What Happens When Arthur Morgan Packs on the Pounds in Red Dead Redemption 2?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
If Arthur Morgan, the protagonist of Red Dead Redemption 2, becomes overweight, the most noticeable effect is a significant reduction in his stamina. This means he’ll tire much faster when running, engaging in combat, or performing other strenuous activities. While a heftier Arthur can absorb more damage, the decrease in stamina can severely impact his mobility and overall effectiveness in various scenarios. Managing Arthur’s weight is a subtle but crucial aspect of gameplay, requiring players to balance calorie intake with physical exertion to achieve the desired physique.
The Chunky Cowboy: A Deep Dive into Arthur’s Weight System
Red Dead Redemption 2 boasts a level of detail rarely seen in open-world games, and the implementation of a dynamic weight system for Arthur Morgan is a testament to this dedication. Unlike purely cosmetic changes, Arthur’s weight directly impacts his stats and performance. Gaining weight isn’t just about seeing a broader Arthur; it’s about making strategic decisions that affect how you play the game.
The Mechanics of Weight Gain
Making Arthur overweight is surprisingly easy. The key is simple: eat a lot, and rest. Consuming copious amounts of food, especially high-calorie meals like cooked big game meat, and then immediately resting (using the “kneel” option, holding triangle/Y) to digest the food is the most effective method. Essentially, you’re maximizing calorie intake while minimizing calorie expenditure.
The game operates on a weight scale, ranging from underweight to overweight, with “perfect” in the middle. Your goal when packing on the pounds is to get Arthur’s status to read as “overweight” when checking his stats.
The Price of Extra Padding: Stamina Takes a Hit
The primary downside of an overweight Arthur is a substantial decrease in stamina. Arthur will tire faster when sprinting, swimming, or engaging in hand-to-hand combat. This can be particularly detrimental during chase sequences, hunting expeditions, or intense gunfights where prolonged stamina is crucial. It’s important to note that even horse stamina will be affected because Arthur’s size impacts the riding process and stamina usage.
Imagine trying to escape a pursuing posse, only to have Arthur gasping for breath after a short sprint. Or struggling to land the final blow on a grizzly bear because you’re too winded to keep your guard up. These are the kinds of situations where an overweight Arthur can prove to be a liability.
The Silver Lining: Increased Damage Resistance
There is, however, a trade-off. An overweight Arthur can withstand more damage. He becomes a tank, capable of absorbing more bullets and blows before succumbing to injury. This can be advantageous in certain combat situations, particularly if you prefer a more aggressive, head-on approach.
Think of it as a classic tank build. You sacrifice mobility and agility for increased survivability. Whether this trade-off is worthwhile depends entirely on your playstyle.
Strategic Considerations: When is Overweight Arthur a Good Idea?
While generally not optimal for all-around gameplay, an overweight Arthur can be strategically advantageous in specific scenarios.
- Story Missions: If an upcoming mission is known to involve heavy combat and less focus on stealth or agility, bulking up Arthur beforehand could increase his chances of survival.
- Brawling: In fistfights, the extra health can give you a significant edge.
- Hunting Predatory Animals: The increased damage resistance allows you to take more risks when hunting dangerous creatures like bears and cougars.
Ultimately, the decision to make Arthur overweight is a matter of personal preference and strategic planning. Experiment with different weight levels to find what works best for your playstyle and the challenges you face in the game.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Arthur’s Weight in RDR2
Here are some frequently asked questions about Arthur Morgan’s weight and its effects in Red Dead Redemption 2:
1. How do I get Arthur Morgan to gain weight quickly?
The fastest way to make Arthur overweight is to repeatedly eat high-calorie foods and immediately rest. Cooked big game meat is an excellent choice, as it provides a significant calorie boost. The kneel rest option (holding triangle/Y) is the quickest way to trigger digestion and promote weight gain.
2. How do I get Arthur to lose weight?
Simply eat less. Focus on keeping his cores (health, stamina, and Dead Eye) filled, but avoid overeating. Engaging in physical activities like running and jumping will also accelerate weight loss.
3. Will Arthur always be underweight because of tuberculosis?
Yes. As Arthur’s tuberculosis progresses, he will find it increasingly difficult to maintain his weight, regardless of how much he eats. This is a subtle but impactful way the game portrays the effects of his illness.
4. What is the most fattening food in Red Dead Redemption 2?
Cooked big game meat is the most calorie-dense food in the game, providing 10 calories per serving. Pearson’s stew can also offer 10 calories depending on the ingredients donated.
5. Does running make you lose weight in RDR2?
Yes, engaging in physical activities like running, jumping, swimming, and fighting will cause Arthur to burn calories and lose weight.
6. What happens if Arthur gets fat?
An overweight Arthur will have reduced stamina but increased health. He’ll tire more quickly but can withstand more damage.
7. How often should Arthur eat in RDR2?
To maintain a “perfect” weight, aim to eat two or three times a day. Pay attention to his cores and consume food as they deplete, but avoid overfilling them consistently.
8. How does Arthur’s weight affect gameplay?
Arthur’s weight directly impacts his stamina and health. Higher weight means more health and less stamina, while lower weight means less health and more stamina.
9. Can you overeat in RDR2?
Yes, consuming excessive calories will cause Arthur to gain weight. The game explicitly warns players about this early on.
10. How do you keep Arthur at a perfect weight?
Maintain a perfect weight by eating moderate amounts regularly and engaging in a balanced amount of physical activity. Keep an eye on his cores and only eat when they need replenishing, avoiding constant snacking. Fast traveling from camp can also affect your weight, so eat prior to doing so.
11. Does donating food to Pearson affect Arthur’s weight?
Donating big game meat to Pearson will not directly affect Arthur’s weight. The meat is used for the camp stew, which can, when consumed by Arthur, affect his weight, depending on its calorie count.
12. Is it better to be underweight, average weight, or overweight?
This depends on your play style. An underweight Arthur has more stamina but less health, ideal for stealth and agility-focused players. An overweight Arthur has more health but less stamina, suitable for tank builds. An average weight Arthur provides a balance of both.
13. Can Arthur go shirtless in the game?
Yes, you can make Arthur shirtless by going to a store and only purchasing shoes. You’ll then need to equip pants separately. This will create a glitch where the torso is bare.
14. Is John Marston skinnier than Arthur Morgan?
Yes, John Marston has a comparatively smaller stature than Arthur Morgan.
15. Are there any glitches associated with Arthur’s weight?
While there aren’t specific glitches tied directly to weight, graphical glitches sometimes occur when Arthur’s character model is drastically altered, such as clothing clipping or disappearing. Exploring the game and its mechanics can be a rewarding experience, with some players even contributing to academic understanding. For more insights on game-based learning, you can visit the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.