Table of Contents

Are the Stormcloaks or Imperials Evil? A Deep Dive into Skyrim’s Moral Ambiguity

The question of whether the Stormcloaks or the Imperials are evil in The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim is complex, and the most accurate answer is: neither side is inherently evil. The conflict is rooted in a clash of ideologies, cultural preservation versus imperial stability, and ultimately, shades of gray that make choosing a side a deeply personal decision. Both factions exhibit morally questionable behavior, driven by their respective goals and the pressures of war. Understanding their motivations and actions requires a nuanced examination of the political landscape of Skyrim and the Empire.

Understanding the Conflict

The core of the conflict stems from the White-Gold Concordat, a treaty signed between the Empire and the Aldmeri Dominion (the ruling power of the High Elves, or Thalmor) after the Great War. This treaty outlawed the worship of Talos, a human ascended to godhood and a central figure in Nord religion.

The Empire: Argues that the Concordat was a necessary evil to prevent the complete destruction of the Empire by the Aldmeri Dominion. They prioritize stability, law, and order, believing that the Empire provides the best chance for the survival of mankind against the Thalmor.
The Stormcloaks: See the ban on Talos worship as an unacceptable infringement on their religious freedom and cultural identity. Led by Ulfric Stormcloak, they rebel against the Empire, seeking to restore Skyrim’s independence and the right to worship Talos freely.

Examining the Morality of Each Faction

The Imperial Legion: Law and Order at a Cost?

The Imperial Legion represents the established power structure. Their strength lies in their organization, resources, and the promise of a unified front against external threats like the Thalmor. However, their adherence to the White-Gold Concordat and their perceived subservience to the Aldmeri Dominion are significant moral drawbacks.

Pros:
- Represents stability and order, potentially preventing further bloodshed and chaos.
- Provides a structured legal system and infrastructure.
- Offers a united front against the Thalmor threat in the long run.
Cons:
- Enforces the ban on Talos worship, directly oppressing Nord religious freedom.
- Is perceived as being controlled by the Aldmeri Dominion, compromising Skyrim’s autonomy.
- Often uses heavy-handed tactics to maintain order, leading to civilian casualties and resentment.

The Stormcloaks: Freedom Fighters or Xenophobic Rebels?

The Stormcloaks champion the ideals of freedom and cultural preservation. They rally behind Ulfric Stormcloak, a charismatic leader who embodies Nord strength and tradition. However, their rebellion is marred by accusations of xenophobia and potentially destructive consequences for Skyrim.

Pros:
- Fights for religious freedom and cultural identity.
- Challenges the authority of the Aldmeri Dominion and its influence over the Empire.
- Seeks to restore Skyrim’s independence and self-determination.
Cons:
- Is accused of being xenophobic towards non-Nords, particularly Dunmer (Dark Elves) residing in Windhelm.
- Their rebellion weakens the Empire, potentially making it more vulnerable to the Aldmeri Dominion.
- Ulfric Stormcloak’s leadership is questioned, with some viewing him as an ambitious warlord rather than a selfless liberator.

Ulfric Stormcloak: Hero or Villain?

Ulfric Stormcloak’s character is a crucial point of contention. He is a powerful orator and warrior, inspiring many Nords to fight for his cause. However, his methods and motivations are often debated.

The Accusations: Ulfric is accused of murdering the High King Torygg in a duel, sparking the civil war. He is also criticized for his treatment of the Dunmer in Windhelm, where they live in a segregated and impoverished district known as the Grey Quarter.
His Defense: Ulfric claims that the duel with Torygg was legitimate under Nord tradition, and that he was challenging the High King’s authority, not committing murder. He also argues that he is focused on the war effort and that the problems in Windhelm are due to the Dunmer refugees flooding the city.
The Reality: Ulfric’s motivations are likely a mix of genuine concern for Skyrim and personal ambition. He believes in the Nord way of life and wants to protect it, but he also seeks to become High King himself.

The Thalmor’s Influence

A key factor often overlooked is the Thalmor’s involvement. They actively seek to destabilize the Empire and see the Stormcloak rebellion as an opportunity to weaken their enemies. The Thalmor dossier on Ulfric Stormcloak reveals that they consider him an asset, as his actions further divide the Empire. This manipulation adds another layer of moral complexity to the conflict.

Choosing a Side: A Matter of Perspective

Ultimately, choosing between the Stormcloaks and the Imperials in Skyrim is a matter of perspective and personal values. There is no definitively “right” or “wrong” choice.

Roleplaying Considerations: Your character’s background, beliefs, and motivations should influence your decision. A Nord who values tradition and religious freedom might naturally gravitate towards the Stormcloaks. An Imperial citizen who believes in order and stability might support the Legion.
Gameplay Impact: The choice of sides affects the storyline, the NPCs you interact with, and the control of various holds in Skyrim. However, it does not fundamentally alter the overall outcome of the game, as the main quest (defeating Alduin) remains the same regardless of your faction allegiance.
Moral Ambiguity: The game intentionally avoids presenting a clear-cut good versus evil scenario. This allows players to engage with the complexities of the conflict and make a decision based on their own understanding of the situation. The Games Learning Society can provide further insights into how video games present complex ethical dilemmas and encourage critical thinking.

