons, players must first give the Large Ember to a suitable blacksmith, such as Andre or the Giant Blacksmith in Anor Londo, then ascend the weapon using the Giant Blacksmith, 5,000 souls, and the boss souls.

11. Should I give the blacksmith the Dull Ember? Yes, giving the Dull Ember to Steady Hand McDuff enables him to infuse weapons with elements.

12. What to do with the Large Divine Ember? Give the Large Divine Ember to Andre, as it allows him to upgrade divine weapons up to +10.

13. How do you upgrade past +5 in DS1? To upgrade past +5, acquire the Large Ember, give it to Andre, and then use “Modify Equipment” at Andre to boost from +5 to +6, followed by “Reinforce Weapon” to upgrade further.

14. Do you need an ember to be summoned? No, only the host needs to be embered to summon a player with a white sign, but not when being summoned or using a red sign.

15. What happens if you give Andre Farron coal? Giving Andre Farron coal enables him to infuse heavy, sharp, and poison infusions into his work, further expanding weapon customization options.