Should You Tell Sebastian Sallow the Truth in Hogwarts Legacy? A Comprehensive Guide

The question of whether to tell Sebastian Sallow the truth in Hogwarts Legacy is a common one, and it’s understandable why. Throughout the game, you’ll encounter a series of morally complex choices, and Sebastian’s storyline is a prime example. The good news is that, from a purely narrative perspective, telling or not telling Sebastian the truth doesn’t significantly alter the overarching story or even your friendship with him. This decision, while pivotal to your role-playing experience, has less to do with grand narrative shifts and more to do with personal character alignment and how you want your relationship with Sebastian to unfold.

However, the choices you make regarding Sebastian, especially those at the end of his quest line, do have lasting consequences, particularly impacting his availability and the potential to learn certain powerful spells. Let’s dive deep into the implications of your choices and what you need to know to make an informed decision.

Telling the Truth vs. Withholding Information: A Closer Look

The initial dilemma of whether to tell Sebastian the truth crops up relatively early in the game during his personal questline. The core issue isn’t about changing the course of the main plot; rather, it’s about the moral path you choose to tread. The decision here is more about how your character views honesty and transparency within their close relationships. While neither choice will completely derail Sebastian’s character arc or your overall game experience, it does set a precedent for how your interactions will continue to develop. The most important consequence to remember is that your truth telling at this stage does not alter the major events of Sebastian’s story.

The real choice of huge consequence with Sebastian arises after his confrontation with his uncle, Solomon. Here the question isn’t so much about the truth, but whether to turn him in to the authorities.

The Consequences of Turning in Sebastian Sallow

Turning in Sebastian has significant and very clear consequences:

• Expulsion from Hogwarts: Sebastian will be expelled, making him unavailable for quests at the end of the game.
• No Epilogue Appearance: He won’t be present during the end-of-year celebrations or the post-game world.
• Loss of Unforgivable Curses: If you haven’t learned the Unforgivable Curses from him, you’ll miss out on that opportunity, although they can be accessed through alternative methods (mentioned later).
• Azkaban: Sebastian will be taken to Azkaban to face justice.

Choosing this option aligns with a more law-abiding and righteous path. However, it cuts off a crucial part of the game’s content and potential for continued interaction. This is a permanent decision, and there is no changing your mind after you make it.

The Consequences of NOT Turning in Sebastian Sallow

Choosing not to turn in Sebastian leads to a very different outcome:

• Continued Interaction: Sebastian remains at Hogwarts, allowing for continued conversations, and access to his quest content.
• Potential to Learn Unforgivable Curses: If you haven’t already, Sebastian can still teach you the Unforgivable Curses, including Avada Kedavra.
• He Gets Away With Murder: This path means Sebastian gets away with the murder of his uncle, remaining free despite his grave actions.

This decision aligns with a more morally grey approach and is favored by players who want to experience all possible game content.

The Moral Implications of Your Choices

The choice about telling Sebastian the truth and, more significantly, turning him in or not, has profound moral implications:

• Justice vs. Loyalty: Do you prioritize the law and justice, or do you remain loyal to a friend who has committed a terrible act?
• Moral Ambiguity: Hogwarts Legacy doesn’t offer clear-cut “good” and “bad” choices. It forces players to confront moral ambiguity and consider the consequences of their actions from different perspectives.
• Consequences of Dark Magic: Sebastian’s actions, and your choices related to him, force you to contemplate the nature of dark magic, the dangers of obsession, and the complexities of friendship.

Ultimately, your decision about Sebastian should be based on the character you want to play, the values you want to embody, and the narrative experience you’re seeking.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here are 15 frequently asked questions to further clarify the complexities of the Sebastian Sallow storyline:

1. Can I save Anne Sallow from her curse?

   • Unfortunately, no. Anne’s curse cannot be lifted in Hogwarts Legacy. Her storyline ultimately ends in tragedy.

2. Does Sebastian go evil?

   • Sebastian doesn’t start evil; his intentions are initially to help his sister. However, he descends down a dark path, leading to the murder of his uncle, and the use of the Unforgivable Curses.

3. Can I stop Sebastian from killing his uncle?

   • No, you cannot stop Sebastian from killing Solomon. The confrontation and the result are predetermined.

4. If I turn Sebastian in, can I still learn Avada Kedavra?

   • You won’t be able to learn Avada Kedavra from Sebastian if you turn him in. You can only gain access to it through the Dark Arts Battle Arena, which requires a Deluxe Edition or a specific DLC purchase.

5. Can you romance Sebastian Sallow?

   • No, Hogwarts Legacy does not include any romance options for any characters.

6. Should I betray Sebastian?

   • “Betraying” Sebastian, by turning him in, results in his expulsion, imprisonment, and the loss of his content. If you value his character’s presence in the game, consider not turning him in.

7. Does my wand choice affect the strength of my character?

   • No, wand choices in Hogwarts Legacy are purely cosmetic and do not impact your character’s abilities.

8. What is the good ending in Hogwarts Legacy?

   • The “good” ending in the game is when you choose to keep the secret of ancient magic contained forever. This requires specific dialogue choices during the main storyline.

9. Can I get expelled from Hogwarts in Hogwarts Legacy?

   • You cannot get expelled from Hogwarts in the way that would end your game prematurely; you can, however, make choices that impact your relationships and availability of certain characters.

10. Should Sebastian take the relic?

    • Regardless of your dialogue choices, Sebastian always ends up taking the relic.

11. Is Sebastian Sallow only a Slytherin?

    • Yes, Sebastian is always a Slytherin, as part of his designed backstory and character arc.

12. What happens if I abandon Sebastian?

    • Abandoning Sebastian means that he leaves the game entirely. You will lose all access to him, including dialogue, interactions and opportunities to learn spells from him.

13. Is it important to choose Natty or Sebastian to go with me to Hogsmeade?

    • No, choosing either Natty or Sebastian to go to Hogsmeade doesn’t make a significant difference to the storyline or quest progress.

14. Does the option to tell or not tell the truth to Sebastian impact the ending?

    • No, your choice to tell Sebastian the truth or not has no impact on the ending or overall story arc. This choice only affects your personal interactions with him.

15. Why did Sebastian turn evil?

    • Sebastian was not evil from the start. His actions were motivated by revenge and an obsession with dark magic, stemming from his need to save his sister and discovering the lies regarding his father.

Conclusion

The decision of whether to tell Sebastian Sallow the truth in Hogwarts Legacy, while seemingly simple, highlights the deeper moral choices present in the game. It reflects the complexities of friendship, loyalty, and justice. Ultimately, your choice is about crafting the character experience you desire. Whether you choose to stand by Sebastian or turn him in, understand that these choices, and their consequences, are a pivotal part of the game’s rich narrative.