Can I Play Dark Souls 3 After Dark Souls 1? A Soulslike Veteran’s Perspective
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Absolutely! You can, and in many ways, you should! Playing Dark Souls 3 (DS3) after experiencing Dark Souls 1 (DS1) is a perfectly viable and, for many, a preferred way to delve into the Dark Souls universe. While each game tells its own story, DS3 builds upon the lore and world established in DS1, offering a richer and more nuanced experience for those familiar with the original. Think of it as revisiting a beloved, albeit incredibly bleak, homeland. However, understand that your experience with DS1 will definitely add a layer of depth to your experience with DS3.
The Appeal of Playing DS3 After DS1
Playing DS3 after DS1 provides numerous advantages:
- Enhanced Lore Appreciation: DS3 is brimming with references, characters, and locations that directly tie back to DS1. Understanding the events of DS1 elevates these nods from simple easter eggs to significant plot points that deepen your understanding of the overall narrative. You’ll recognize the significance of locations like Anor Londo and characters who echo past legends.
- Familiar Combat Foundation: While the combat mechanics in DS3 are faster and more aggressive than in DS1, the core principles remain the same. Your experience with DS1 will give you a solid understanding of stamina management, enemy attack patterns, and effective build strategies, allowing you to adapt to the faster pace of DS3 more easily.
- Emotional Resonance: Witnessing the fate of familiar characters and places in DS3 can be incredibly moving, especially if you’ve grown attached to the world of DS1. Seeing the consequences of past actions and the cyclical nature of the Age of Fire and Age of Dark carries far more weight when you’ve personally experienced the events that set them in motion.
- Improved Navigation and Exploration: DS1 teaches you the importance of careful exploration and observation. This skill translates directly to DS3, where hidden paths, secret areas, and valuable items are often tucked away in the most unexpected places. Your patience and attention to detail will be richly rewarded.
- Understanding the Interconnected World: While not as interconnected as DS1, DS3 still features clever level design that rewards exploration and provides a sense of place. Having a foundation in DS1’s world design helps you appreciate the nuances of DS3’s environments and the ways in which they connect to the overall narrative.
However, understand that there are many ways to approach the game as well as many different perspectives, which the Games Learning Society explores in their research.
Potential Downsides to Consider
While playing DS3 after DS1 is generally recommended, there are a few potential drawbacks:
- Clunky Combat Adjustment: After experiencing the faster, more fluid combat of DS3, returning to DS1 can feel clunky and slow. This might make subsequent playthroughs of DS1 less enjoyable if you prioritize gameplay feel above all else.
- Spoiler Concerns: DS3 does spoil certain aspects of DS1, particularly regarding the fates of some key characters and the overall lore. If you are extremely sensitive to spoilers, playing DS1 first is essential.
- Missed Mechanical Improvements: DS3 features numerous quality-of-life improvements that are absent in DS1. These include faster travel, more forgiving death mechanics, and a generally more streamlined user interface. Going back to DS1 after experiencing these improvements can feel somewhat restrictive.
FAQ: Answering Your Dark Souls 3 Questions
Here are some frequently asked questions to further clarify the relationship between DS1 and DS3 and help you decide on your ideal playthrough order:
1. Is Dark Souls 3 a Direct Sequel to Dark Souls 1?
Yes and no. DS3 is a thematic and spiritual sequel to DS1. It continues the overarching narrative concerning the First Flame and the cyclical struggle between the gods and humanity. However, the immediate plot and characters are largely distinct, although interconnected.
2. Do I Need to Play Dark Souls 2 Before Dark Souls 3?
Not necessarily. Dark Souls 2 is more of a standalone entry in the series, with a weaker narrative connection to DS1 and DS3. While it explores similar themes and contributes to the overall lore, it is not essential for understanding the plot of DS3. However, DS2 is still a fantastic game in its own right and well worth playing.
3. Is Dark Souls 3 Easier or Harder Than Dark Souls 1?
This is subjective and depends on your play style. Many players find DS3 more challenging due to its faster combat and more aggressive enemies. However, others find it easier due to its more forgiving mechanics and clearer direction. Generally, most will find the first game they play to be the hardest.
4. Will Playing Dark Souls 3 Spoil Dark Souls 1?
Yes, to some extent. DS3 reveals the fates of certain characters and locations from DS1, which could diminish the impact of experiencing them for the first time in the original game.
5. Does Dark Souls 3 Feel Like Dark Souls 1?
While sharing the same core mechanics and atmosphere, DS3 has a distinct identity. Its combat is faster and more aggressive, its environments are more visually stunning, and its story is more directly tied to the events of DS1.
6. Is Dark Souls 3 a Good Starting Point for the Series?
It can be, but it’s generally not recommended. Starting with DS1 allows you to appreciate the evolution of the series and experience the lore in its intended order. However, if you’re intimidated by the older graphics and slower pace of DS1, DS3 can serve as a gateway into the Dark Souls universe.
7. How Long Does it Take to Beat Dark Souls 3?
The main story typically takes around 30-40 hours, while a completionist run can take upwards of 80-100 hours or more, depending on your skill level and play style.
8. Does Dark Souls 3 Have Multiple Endings?
Yes, DS3 has four distinct endings, each requiring specific actions or quest completions.
9. Is Dark Souls 3’s Story as Good as Dark Souls 1’s?
This is subjective. Some prefer the more straightforward and character-driven narrative of DS1, while others appreciate the more complex and lore-rich story of DS3.
10. Can I Still Play Dark Souls 3 After Beating the Game?
Yes, you can choose to either start a New Game Plus or continue exploring the world after defeating the final boss.
11. Is Dark Souls 3 Worth Playing in 2024?
Absolutely! DS3 remains a critically acclaimed and highly enjoyable game. Its challenging gameplay, stunning visuals, and rich lore continue to captivate players years after its release.
12. What Class Should I Choose in Dark Souls 3?
The best class depends on your play style. The Knight is a good all-around choice for beginners, while the Pyromancer offers a versatile blend of melee and magic.
13. Is There a Connection Between Elden Ring and Dark Souls 3?
Officially, no. Elden Ring and the Dark Souls series exist in separate universes. However, they share similar gameplay mechanics and thematic elements, and many fans believe they are connected in some way.
14. What Makes Dark Souls 3 Difficult?
DS3 is difficult due to its challenging enemies, unforgiving death mechanics, and emphasis on precise timing and strategy. It demands patience, perseverance, and a willingness to learn from your mistakes.
15. Where Can I Learn More About the Lore of Dark Souls?
There are many excellent resources available online, including wikis, YouTube channels, and online forums dedicated to Dark Souls lore. Consider also academic sources: much can be found in research from sources like the Games Learning Society about the ways the games’ stories are presented and understood. Check out GamesLearningSociety.org for more info.
Conclusion: Embrace the Journey
Ultimately, the decision of whether to play DS3 after DS1 is a matter of personal preference. However, considering the benefits of experiencing the lore in order and appreciating the enhanced emotional impact, playing DS3 after DS1 is a highly rewarding experience. Just be prepared for a challenging but ultimately satisfying journey into the heart of the Dark Souls universe. Good luck, Ashen One!