Tracking Minthara: Where She Goes After Your Conversation in Baldur’s Gate 3

In the sprawling world of Baldur’s Gate 3, every choice has a consequence, and every conversation can set a new path in motion. One of the more morally ambiguous characters you encounter early on is Minthara, a Drow Paladin with a penchant for ruthless efficiency. Depending on your decisions, your interactions with her can drastically alter the fate of the Emerald Grove and its inhabitants. The question of where Minthara goes after you talk to her is crucial because it marks a pivotal turning point in your adventure.

The answer depends entirely on the context of your conversation:

• If you reveal the location of the Emerald Grove: After you share the Grove’s location (willingly or unwillingly through illithid mind-probing) to Minthara within the Shattered Sanctum, she leaves to gather her goblin army and prepare for the assault. She will lead the raid on the Druid Grove, resulting in its destruction and the massacre of the Tieflings and Druids residing there.

• If you betray her at the Grove: If you mislead her to the grove’s location and then betray her at the last moment after leading her to the Emerald Grove, you can start a fight between you and her goblin army. After you share the grove’s location, fast travel back there and take a long rest.

• If you choose not to reveal the Grove’s location or kill her/knock her out: She will stay within the Shattered Sanctum. You may continue to find her there until you make a decision or finish the Goblin Camp leader quest.

• If you recruit her: Upon siding with her, you can find her again in Act 2 at Moonrise Towers where she’ll be available to recruit into your party.

Knowing these different outcomes are essential for guiding your Baldur’s Gate 3 playthrough. Each conversation determines how the game unfolds.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Minthara

Recruiting Minthara

1. Who leaves if you recruit Minthara?

   If you actively assist in the goblin raid on the Druid Grove, both Wyll and Karlach will immediately leave your party. Their moral compasses point strongly against senseless violence and aiding evil forces. Choosing Minthara comes at the cost of these companions.

2. Is there a way to get Minthara without killing the Grove?

   Yes, but it involves a workaround. One strategy is to knock Minthara out before the raid and ensure that the other Goblin Camp leaders are defeated. Another tactic is to resolve the conflict between the druids and the tieflings so that they’re not pushed out of the grove. This sometimes allows her to appear at Moonrise Towers in Act 2 where you can later recruit her. In early patches, stealing the idol of Silvanus from the Emerald Grove, without directly participating in the massacre, was also a means to progress her recruitment, but its effectiveness is variable based on game updates.

3. What happens if you knock Minthara out?

   If you knock Minthara out (make sure it’s non-lethal damage) and kill the other Goblin Camp leaders, the game will often treat this as a victory. However, Minthara will still be alive and, after a Long Rest, will wake up in the same spot where you knocked her out. This is one of the requirements for recruiting her later.

4. Can you recruit Minthara without being evil?

   Yes, it’s possible, although it requires specific actions and often hinges on exploiting game mechanics. The “Knockout Method” mentioned above is a popular tactic. A more convoluted approach involves manipulating the Tiefling-Druid conflict without directly participating in the slaughter, allowing events to unfold that lead to Minthara’s later appearance and recruitment in Act 2. The requirements can be a bit tricky and depend on the game version.

5. Is there a way to get Minthara without killing the Tieflings?

   Yes, that is to resolve the conflict between the druids and the tieflings. Therefore, they’re not pushed out of the grove. When you report back to Minthara, then she will start the raid.

Minthara’s Interactions and Romance

6. Can you romance Minthara without raiding the Grove?

   Yes, it is possible. As long as she is recruited through non-violent methods, then you may have the Minthara romance even if you don’t kill the grove.

7. Can you betray Minthara at the Grove?

   Yes, you can betray Minthara after leading her to the Emerald Grove. After revealing the Grove’s location, quickly travel back, take a long rest, and prepare for a battle. This triggers a fight where you can defend the Grove against her forces.

8. How to sleep with Minthara?

   To initiate a romance scene with Minthara, you must first recruit her. Find her near the center of your camp and start a conversation. Be receptive to her advances and express your interest. She’ll offer to join you when you go to bed. Interact with a bedroll and you’ll have a choice of going to bed alone or with Minthara. Note that specific dialogue choices and high approval are often necessary.

9. Can you romance Minthara and Shadowheart?

   Yes, it is possible to romance both Minthara and Shadowheart, but timing is crucial. You can start a romance with Shadowheart even after an intimate night with Minthara. It’s recommended to build a strong rapport with Shadowheart before the Grove raid.

10. How to romance Minthara after saving her?

    After saving Minthara from Moonrise Towers, you must speak with her to unlock the romance scene. You’ll need to choose these options for the scene to begin: First choice: Yes, I’m yours, Minthara. Second choice: Do as she says.

Consequences of Recruiting Minthara

11. Is it worth recruiting Minthara?

    At the game’s release, bugs often plagued Minthara’s dialogue and interactions, making her a less compelling companion. However, patches have addressed many of these issues. Whether it’s “worth it” depends on your playstyle and priorities. If you’re roleplaying an evil or morally flexible character, Minthara can be a fascinating and powerful ally. But be prepared to sacrifice other potential companions and make choices that have significant consequences. You may learn more at Games Learning Society.

12. Can you be good and still recruit Minthara?

    As mentioned earlier, there are convoluted methods that allow you to recruit Minthara without directly participating in the massacre of the Grove’s inhabitants. These approaches often involve exploiting game mechanics or allowing events to unfold without your direct involvement. However, even with these methods, the consequences of your actions may still be ethically questionable.

Companionship Dynamics

13. Can I recruit Minthara and Halsin?

    Normally, you can either get Minthara or Halsin as your BG3 companions – but not both. If you choose to destroy Emerald Grove and facilitate the Tiefling refugees’ murders, Halsin, head druid of said grove, naturally refuses to join you. However, the method of getting Minthara via the knocking out/non-lethal method allows Halsin to stay.

14. Can you recruit Minthara and Jaheira?

    Yes, you can recruit both Jaheira and Minsc with her. They’re dependent on your choice about the Nightsong in Act 2, nothing to do with Act 1 choice.

15. Can I have Minthara and Karlach?

    You can still recruit Minthara without losing Wyll and Karlach if you simply skip the entire goblin grove raid quest and head straight for moonrise towers. It’s an option the game gives you and causes events to progress without you. You can trigger Karlach and Minthara banter in this case, allowing you to have both.

Conclusion

The path you choose in Baldur’s Gate 3, especially regarding Minthara, has far-reaching consequences. Deciding where Minthara goes after you talk to her is a decision that echoes throughout your entire playthrough. Weigh the options carefully, consider the moral implications, and choose the path that best suits your desired narrative. Understanding the intricate details of recruiting and interacting with Minthara, as well as the potential consequences, will enhance your overall Baldur’s Gate 3 experience.

You can further enhance your gaming experience by studying the deeper elements of games at GamesLearningSociety.org.