Should I Let Lord Shimura Live in Ghost of Tsushima? A Deep Dive into a Difficult Decision
The question that hangs heavy over the final moments of Ghost of Tsushima is not whether you can defeat Lord Shimura, but whether you should. This choice, seemingly simple on the surface, is a complex tapestry woven from honor, duty, personal conviction, and the very soul of Jin Sakai himself. There’s no easy answer, no unequivocally “right” path. However, taking all factors into account, sparing Lord Shimura is arguably the more narratively satisfying and logically consistent choice for Jin’s character arc, though killing him is the one most likely to be canon. While either outcome presents a bittersweet conclusion, letting Shimura live allows Jin to fully embrace his identity as the Ghost and reject the rigid samurai code that has constrained him for so long.
The Weight of Honor: Two Sides of the Same Coin
The dilemma presented at the end of Ghost of Tsushima centers on the conflict between two competing ideals: the traditional samurai code, embodied by Lord Shimura, and the pragmatic, unconventional methods adopted by Jin as the Ghost. Shimura, bound by his loyalty to the Shogun and his unwavering belief in bushido, sees Jin’s tactics as dishonorable and a threat to the established order. He demands an honorable death, a final act of ritual suicide at Jin’s hands, to preserve his legacy and ensure his soul finds peace.
Killing Shimura, then, represents a final, albeit tragic, adherence to the samurai code. It’s an act of mercy, granting him the warrior’s death he desires and preserving his honor in the eyes of his peers. Some might argue that Jin owes him this final respect, given Shimura’s role as his father figure and mentor.
Conversely, sparing Shimura is a complete rejection of the samurai code. It’s Jin choosing his own path, acknowledging that the old ways are insufficient to protect Tsushima and that a new form of heroism is necessary. By refusing to grant Shimura his wish, Jin condemns him to live with the perceived dishonor of his defeat and the knowledge that the samurai order he upheld is crumbling. The text suggests as well that he will be executed by the shogun for failing to follow orders if spared.
Factors to Consider
Before making your final decision, consider these key factors:
- Jin’s Character Development: Throughout the game, Jin gradually sheds the constraints of the samurai code, embracing the “ghostly” tactics of stealth, deception, and unconventional warfare. Sparing Shimura is the logical culmination of this transformation, solidifying his identity as a protector who prioritizes the needs of his people over rigid tradition.
- Shimura’s Perspective: While Shimura’s motives are rooted in a desire to uphold honor and order, his adherence to the samurai code ultimately blinds him to the realities of the Mongol invasion. His refusal to adapt and his insistence on traditional methods contribute to the initial devastation of Tsushima.
- The Consequences: The game mechanics offer minimal post-game differences between the two choices. The primary difference lies in the dye received for the Ghost Armor, along with the story implications of having spared Shimura. The fact that a sequel is possible adds further weight to the decision.
- Your Personal Interpretation: Ultimately, the best ending is the one that resonates most deeply with you. Consider what you value most – honor, duty, or personal freedom – and make your choice accordingly.
Why Sparing Shimura Feels “Right”
While both endings are powerful and emotionally resonant, sparing Shimura offers a more compelling narrative conclusion for several reasons:
- It Completes Jin’s Transformation: Jin’s journey is one of radical change, and sparing Shimura is the final step in his evolution. It’s a decisive break from the past and a bold declaration of his commitment to the future.
- It Highlights the Futility of Rigid Ideology: Shimura’s unwavering adherence to the samurai code ultimately proves detrimental to Tsushima. Sparing him underscores the limitations of his ideology and the necessity of adapting to changing circumstances.
- It Offers a Glimmer of Hope: Despite the tragedy of the situation, sparing Shimura suggests the possibility of reconciliation, however remote. It leaves the door open for future interactions and a potential reevaluation of their relationship. While the game’s dialogue doesn’t suggest this, the nature of Jin’s character suggests he would remain open to some relationship in the future, making Shimura’s rejection of him as the Ghost even more tragic.
- It’s a Braver Choice: Killing Shimura is, in some ways, the easier option. It fulfills his wish and provides a sense of closure. Sparing him requires Jin to shoulder the burden of his uncle’s disapproval and the uncertainty of the future. It shows Jin’s character is growing in resilience to criticism and doubt.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What dye do I get for killing Lord Shimura?
You receive the “Righteous Punishment” dye, a white coloration for the Ghost Armor, Ghost Mask, and Ghost Headband.
2. What dye do I get for sparing Lord Shimura?
You receive the “Vow of Vengeance” dye, a crimson red coloration for the Ghost Armor.
3. Is killing Lord Shimura the “bad” ending?
It’s a matter of perspective. While some consider it the “bad” ending due to the act of killing a family member, it can also be seen as an act of mercy and respect for Shimura’s wishes. Neither ending is objectively “good” or “bad”.
4. Is there a “canon” ending to Ghost of Tsushima?
There’s no officially confirmed canon ending. However, the spare ending may be canon for Ghost of Tsushima 2.
5. Does the ending affect the post-game gameplay?
The ending has minimal impact on post-game gameplay. The primary difference is the dye you unlock.
6. Is Lord Shimura evil?
Lord Shimura is not evil. He is a complex character driven by his unwavering adherence to the samurai code and his duty to the Shogun. He represents the traditional values that Jin ultimately rejects.
7. Does sparing or killing Shimura affect the story in any other significant ways?
Aside from the unlocked dye, the story remains mostly unchanged. Both endings will result in a mournful parting.
8. Is Jin considered a traitor regardless of my choice?
Yes, Jin is considered a traitor by the Shogun regardless of whether you kill or spare Shimura because of his Ghost tactics. The final battle only resolves his relationship with his uncle.
9. What happens to Jin after I spare Shimura?
Jin becomes an outlaw hunted by the Shogun’s forces. The future is uncertain, but he remains committed to protecting the people of Tsushima.
10. Can Lord Shimura survive if I spare him?
Yes, Lord Shimura will survive if spared, though it is implied that he will then face consequences from the Shogun for disobeying his orders and failing to defeat Jin.
11. Does the relationship between Jin and Yuna change depending on my choice?
No, the relationship between Jin and Yuna remains consistent regardless of the ending you choose.
12. Does Ghost of Tsushima have a sequel planned?
Sucker Punch Productions has not yet officially announced Ghost of Tsushima 2 as of 2024.
13. Where can I learn more about the educational aspects of video games?
You can explore the research and discussions on game-based learning at the Games Learning Society website: https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/. The GamesLearningSociety.org is a great resource.
14. Is Ghost of Tsushima based on a true story?
Yes, it is inspired by the historical Mongol invasion of Tsushima Island in 1274. However, many of the events and characters are fictionalized.
15. Is it more honorable to kill or spare Shimura?
This depends on your interpretation of honor. Killing Shimura is honorable in the context of the samurai code, while sparing him is honorable in the context of Jin’s evolving moral compass.
Ultimately, the choice is yours. Let your instincts guide you, and choose the ending that resonates most deeply with your understanding of Jin Sakai and the world of Ghost of Tsushima.