Should You Turn In Sebastian Sallow in Hogwarts Legacy? A Deep Dive
The choice of whether or not to turn in Sebastian Sallow in Hogwarts Legacy is one of the most morally complex and gameplay-altering decisions you’ll face. There’s no easy answer, as it hinges on your personal roleplaying preferences, your desire to learn all the spells, and your tolerance for the darker side of magic. Generally, if you prioritize experiencing all content the game has to offer, including learning the Unforgivable Curses, you should NOT turn Sebastian in. However, if you believe he deserves punishment for his actions and are willing to sacrifice the opportunity to learn those spells, then turning him in might be the choice for you. The decision has significant ramifications, permanently altering your game experience. Let’s delve deeper.
The Weight of Choice: Sebastian’s Fate and Your Consequences
The decision point arrives after the tragic climax of Sebastian’s questline: the death of his uncle, Solomon Sallow. This event throws your character into a moral quandary: do you report Sebastian’s crime to the authorities, leading to his expulsion and potential imprisonment? Or do you protect him, allowing him to continue his studies (albeit in a diminished capacity) and potentially offering you further instruction in the Dark Arts?
The immediate consequence of turning Sebastian in is his removal from the game. You will lose all further interaction with him, including the opportunity to complete his remaining side quests and, crucially, to learn the Avada Kedavra curse if you haven’t already. He will be expelled from Hogwarts and absent from the game’s epilogue, effectively severing that narrative thread.
Conversely, choosing not to turn him in allows Sebastian to remain at Hogwarts, though his presence is significantly reduced. More importantly, it preserves the opportunity to learn Imperio and Avada Kedavra if you haven’t already learned them during his questline. This option caters to players aiming for complete spell collection and a full exploration of the game’s mechanics.
It’s crucial to understand that the decision has NO impact on the main storyline’s ending itself. Regardless of your choice regarding Sebastian, you’ll experience the same final events. The decision only affects Sebastian’s storyline and, by extension, your ability to access certain Dark Arts spells.
Understanding the Morality of Sebastian’s Actions
Sebastian’s path is fraught with peril and ethical ambiguity. He is driven by a desire to cure his sister Anne’s affliction, a noble intention that gradually becomes twisted by his increasing reliance on Dark Arts. The Games Learning Society often discusses the ethical implications of choices in games, and Sebastian’s storyline presents a perfect example of such a dilemma. The constant use of dark arts and his thirst for knowledge leads to some irredeemable actions, notably the killing of his uncle.
His actions raise crucial questions about the ends justifying the means, the corrupting influence of power, and the responsibility one bears when wielding dangerous magic. Turning him in can be seen as an act of justice, holding him accountable for his crimes and preventing further harm. It aligns with a more morally upright playthrough.
On the other hand, protecting him can be interpreted as an act of compassion, acknowledging his initial good intentions and potentially hoping for his redemption. It also allows you to explore the full breadth of the game’s spellbook, embracing the darker side of magic that Hogwarts Legacy offers.
Making the Right Choice for YOUR Playthrough
Ultimately, the decision rests on your personal preferences and roleplaying style. Here are some questions to consider:
- What kind of character are you playing? Are you a staunch upholder of the law, or are you more lenient and forgiving?
- How important is it to you to learn all the spells? Are you a completionist who wants to experience every aspect of the game?
- How do you feel about the Unforgivable Curses? Are you comfortable using them, or do you find them morally reprehensible?
- What is your opinion of Sebastian’s actions? Do you believe he is fundamentally good, or has he crossed a line?
Answering these questions will help you align your decision with your character’s values and your gameplay goals.
FAQ: Addressing Your Burning Questions About Sebastian
Here are some frequently asked questions (FAQs) regarding Sebastian Sallow and the consequences of your choices:
1. Can you get Avada Kedavra if you turn Sebastian in?
No. Turning Sebastian in prevents you from learning Avada Kedavra unless you learned it before turning him in. He is the only character in the game who can teach you this spell.
2. What happens if I side with Sebastian?
Siding with Sebastian by choosing not to turn him in allows you to continue learning Dark Arts spells from him, including Imperio and potentially Avada Kedavra. It also allows you to complete the rest of his side quests.
3. Is there a good ending for Sebastian in Hogwarts Legacy?
While there is no definitive “good ending” that completely redeems Sebastian, the ending where you don’t turn him in and potentially influence him towards some introspection and learning is arguably the less bad of the available options. His story remains tragic, but you maintain a connection with him.
4. What happens if you say no one should know that curse to Sebastian?
Saying “no one should know that curse” to Sebastian regarding Avada Kedavra initially delays the learning of the spell, but you can still learn it later if you do not turn him in. You can revisit him in the Undercroft and ask him to teach you.
5. Is there a way to avoid Sebastian killing his uncle?
No. Sebastian will always kill his uncle Solomon regardless of your choices. This is a fixed event in his storyline. The only choice you have is whether or not to turn him in afterward.
6. What happens if you betray Sebastian?
Betraying Sebastian by turning him in results in his expulsion from Hogwarts, and you will lose all further interaction with him in the game. You will be unable to complete his side quests or learn any more spells from him.
7. Is it okay to trust Sebastian in Hogwarts Legacy?
Trusting Sebastian is a complex issue. He has good intentions but is easily swayed by the lure of the Dark Arts. Whether or not you trust him depends on your own judgment and how you interpret his actions. There’s no clearly “right” answer.
8. Can you marry Sebastian in Hogwarts Legacy?
No. Hogwarts Legacy does not feature any romance options, including the ability to marry Sebastian.
9. Does turning in Sebastian make a difference to the ending?
Turning in Sebastian does not impact the ending, but it does have consequences. It has big consequences in Hogwarts Legacy because he won’t be available in quests at the end of the game and won’t be in the epilogue.
10. Does Sebastian turn evil?
Sebastian does not become purely evil, but he is deeply changed by his experiences and his use of the Dark Arts. He becomes more ruthless and justifies his actions, even when they are morally questionable.
11. Should Sebastian leave the Relic?
Regardless of the dialogue options, Sebastian will always take the Relic. Your choices do not affect this outcome.
12. Can you learn Avada Kedavra after rejecting Sebastian?
Yes, you can learn Avada Kedavra after initially rejecting Sebastian’s offer to teach it to you. As long as you do not turn him in, you can later revisit him in the Undercroft and ask him to teach it to you.
13. Should I tell Ominis about Sebastian?
Preferably, it’s better to tell Ominis since he’s actually standing in the room and will make his presence known once Sebastian finishes talking. However, in the long-run it doesn’t really matter what you choose.
14. Does Anne forgive Sebastian?
Anne leaves a letter for Sebastian, stating that she left to have time to herself. While she states that she will always love him, she does express a uncertainty about whether she will forgive him for what he had done to their uncle and half-felt that he must face justice for his crimes.
15. What should I say to Sebastian after he kills his uncle?
Choosing to say “No one should know that curse” and NOT turning Sebastian in is the most beneficial outcome, as it allows for the player to later revisit and learn the spell, if that’s what they desire.
The Final Verdict
The choice of whether to turn in Sebastian Sallow is a deeply personal one, driven by your own moral compass and gameplay preferences. Understand the consequences, consider your character’s values, and choose the path that aligns with your desired Hogwarts Legacy experience. Remember, this is a game that, like the GamesLearningSociety.org believes, can offer insights and reflections on morality, ethics, and the complexities of human choices. Good luck, and may your choices lead to a fulfilling journey through the wizarding world.