Table of Contents

Avoiding Keira Metz’s Demise in The Witcher 3: A Comprehensive Guide

Yes, you absolutely can avoid killing Keira Metz in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. In fact, orchestrating her survival is arguably the best outcome for several reasons, impacting the story, future quests, and even character interactions. Ensuring Keira’s survival involves making specific choices during her questline, primarily by persuading her to go to Kaer Morhen instead of seeking refuge with Radovid. This leads to a much more fulfilling conclusion to her story and provides valuable assistance later in the game.

How to Save Keira Metz: A Step-by-Step Guide

The questline that determines Keira’s fate is pivotal. Here’s how to navigate it for the best possible outcome:

Complete “Hunting a Witch”: This is the initial quest that introduces Geralt to Keira and her situation. Finish this quest to progress her story.
Complete “A Towerful of Mice”: During this quest, you’ll explore Fyke Isle with Keira. Regardless of whether you lift the curse on Anabelle, be respectful and understanding towards Keira. This lays the groundwork for a positive relationship.
The Key Decision: “An Invitation from Keira Metz”: This is the critical juncture. After completing “A Towerful of Mice,” Keira invites Geralt for dinner. You can choose to accept or decline her advances. It doesn’t significantly affect the outcome, but declining gracefully can improve the relationship in the long run.
The Plague Research: After dinner, Keira reveals her plan to present the plague research to King Radovid. This is where you need to intervene.
Persuade Her to Go to Kaer Morhen: During the dialogue, you must convince Keira that going to Radovid is a suicidal move. Highlight Radovid’s ruthlessness and his history of persecuting mages. The key is to present Kaer Morhen as a safer alternative where she can use her knowledge for good, potentially helping the Witchers. Geralt can say something along the lines of, “That’s suicide. There’s a better way: go to Kaer Morhen.“
Avoid the Fight: If you fail to persuade Keira, a fight will ensue. Avoid fighting her at all costs! Choose dialogue options that de-escalate the situation.
If You Fight Her and Win: Even if a fight starts, and you defeat her, you can still choose to spare her life during the post-battle dialogue. However, this situation is riskier and less ideal. Persuasion is always preferable.
Final Acceptance: If your persuasion is successful, Keira will agree to go to Kaer Morhen. This is the best possible outcome.

The Benefits of Saving Keira Metz

Kaer Morhen Support: Keira provides valuable assistance during the Battle of Kaer Morhen, using her magical abilities to aid in the defense against the Wild Hunt.
Saving Lambert: Perhaps the most significant benefit is Keira’s intervention in saving Lambert during the battle. If she’s present, she will automatically help him, ensuring his survival. Without her, Geralt must rush to Lambert’s aid, making the battle more challenging.
Cure for Catriona Plague: When you let her go to Kaer Morhen, she dedicates herself to finding a cure for the Catriona plague. This action is a testament to her growth and redemption.
Trader at Kaer Morhen: After the battle, Keira becomes a vendor at Kaer Morhen, offering useful items and crafting materials.
Improved Story Outcome: Saving Keira leads to a more satisfying narrative arc, showcasing the potential for redemption and highlighting the importance of second chances.

What Happens If You Fail?

Death at Radovid’s Hands: If you allow Keira to go to Radovid, she will be captured and burned at the stake. Her research will be in vain, and her potential will be tragically wasted.
Fighting and Killing Keira: If you choose to fight and kill her, you lose all the benefits mentioned above. You also miss out on a compelling character arc.
Failed Brothers in Arms Quest: As mentioned in the article, if Keira does not go to Kaer Morhen, the Brothers In Arms: Velen quest later will automatically fail.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Is it really necessary to kill Keira Metz to progress in the game?

No, it’s absolutely not necessary to kill Keira Metz. In fact, letting her live and sending her to Kaer Morhen is the optimal choice, unlocking numerous benefits and contributing to a more positive overall outcome.

2. What happens if I don’t persuade Keira and fight her instead?

If you fight Keira and win, you will have the choice to spare her life. However, even if you do spare her, the outcome isn’t as positive as if you had persuaded her from the beginning. You will miss out on some of her later contributions.

3. Can Lambert die if Keira isn’t at Kaer Morhen?

Yes, Lambert can die if Keira isn’t at Kaer Morhen. During the Battle of Kaer Morhen, he will be surrounded by enemies and need assistance. Keira’s presence guarantees his survival, but without her, Geralt must intervene, which can be challenging.

4. What are the consequences of letting Keira go to Radovid?

Letting Keira go to Radovid results in her horrific death by burning at the stake. Radovid, known for his ruthlessness towards mages, sees her as a threat despite her intentions, leading to a grim end.

5. Does Keira offer any benefits if she survives?

Yes, Keira provides numerous benefits if she survives and goes to Kaer Morhen. She aids in the defense of Kaer Morhen, potentially finds a cure for the Catriona plague, becomes a merchant, and plays a vital role in saving Lambert.

6. Can I romance Keira Metz? Does this affect the outcome?

You can have a brief romantic encounter with Keira during her questline. However, whether you accept or decline her advances doesn’t significantly impact her ultimate fate. The key is to persuade her to go to Kaer Morhen.

7. Is it possible to buy items from Keira after she arrives at Kaer Morhen?

Yes, after the Battle of Kaer Morhen, Keira becomes a merchant at Kaer Morhen, selling various useful items, including alchemy ingredients and crafting components.

8. Does Keira’s presence at Kaer Morhen affect the game’s ending?

While Keira’s presence doesn’t directly alter the main endings of The Witcher 3, her survival contributes to a more complete and positive overall narrative experience. Her aid in the Battle of Kaer Morhen and her dedication to finding a plague cure add depth to the story.

9. What happens if I miss Keira’s questline entirely?

If you miss Keira’s questline, she will eventually attempt to seek out Radovid on her own and meet her demise. You’ll find her impaled and burned. You also miss out on all the potential benefits she could have provided.

10. Does siding with Roche or Dijkstra influence Keira’s fate?

The political choices of siding with Roche or Dijkstra in the “Reason of State” quest do not directly influence Keira’s fate. Her destiny is primarily determined by your actions during her personal questline.

11. What’s the best dialogue option to convince Keira to go to Kaer Morhen?

The most effective dialogue options emphasize the danger of seeking Radovid’s help and highlight Kaer Morhen as a safe haven where she can use her knowledge to help others. Focus on appealing to her sense of reason and self-preservation.

12. How does Keira save Lambert during the Battle of Kaer Morhen?

During the battle, Lambert gets surrounded by Wild Hunt warriors. If Keira is present, she’ll use her magic to clear out the enemies, effectively saving Lambert’s life without Geralt’s direct intervention.

13. Can I go back and change my decision regarding Keira if I made the wrong choice?

Unfortunately, The Witcher 3 relies on choices having lasting consequences. If you’ve already made a decision that leads to Keira’s death, you cannot change it unless you reload a previous save. This reinforces the importance of carefully considering your options.

14. What are some of the items Keira sells at Kaer Morhen?

Keira sells a variety of alchemy ingredients, crafting materials, and other useful items. These can include rare herbs, monster parts, and even some valuable books and diagrams.

15. Where can I learn more about character choices and consequences in The Witcher 3?

For in-depth analysis of character choices, narrative design, and game mechanics in The Witcher 3 and other games, consider exploring resources like the Games Learning Society. You can find more information at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/.

Can I avoid killing Keira?