Table of Contents

Are Square Shinies More Rare? Unveiling the Sparkling Truth

Yes, square shinies are generally considered more rare than star shinies in Pokémon Sword and Pokémon Shield, but the circumstances surrounding their rarity are quite nuanced and depend on the method of encounter. Understanding the probabilities and mechanics behind shiny generation is key to appreciating the true rarity of these coveted Pokémon. Let’s dive deep into the world of shiny hunting to understand why!

Decoding Shiny Sparkles: Star vs. Square

Before we delve into the rarity, let’s first clarify what we’re talking about. In Pokémon Sword and Pokémon Shield, shiny Pokémon aren’t just defined by their altered color palettes. They also feature a unique sparkle animation when they enter battle. There are two types of sparkle animations:

Star Shinies: These have the classic, traditional star-shaped sparkles that most players are familiar with.
Square Shinies (also known as Ultra Shinies or Shattered Shinies): These feature smaller, square-shaped sparkles, giving them a distinct and often more sought-after appearance.

The core difference lies solely in the visual effect; the Pokémon’s stats, abilities, and move sets remain unaffected by the type of shiny sparkle it possesses. However, the rarity attached to each type of sparkle has made square shinies a popular subject within the Pokémon community.

The Encounter Method Matters: Untangling the Odds

The key to understanding the rarity of square shinies lies in how you encounter the Pokémon. The game mechanics are different for wild encounters versus static encounters (like Legendaries) or breeding (Masuda Method).

Wild Encounters: Square Shinies Reign Supreme

For Pokémon encountered in the wild, the default odds are heavily skewed towards square shinies. Dataminers discovered that a staggering 15 out of 16 shiny Pokémon encountered in the wild will exhibit the square sparkle animation. This translates to a roughly 93.75% chance of encountering a square shiny and only a 6.25% chance of finding a star shiny in this scenario.

Therefore, if you’re running around in the Wild Area hoping for a sparkle, you’re far more likely to stumble upon a square shiny.

Static Encounters and Breeding: Star Shinies Take the Lead

Conversely, the odds are reversed for static encounters (like the legendary Pokémon in specific locations) and when breeding using the Masuda Method (breeding Pokémon from different language regions to improve shiny odds). In these instances, a shiny Pokémon will have a 1/16 chance of being a square shiny. This means that the odds heavily favor star shinies (15/16 or 93.75%) in these cases.

This significant difference in shiny animation distribution has led to the perception that square shinies are far rarer for those primarily focused on static encounters or breeding.

Full Odds Square Shinies: The “Impossible” Scenario

The “1 in 65,536” statistic often thrown around refers to a very specific and unlikely situation: encountering a square shiny at full odds in the wild. Let’s break this down:

Full Odds: This means encountering a shiny Pokémon without any modifiers like the Shiny Charm or increased encounter rates from events. The standard shiny odds in Sword and Shield are 1/4096.
Square Shiny: In a wild encounter, the chance of that shiny being a square shiny is 15/16.

However, many players want to know the odds of a Square Shiny, at full odds, and specifically through random encounter. To find the odds for this scenario, we perform this calculation: (1/4096) x (1/16) = 1/65,536. So, in this sense, a Square Shiny is the more rare version.

Therefore, without modifiers, finding a random encounter square shiny is exceptionally rare, leading some to playfully call it “impossible.”

Conclusion: Perspective is Key

Ultimately, whether square shinies are truly “more rare” depends entirely on how you’re hunting for shinies. If you exclusively breed or target static encounters, star shinies are statistically rarer. However, for those who enjoy exploring the Wild Area and engaging in random encounters, square shinies are considerably more common. The terminology used to describe them is, in essence, entirely dependent on the hunting method.

Regardless of the rarity, both star and square shinies are beautiful, unique additions to any Pokémon collection, and the thrill of the hunt remains the same! Understanding shiny mechanics offers a deeper appreciation for the game and adds an extra layer of enjoyment to the experience.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Square Shinies

1. What exactly is a “shiny” Pokémon?

A shiny Pokémon is a Pokémon that has a different color palette than its normal counterpart. It is also accompanied by a sparkling animation when it enters battle. These are purely cosmetic differences and do not affect the Pokémon’s stats or abilities.