The conflict between the Stormcloaks and the Imperials is a microcosm of real-world political struggles, where ideals clash and compromises are made. By examining the motivations, actions, and consequences of each faction, players can gain a deeper understanding of the moral ambiguities inherent in war and the difficult choices faced by leaders and individuals alike. Visit GamesLearningSociety.org to explore how games like Skyrim can be used to learn and engage with complex social issues.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Are the Stormcloaks racist?

While the Stormcloaks claim to fight for Skyrim’s freedom, their actions and rhetoric often suggest a bias against non-Nords. The treatment of Dunmer (Dark Elves) in Windhelm, where they live in impoverished conditions in the Grey Quarter, fuels these accusations. While not all Stormcloaks are overtly racist, the faction’s focus on Nord traditions and identity can create an environment where xenophobia is tolerated or even encouraged.

2. Are the Imperials puppets of the Thalmor?

The Imperials are not direct puppets of the Thalmor, but the White-Gold Concordat forces them to comply with certain demands, including the ban on Talos worship. This compliance is seen by many as a sign of weakness and subservience to the Aldmeri Dominion, leading to the perception that the Empire is no longer truly independent.

3. Does joining the Stormcloaks or Imperials affect the main quest?

No, joining the Stormcloaks or the Imperials does not significantly alter the main quest of defeating Alduin. The civil war questline runs parallel to the main quest, and regardless of which side you choose, you will still ultimately need to fulfill your destiny as the Dragonborn and save the world.

4. Can I switch sides after joining the Stormcloaks or Imperials?

Yes, but only during a specific point in the questline. During the quest to retrieve the Jagged Crown, you have the option to betray your chosen faction by delivering the crown to the opposing side. This is the only point in the game where you can officially switch allegiances.

5. What happens if the Stormcloaks win the war?

If the Stormcloaks win the war, Skyrim gains its independence from the Empire. Ulfric Stormcloak will likely become the High King, and the worship of Talos will be openly practiced once again. However, this victory comes at the cost of a weakened Empire, potentially making it more vulnerable to the Aldmeri Dominion.

6. What happens if the Imperials win the war?

If the Imperials win the war, Skyrim remains a province of the Empire. The worship of Talos will continue to be suppressed, and the Empire will maintain its control over the region. This victory ensures stability and order, but it also perpetuates the oppressive terms of the White-Gold Concordat.

7. Is Ulfric Stormcloak a Dragonborn?

No, Ulfric Stormcloak is not a Dragonborn. He is a powerful warrior and skilled in the use of the Voice (shouts), but he does not possess the Dragonborn’s unique ability to absorb dragon souls.

8. What is the White-Gold Concordat?

The White-Gold Concordat is a treaty signed between the Empire and the Aldmeri Dominion after the Great War. It officially ended the war but imposed harsh terms on the Empire, including the disbandment of the Blades and the outlawing of Talos worship.

9. What are the Thalmor’s goals in Skyrim?

The Thalmor seek to destabilize the Empire and weaken its power. They see the Stormcloak rebellion as an opportunity to further divide the Empire and advance their own agenda. They are actively involved in manipulating events in Skyrim to achieve their goals.

10. Do the Stormcloaks hate all elves?

While the Stormcloaks are primarily focused on Nord traditions and culture, their actions often reflect a bias against elves, particularly the High Elves (Altmer) of the Aldmeri Dominion. The treatment of Dark Elves (Dunmer) in Windhelm is also evidence of this prejudice. However, it is important to note that not all Stormcloaks harbor hateful sentiments towards all elves.

11. Who was the High King before Ulfric killed him?

The High King before Ulfric killed him was Torygg. He ruled Skyrim from Solitude and was seen as a just and capable leader by many, even those who opposed the Empire. His death sparked the Skyrim Civil War.

12. Why do the Nords worship Talos?

Talos, also known as Tiber Septim, was the founder of the Third Empire and the first Emperor of Tamriel. He unified the continent and brought an era of peace and prosperity. After his death, he ascended to godhood and became a central figure in Nord religion, representing strength, courage, and human potential.

13. Can I become High King if I side with the Stormcloaks?

No, you cannot become High King if you side with the Stormcloaks. After the Stormcloaks win the war, Ulfric will most likely become the High King. The Dragonborn does not have a possibility to rule as High King or Queen.

14. Does siding with the Stormcloaks or Imperials make me a hero or villain?

Neither siding with the Stormcloaks or the Imperials makes you a hero or villain. Both factions have positive and negative aspects, and neither side has a monopoly on morality. The choice is ultimately up to the player and their character’s personal values.

15. How does the civil war in Skyrim relate to real-world conflicts?

The civil war in Skyrim can be seen as a reflection of real-world political conflicts involving issues of nationalism, religious freedom, cultural preservation, and the struggle for self-determination. It explores the complexities of war, the challenges of leadership, and the moral compromises that are often necessary in the face of conflict.

Are Stormcloaks or Imperials evil?