Is it Possible to Not Save Micah in Red Dead Redemption 2?

Unfortunately, the answer is a definitive no. You cannot avoid saving Micah Bell in Red Dead Redemption 2. Despite the player’s potential dislike for the character and awareness of his treacherous nature, the mission “Blessed Are the Peacemakers” in Chapter 2 is mandatory for progressing the main storyline. This mission forces Arthur Morgan to break Micah out of jail in Strawberry, setting in motion a chain of events that significantly impacts the narrative. Whether you relish the idea or despise it, Micah’s escape is a crucial plot point that cannot be circumvented.

Why Saving Micah is Unavoidable

The game’s narrative is structured in a way that certain events must occur to advance the plot. Micah’s rescue is one of these unavoidable events. It serves several narrative purposes:

• Catalyst for Conflict: Micah’s presence introduces a significant source of conflict within the Van der Linde gang, ultimately leading to its downfall.

• Character Development: The rescue mission reveals aspects of Arthur’s character, demonstrating his loyalty to the gang (at least initially) and his willingness to follow Dutch’s orders, even when he has reservations.

• Plot Progression: Micah’s actions after his rescue directly contribute to the escalating tensions and law enforcement pressure that force the gang to continually move and ultimately fracture.

The Illusion of Choice in Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2 is lauded for its immersive open world and the illusion of choice it provides players. However, it’s essential to remember that the main storyline is pre-determined. While players have considerable freedom in how they approach missions and interact with the world, certain key events are immutable. This carefully constructed narrative ensures that the story unfolds as Rockstar Games intended. The developers chose to force certain things upon the player to make the story move in a particular manner and set up the game’s ending. Even though there is a lot of player freedom, the main plot events have to occur in order to beat the game’s story mode.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Micah Bell and His Role

Here are 15 frequently asked questions about Micah Bell and his role in Red Dead Redemption 2, offering more insight into his character, the implications of saving him, and alternative possibilities that players have considered:

1. Can I just go back to a saved game and let Micah rot in jail?

No, reverting to a saved game will not change the fact that you eventually have to break Micah out of jail. The storyline is designed to force this event.

2. Is there any other way to free Micah besides using the Steam Donkey?

The primary method involves using the Steam Donkey contraption to pull the bars off the window. While creative players may have attempted alternative approaches, the game’s scripting heavily favors the intended method.

3. How do you not lose honor when rescuing Micah?

Maintaining high honor during the Micah rescue is challenging. Evading lawmen completely and escaping without incurring a bounty is possible with skillful gameplay. Avoid unnecessary violence and prioritize stealth. This can still be extremely difficult due to the constraints of the mission itself.

4. Does Micah betray you in RDR2?

Yes, Micah betrays the gang by providing information to the Pinkertons after his return from Guarma. This revelation significantly impacts the narrative and Arthur’s perception of the gang’s future.

5. Is Micah actually a good guy deep down?

Micah Bell is widely regarded as one of the most unredeemable villains in video game history. He lacks any discernible redeeming qualities and consistently demonstrates cruelty and self-serving behavior.

6. What Happens If Arthur DOESN’T Break Micah Out Of Jail In Red Dead Redemption 2? (SECRET Outcome)

There is no secret outcome. Arthur MUST break Micah out of jail for the story to continue, so there will be no change to the game even if you try some other method.

7. Why did Dutch like Micah so much?

Dutch’s affinity for Micah is complex. Factors include Micah saving Dutch’s life and Micah’s unwavering support for Dutch’s increasingly erratic plans. This blinded Dutch to Micah’s true nature. He also may have just been seeing things differently as he lost his mind.

8. Can you go back to Micah’s body after the final encounter?

Yes, after the final confrontation, you can visit Micah Bell’s frozen corpse at the cabin on Mount Hagen. You can also pick up his unique double-action revolver.

9. Can you go back and loot both of Micah’s revolvers?

While Micah carries twin revolvers, you can only loot one from his body after the final encounter. The game mechanics only allow for acquiring a single instance of Micah’s Revolver.

10. How to save Micah without dynamite?

Dynamite is not necessarily needed. The primary way to save Micah is by using the Steam Donkey to remove the bars, as described in the mission.

11. Can you find Dutch after he kills Micah?

After the events on Mount Hagen, Dutch disappears. In Red Dead Redemption 2, his fate remains ambiguous. In the first Red Dead game, John Marston eventually tracks him down and kills him.

12. Could Arthur have killed Micah without TB?

It is highly probable that a healthy Arthur Morgan would have been able to defeat Micah in a one-on-one fight. Tuberculosis significantly weakened Arthur, giving Micah a crucial advantage. Arthur weakened, and the effects of TB, put him at a severe disadvantage.

13. What gun does Micah give you?

Micah does not give Arthur a gun. However, you can loot Micah’s Revolver after killing him on Mount Hagen. It is a unique double-action revolver with a distinctive appearance and engravings.

14. Can you beat Micah as Arthur outside of the main storyline?

There are no opportunities to fight Micah outside of the scripted encounters in the main story. The narrative confines confrontations to specific moments.

15. Does Micah ever sleep rdr2?

Micah is noted for rarely sleeping within the game’s routine. This contributes to his unsettling presence and adds to the sense that he is always scheming.

The Enduring Dislike for Micah Bell

Micah Bell is a character that players love to hate. His actions throughout Red Dead Redemption 2, from his impulsive violence to his ultimate betrayal, make him a truly despicable figure. While the game offers many choices and paths, the requirement to save Micah serves as a constant reminder of the limitations within the narrative structure. Despite this constraint, the game’s rich story and intricate world continue to captivate players, sparking discussions and theories long after the credits roll. Game developers are constantly looking for the sweet spot between player freedom and storyline demands. More and more, games are offering more and more options for the player to take, but sometimes story demands that certain things happen in order to set up particular events.

For further insights into gaming narratives and game design principles, explore the resources available at the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org. Understanding how games create compelling stories can be just as engaging as playing them.

In conclusion, while the burning desire to leave Micah Bell in jail may be strong, the narrative demands his rescue, solidifying his role as a central antagonist and driving force behind the tragic events of Red Dead Redemption 2.