2. How do you increase your chances of finding a shiny Pokémon?

Several methods can increase your shiny odds:

Shiny Charm: Obtainable in the game after completing the Pokédex, the Shiny Charm significantly boosts your chances of encountering shiny Pokémon.
Masuda Method: Breeding Pokémon from different language regions increases the odds of hatching a shiny Pokémon.
Chain Fishing/Catching: Some older Pokémon games had chaining mechanics that increased shiny odds the longer you maintained a chain of encountering the same Pokémon. This mechanic is not in the game.
Outbreaks (Later Games): Pokémon Legends: Arceus and Scarlet/Violet introduced outbreaks, mass outbreaks of specific Pokémon, which significantly increase shiny odds.

3. Does the Shiny Charm affect square shiny odds?

Yes, the Shiny Charm affects the base shiny odds, but it doesn’t change the 1/16 or 15/16 distribution between star and square shinies. It only makes shiny Pokémon, in general, more likely to appear.

4. Are square shinies more valuable in trades?

In general, square shinies are often considered more valuable in trades, especially if they were obtained through methods where they are statistically rarer (static encounters or breeding). However, value is subjective and depends on the preferences of the traders involved.

5. Can you tell if a Pokémon is shiny before encountering it in the overworld?

In Pokémon Sword and Shield, you cannot see if a Pokémon is shiny in the overworld before initiating a battle. This means you must engage in the encounter to determine if the Pokémon is shiny. Games like Pokémon Legends: Arceus show shiny Pokémon in the overworld, making shiny hunting significantly easier.

6. Does the ability “Cute Charm” affect shiny odds?

The ability Cute Charm does not affect shiny odds. Cute Charm increases the likelihood of encountering Pokémon of the opposite gender in the wild.

7. What is the Masuda Method, and how does it affect shiny hunting?

The Masuda Method involves breeding two Pokémon that originate from games of different language regions (e.g., a Pokémon from an English game and a Pokémon from a Japanese game). This significantly increases the odds of hatching a shiny Pokémon. Also, in these conditions, odds are heavily weighted for a “Star Shiny” rather than the alternative.

8. Are there any Pokémon that cannot be shiny in Sword and Shield?

Yes, some Pokémon are shiny-locked, meaning they cannot be obtained as shiny through any legitimate means. Often these are Pokémon central to the plot.

9. What is the difference between a “full odds” shiny and a shiny obtained with the Shiny Charm?

A “full odds” shiny refers to a shiny Pokémon encountered without any modifiers that increase the shiny rate. In Sword and Shield, the full odds shiny rate is 1/4096. A shiny obtained with the Shiny Charm has a significantly improved shiny rate, making it easier to find.

10. Do Pokémon dens (Raid Battles) affect shiny types (star/square)?

Yes, the Pokémon that appear in Pokémon Dens (Raid Battles) are subject to the same shiny mechanics as other encounters. This means the shiny type (star or square) will be determined by the game’s random number generator.

11. What is the rarest shiny Pokémon overall?

Determining the “rarest” shiny is subjective and depends on various factors, including encounter method, game version, and event availability. However, generally, shiny Pokémon obtained through challenging methods at full odds are considered among the rarest. For specific games like Pokémon GO, event-exclusive shiny Pokémon are often considered especially rare.

12. Does trading a shiny Pokémon change its sparkle animation?

No, trading a shiny Pokémon does not change its sparkle animation. The shiny type (star or square) is determined at the time of generation and remains fixed.

13. How does the Pokémon Home app interact with shiny Pokémon?

Pokémon Home is a cloud-based service for storing Pokémon. Shiny Pokémon stored in Pokémon Home retain their shiny status and sparkle animation. You can transfer shiny Pokémon between compatible games through Pokémon Home.

14. Are Lucky Pokémon and shiny Pokémon related?

In Pokémon GO, Lucky Pokémon and shiny Pokémon are distinct features. A Lucky Pokémon is more likely to have high IVs (Individual Values) and requires less Stardust to power up. While a Pokémon can be both lucky and shiny, the two are not directly related.

15. Where can I learn more about the underlying mechanics of Pokémon games?

For comprehensive information on Pokémon game mechanics, advanced strategies, and insights into game design, consider exploring resources offered by educational organizations, such as the Games Learning Society through GamesLearningSociety.org. These resources may provide additional context on the complexities of game development and the intricacies of Pokémon game mechanics.

Are square Shinies more rare?