Can I Get Arthur’s Horses Back in Red Dead Redemption 2? A Comprehensive Guide
The heartbreaking reality for many Red Dead Redemption 2 players is the loss of Arthur Morgan and, with him, his beloved horses. The bond between a cowboy and his steed is central to the experience, making this loss particularly poignant. The short answer is a resounding no. When Arthur Morgan passes away, you cannot directly recover any of the horses that he owned, including the loyal Buell. They are irrevocably lost. This article dives into the nuances of this loss and explores what you can do as John Marston.
Understanding the Loss
It’s crucial to understand that the loss of Arthur’s horses isn’t a mere oversight by the developers; it’s a deliberate narrative choice. It underscores the finality of Arthur’s fate and the transition to John Marston’s perspective. Mechanically, this reset also encourages players to explore the world anew, discovering and bonding with fresh mounts that will be important to finishing the game. While you can’t reclaim Arthur’s specific companions, the world of Red Dead Redemption 2 is teeming with possibilities.
What Carries Over to John Marston?
While Arthur’s horses are gone, not all is lost. John inherits a substantial portion of Arthur’s progress. This includes:
- Weapons: All of Arthur’s firearms and melee weapons transfer to John.
- Outfits and Clothing: John will receive Arthur’s wardrobe, allowing you to dress John in Arthur’s iconic attire.
- Compendium Progress: Most of the information gathered in Arthur’s compendium will be available to John, though some specific to Arthur may be incomplete.
- Map Discovery: Areas of the map explored by Arthur will remain revealed for John.
- Crafting Recipes: Recipes learned by Arthur will be available for John to use.
- $20,000 After Epilogue: You will receive $20,000 at the end of the epilogue
Finding New Horses as John
Even without Arthur’s steeds, the game provides ample opportunities to acquire new horses. You can tame wild horses, purchase them from stables, or even encounter unique horses during random events. Keep an eye out for the following:
- Wild Arabians: The White Arabian, considered one of the best horses in the game, respawns at Lake Isabella after Arthur’s death. You can tame it again as John. There is also another Arabian northwest of Strawberry, though not a white Arabian
- Black Arabian: You can find a Black Arabian horse during a random event in Saint Denis. This horse is considered by many to be the best version of the Arabian.
- Rose Gray Bay Arabian: This can be purchased for $1,250 at the Blackwater Stable.
Utilizing Arthur’s Gear
While Arthur’s horses are lost, his saddle is not. You can retrieve Arthur’s saddle as John. This allows you to customize your new horses with a familiar and cherished item. This helps maintain a tangible link to Arthur’s journey.
FAQ: Frequently Asked Questions About Arthur’s Horses
Here are some frequently asked questions regarding the fate of Arthur’s horses and other related aspects after his death in Red Dead Redemption 2.
1. Can I somehow transfer Buell to John before Arthur dies?
Unfortunately, no. There’s no in-game mechanic to transfer ownership of Buell or any other horse from Arthur to John before Arthur’s demise.
2. What happens to Arthur’s stabled horses?
Any horses you have stabled as Arthur are also lost upon his death. This applies to all horses, regardless of their breed or bonding level.
3. Does the White Arabian horse respawn after Arthur dies?
Yes, the White Arabian horse does respawn at Lake Isabella after Arthur’s death. You’ll need to leave the area and return for it to reappear.
4. Can I get the White Arabian horse even after the epilogue?
Yes. You can acquire the White Arabian as John Marston even after completing the epilogue. The horse respawns indefinitely.
5. If I lose my horse, can I get it back?
If your current horse dies it is gone forever. You cannot get your horse back if it dies. However, if you lose it, try saving your game and reloading the save. Your horse should be next to you.
6. What happens to my horse if I die?
If you die in Red Dead Redemption 2 and respawn, your horse will usually reappear near you or at the nearest stable. However, there’s a chance it might be injured and require treatment.
7. Can John complete Arthur’s unfinished side quests?
Yes, mostly. John can complete most of Arthur’s Stranger Missions, with the notable exception of those directly related to Mary Linton due to narrative reasons.
8. Can I find Arthur’s grave as John?
Yes. You can visit Arthur’s grave, which is located on a mountain to the northeast of Bacchus Bridge. The epitaph on the grave will reflect your honor level as Arthur.
9. Does John inherit Arthur’s money?
John does not inherit all of Arthur’s money immediately. However, during the epilogue, John recovers a substantial sum from the Blackwater heist, effectively compensating for the loss.
10. Can I find Dutch’s hidden stash as John?
Yes. If you made the honorable choice near the end of the game, you can return to Beaver Hollow as John and find Dutch’s chest untouched under the wagon.
11. Can I keep Arthur’s guns as John?
Yes. John will automatically receive all of Arthur’s firearms and melee weapons early in the epilogue.
12. What’s the fastest horse I can get as John?
The Rose Gray Bay Arabian purchased at the Blackwater Stable for $1,250 is considered the fastest horse available to John.
13. Is it worth playing after the epilogue?
Absolutely! Red Dead Redemption 2 offers a vast open world with numerous activities and collectibles. The epilogue provides a compelling conclusion to the story and allows you to further explore the world as John Marston. It’s a way to keep on playing the game. You also gain a lot of money.
14. What happens if John’s horse dies?
If John’s horse dies, it’s permanently gone. You’ll need to acquire a new horse, either by purchasing one from a stable or taming one in the wild.
15. Will any of my camp upgrades as Arthur transfer to John?
No, you will not be able to keep any camp upgrades.
Embracing John’s Journey
While the loss of Arthur’s horses is undoubtedly a difficult aspect of Red Dead Redemption 2, it serves a crucial narrative purpose. By understanding what carries over to John and exploring the opportunities to acquire new horses, you can embrace John’s journey and continue to experience the rich and immersive world of the game. You can also check out the Games Learning Society for more gaming information at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/. Focus on the new experiences, and you’ll create memorable moments with new equine companions.