What Happens If I Killed Yura in Elden Ring? A Comprehensive Guide

So, you’ve slain Bloody Finger Hunter Yura in Elden Ring. Perhaps it was for a quick Nagakiba, or maybe you just didn’t like his vibe. Whatever the reason, killing Yura before completing his questline has significant consequences.

The immediate effect is, of course, his death. However, this drastically alters the trajectory of his storyline and impacts your ability to acquire certain items and experience specific narrative elements. Primarily, killing Yura early prevents you from obtaining his Ronin’s Armor set through the intended method. This armor set becomes available later in the game when Yura’s body is possessed by Shabriri, who resides in the Mountaintops of the Giants. Defeating Shabriri in Yura’s body grants you the armor.

Furthermore, by killing Yura early, you miss out on key dialogue and interactions that shed light on certain aspects of the game’s lore, including potential hints toward a specific ending. You also forfeit the opportunity to acquire Eleonora’s Poleblade, a powerful weapon with bleed build-up, obtained by assisting Yura later in his questline. While you can obtain the Nagakiba immediately by killing him, you trade immediate gratification for long-term benefits and a richer narrative experience. Therefore, understanding the full scope of Yura’s quest and the implications of killing him early is crucial for making informed decisions within your Elden Ring playthrough.

Yura’s Questline: A Missed Opportunity?

Yura’s quest is more than just a fetch-quest; it’s a journey that reveals snippets of the game’s deeper lore. By choosing to cut it short, you are closing the door on a string of interactions and rewards that contribute to a more holistic understanding of the game.

Nagakiba: Instant Gratification vs. Long-Term Gain

While killing Yura grants you the Nagakiba katana early, this is arguably the lesser reward compared to what awaits those who follow the questline.

The Power of Eleonora’s Poleblade

Completing Yura’s quest rewards you with Eleonora’s Poleblade, a weapon often considered superior to the Nagakiba due to its unique moveset and powerful bleed-inducing capabilities.

Consequences Beyond Items: Lore and Narrative

Beyond the tangible rewards, Yura’s quest offers glimpses into the broader narrative of the game. Killing him early means you will not experience these crucial interactions.

The Importance of Ronin’s Armor

The Ronin’s Armor set isn’t just for cosmetic purposes. It’s a symbol of Yura’s character and his dedication to fighting the bloody fingers. Obtaining it through the proper questline completion adds a layer of significance that is lost when Yura is killed prematurely.

FAQs: Unpacking the Details of Yura’s Fate

Here are some frequently asked questions to further clarify the implications of your actions:

Can I still get the Ronin armor if I killed Yura early?

Unfortunately, no. Killing Yura early prevents you from acquiring the Ronin’s Armor through the intended questline method. You can only get it by allowing the quest to progress to the point where Shabriri inhabits Yura’s body in the Mountaintops of the Giants, then defeating him.

Can I get Nagakiba after killing Yura?

Yes, you can obtain the Nagakiba by killing Yura. He drops it immediately upon defeat. However, this short-circuits his questline and forfeits other potential rewards.

Is Yura’s questline important?

Yes, Yura’s questline is important for those seeking a deeper understanding of the lore, unique items like Eleonora’s Poleblade, and the Ronin’s Armor set. It also provides hints toward specific endings.

Why was Yura “killed” by Eleonora?

Yura was killed by Eleonora because he was deemed to be a threat to her kind. In actuality, he was already near death. Eleonora’s presence simply brought about his demise, which allowed Shabriri to possess his body.

Is there a downside to killing Yura?

Yes, the primary downside is the loss of his questline rewards, specifically the Ronin’s Armor and Eleonora’s Poleblade. You also miss out on crucial lore and narrative elements.

Is it worth killing Yura for the Nagakiba early?

Generally, no. While killing Yura grants the Nagakiba immediately, the long-term rewards of completing his questline are far greater.

Is it worth killing Yura early if I don’t care about the questline?

Even if you don’t care about the questline, killing Yura early is generally not recommended. Eleonora’s Poleblade is a significantly stronger weapon than Nagakiba. You would be better off just completing the questline in that scenario.

What does Yura’s questline give you besides the Nagakiba?

Yura’s questline rewards you with Eleonora’s Poleblade, and allows you to acquire the Ronin’s Armor set later in the game.

Can I get Raptor of the Mists without Yura?

No, the Raptor of the Mists Ash of War is only available by progressing Yura’s questline and helping him defeat an assassin.

Do you have to kill the dragon for Yura?

No, you do not need to kill the dragon in Agheel Lake to continue Yura’s questline. Talking to him about the dragon is sufficient.

What weapons does Bloody Finger Okina have?

Bloody Finger Okina wields the Rivers of Blood katana and the Wakizashi in his off-hand.

Why was Yura possessed by Shabriri?

According to Shabriri, Yura gave him his body. The exact circumstances are unclear, but it seems Yura’s spirit was weak or willing enough to allow the possession to occur.

Which NPCs are worth killing in Elden Ring?

This is a subjective question that depends on your playstyle. Some NPCs drop unique items upon death, but killing them can also lock you out of quests and storylines. Some examples are provided below.

Does killing NPCs in Elden Ring matter?

Yes, killing NPCs can have significant consequences, including locking you out of quests, preventing you from obtaining certain items, and altering the game’s narrative.

What katana to pair with Rivers of Blood?

The Nagakiba is a strong choice to pair with the Rivers of Blood if you are looking for a long reach, or the Uchigatana if you don’t want to put points into strength.

Final Thoughts

Killing Yura is a decision that should be considered carefully. While the immediate acquisition of the Nagakiba might seem appealing, the long-term consequences and missed opportunities are significant. For those who value lore, unique items, and a well-rounded narrative experience, completing Yura’s questline is undoubtedly the better option. Ultimately, the choice is yours, Tarnished. But, with the knowledge presented here, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your individual playstyle and goals in Elden Ring.

For more insights into the educational power of games, visit the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.