Table of Contents

Can I Sell Legendary Fish? A Stardew Valley Guide

Absolutely, you can sell legendary fish in Stardew Valley! They fetch a high price, making them a tempting source of income. However, there are a few things to consider before heading to the shipping bin. Let’s dive into the details of dealing with these rare catches.

The Allure of Legendary Fish

Legendary fish in Stardew Valley are, well, legendary. They’re rare, difficult to catch, and each type can only be caught once per save file except for the Legend fish which is caught endlessly. This makes them highly prized. While the immediate reward of selling them is appealing, there are other factors to weigh, like the fish’s utility and visual appeal.

Selling vs. Keeping: The Dilemma

The decision of whether to sell or keep your legendary fish is a personal one, dependent on your current needs and future plans in the game.

Selling: The most straightforward benefit is the immediate influx of gold. Legendary fish command a high price, especially if you have the Fisher and Angler professions, boosting their base sell price even further. If you’re in dire need of funds to upgrade your tools, expand your farm, or purchase essential items, selling a legendary fish might be the best option. The Legend Fish can sell for 5000g-10,000g depending on its quality.
Keeping: Since an update in the game, you can now house fish in a fish tank inside of your home. This may be of interest as the legendary fish may serve to give your home a unique look.

Factors Influencing Your Decision

Before making the plunge, consider these factors:

Your Financial Situation: Are you swimming in gold, or are you struggling to make ends meet? If you’re flush with cash, keeping a legendary fish for display or completionist purposes becomes more appealing.
The Stage of the Game: Early in the game, the income from a legendary fish can be a game-changer. Later on, when your farm is thriving and generating consistent revenue, the financial impact is less significant.
Completionist Tendencies: Do you strive to collect every item and achievement in the game? If so, keeping one of each legendary fish might be more important than the immediate profit.
The Availability of Fish Tanks: With the added functionality of using the fish tanks for decoration, the decision to keep or sell becomes more complex.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Legendary Fish

Here are some frequently asked questions related to the legendary fish.

1. What are the legendary fish in Stardew Valley?

The five legendary fish in Stardew Valley are:

Crimsonfish: Found in the ocean during summer.
Angler: Found in the river near the JojaMart during fall.
Legend: Found in the mountain lake during spring (requires rainy weather and a high fishing level).
Glacierfish: Found in Cindersap Forest during winter.
Mutant Carp: Found in the Sewers at any time of year. The only one that doesn’t require a specific season.

2. Can I catch legendary fish multiple times?

No, you can only catch each legendary fish once per save file, except for the Legend fish. Once you’ve caught a Crimsonfish, Angler, Glacierfish, or Mutant Carp, they will no longer appear. The Legend can be caught endlessly.

3. What happens if I accidentally sell a legendary fish?

Once it’s sold, it’s gone. You cannot catch another one of that specific legendary fish in that save file (excluding the Legend).

4. How much do legendary fish sell for?

The sell price varies depending on the fish and its quality. With the exception of the Legend Fish, these fish all share the same selling point, where without any fishing perks, they sell for 5,000g at normal quality.

5. How do fishing professions affect the sell price of legendary fish?

The Fisher profession increases the sell price of fish by 25%, and the Angler profession further increases it by 50%. These professions significantly boost the value of legendary fish.

6. Can I put legendary fish in a fish pond?

No, you cannot put legendary fish in fish ponds. Fish ponds only accept regular fish.

7. Can I use magic bait to catch legendary fish?

Yes, magic bait can be used to catch legendary fish at any time of day. However, you still need to be in the correct location and season (except for the Mutant Carp).

8. Is it better to eat or sell legendary fish?

Selling is generally the better option. The stat boosts from eating them are minimal compared to the significant profit you can gain. However, if you really need a temporary boost, eating one might be justifiable.

9. Can I use legendary fish in recipes?

Yes, you can use legendary fish in recipes that call for “any fish.” However, this is generally not recommended, as you’re essentially wasting a valuable and rare item.

10. What’s the best way to increase my chances of catching legendary fish?

Increase your fishing level: Higher fishing levels make it easier to catch difficult fish.
Use tackle: Tackle like the Cork Bobber or Trap Bobber can make fishing easier.
Eat food that buffs fishing: Seafoam Pudding or Trout Soup provide temporary fishing buffs.
Fish in the correct location and season: Legendary fish only appear in specific locations during specific seasons (except for the Mutant Carp).

11. What is the hardest legendary fish to catch?

The Legend is widely considered the most difficult legendary fish to catch due to its high difficulty rating and the specific conditions required for it to appear (rainy weather in the spring).

12. Are legendary fish affected by fish quality?

Yes, legendary fish can have different quality levels (normal, silver, gold), which affect their sell price.

13. What are some alternative uses for legendary fish besides selling?

Besides selling, you can:

Display them in fish tanks: A great way to show off your rare catches.
Use them for quests: Some quests might require you to catch a specific fish, although this is rare.
Keep them for completionist purposes: If you’re a completionist, you might want to keep one of each.

14. Does luck affect my chances of catching legendary fish?

Yes, daily luck and luck buffs (from food or drinks) can slightly increase your chances of catching rare fish, including legendary ones.

15. Where can I learn more about Stardew Valley and game-based learning?

You can explore resources on game design, learning through games, and the intersection of education and gaming at the Games Learning Society. Visit their website at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/ to find more information and publications on these topics. GamesLearningSociety.org is a fantastic resource for understanding the educational potential of games like Stardew Valley.

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, the decision to sell or keep your legendary fish depends on your personal play style and goals. If you need the gold, sell away! If you value collection and display, consider keeping them. There’s no right or wrong answer, just what’s best for your Stardew Valley journey.

Can I sell legendary fish?