Can You Bring Millicent Back After Killing Her in Elden Ring?
The short answer is no, you cannot bring Millicent back to life if you kill her in Elden Ring. Once she is defeated, whether by accident or intention, she is permanently gone for that playthrough. This is a crucial aspect of her questline and an important consideration for players. Millicent, a character deeply connected to Malenia and the Scarlet Rot, presents players with a series of significant choices that directly impact her fate and the rewards you can obtain. Her death, unfortunately, is irreversible.
Why is Millicent’s Death Permanent?
Millicent’s permanent death is a deliberate design choice by the developers at FromSoftware, characteristic of their approach to non-player characters (NPCs). Unlike some other NPCs who can be resurrected or reappear in different forms, Millicent’s story has a definitive conclusion, shaped by player actions. This choice emphasizes the weight of player decisions, where unintended consequences or deliberate actions have lasting effects on the game world. Her questline is about her struggle with the Scarlet Rot and her identity, and it’s designed to make the player think hard about the ramifications of their choices.
The Significance of Millicent’s Questline
Millicent’s quest is not just another side story; it’s intricately woven into the lore surrounding Malenia, the Blade of Miquella, and the Scarlet Rot. Millicent is considered a “bud” or offshoot of Malenia, essentially making her a type of daughter or extension. This relationship adds a layer of depth to her quest, making player decisions more impactful. The choices you make will not only impact Millicent’s fate but will also lead to obtaining different, powerful talismans that affect combat builds significantly.
Accidental Deaths
Many players have reported accidentally killing Millicent by jumping on her or hitting her during combat, unaware she’s an NPC they might need to interact with. This can be particularly frustrating because, unlike some characters that might simply be stunned, killing her is final. Once she’s gone, you won’t be able to progress further in her questline or obtain the rewards associated with assisting her. This highlights the importance of being careful around NPCs, especially those you haven’t yet met or fully understood their significance.
The Consequences of Killing Millicent
Killing Millicent has several distinct consequences:
- Quest Failure: Her questline is permanently terminated. You will not be able to receive the rewards associated with assisting her, including the Rotten Winged Sword Insignia talisman.
- Talisman Acquisition (Sometimes): If you kill her at Windmill Village or any time after receiving the Valkyrie’s Prosthesis and giving it to her, she will drop Millicent’s Prosthesis. However, you won’t get the Rotten Winged Sword Insignia if you choose to attack her.
- Gowry’s Fate: If you kill Millicent in Elphael, Brace of the Haligtree, Sage Gowry will be found dead back at his shack, with the Flock’s Canvas Talisman and Gowry’s Bell Bearing on his corpse.
- Missed Lore: You will miss out on significant story information and lore details that are revealed throughout her quest.
- No Needle: If you kill Millicent before she chooses to remove the needle, a flower will appear in her place, and you will not obtain the Unalloyed Gold Needle.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are 15 frequently asked questions about Millicent and her questline to help players understand the nuances and consequences of their actions:
1. What rewards do you get if you help Millicent?
If you choose to assist Millicent, you’ll receive the Rotten Winged Sword Insignia talisman after helping her at the summoning stones in Elphael, Brace of the Haligtree. Additionally, you can continue her questline and learn more about her connection to Malenia.
2. What happens if you challenge Millicent?
If you challenge Millicent, you will fight her. Upon defeating her, you obtain Millicent’s Prosthesis, and Sage Gowry will die, and you can loot his Flock’s Canvas Talisman and Gowry’s Bell Bearing at his shack.
3. Where is the first location to kill Millicent for her talisman?
The first location where you can kill Millicent to obtain Millicent’s Prosthesis is Windmill Village. You need to have already given her the Valkyrie’s Prosthesis and progressed her questline.
4. What is the difference between Millicent’s Prosthesis and Rotten Winged Sword Insignia?
Millicent’s Prosthesis provides a straight +5 Dexterity boost alongside a damage boost on successive attacks, making it a more versatile choice for those looking to increase their stats. The Rotten Winged Sword Insignia does not boost stats but provides the best damage boost on successive attacks.
5. How do you start Millicent’s questline?
You initiate her questline by speaking to her in the Church of the Plague in Caelid. You must have the Unalloyed Gold Needle to cure her Scarlet Rot.
6. Is Millicent Malenia’s daughter?
The game hints at a connection. Millicent and her “sisters” are described as being like “buds” or offshoots of the Scarlet Aeonia, which is associated with Malenia. This suggests she’s either a daughter or extension of Malenia.
7. Can you get the Unalloyed Gold Needle if you kill Millicent?
No, you cannot. If you kill her before she removes the needle during her questline, you’ll only find a flower in her place, and you will miss the Unalloyed Gold Needle.
8. Why does Millicent kill herself?
Millicent removes the needle, which was keeping her from fully succumbing to the Scarlet Rot. She chooses to die as herself rather than transform into a being like Malenia. She fears the “blooming” process.
9. Should you kill Sage Gowry?
You can kill Gowry to obtain the Flock’s Canvas Talisman and Gowry’s Bell Bearing. If you kill Millicent at the end of her quest in Elphael, Brace of the Haligtree, Gowry will be dead at his shack, and you can loot these items from his corpse.
10. What are Millicent’s weaknesses in combat?
Like many NPCs, Millicent is vulnerable to jump attacks and can be interrupted if you strike her before she completes an attack animation.
11. Does killing Millicent as an invader end the quest?
Yes, if you use the red summon sign to invade and kill her, the questline ends prematurely, and you will only get Millicent’s Prosthesis.
12. Is there any downside to killing NPCs?
While killing some NPCs provides benefits like Bell Bearings or specific items, some NPCs, such as Millicent, provide more benefits by keeping them alive and completing their questlines. Killing some, especially early, can lock you out of certain content.
13. Can you complete Millicent’s quest if you kill Sage Gowry early?
Yes, you can complete Millicent’s questline even if you kill Sage Gowry before meeting him. He has no bearing on the progression of her questline.
14. How many sisters does Millicent have?
Millicent has four sisters, who are also afflicted by the Scarlet Rot and went to the Haligtree under Gowry’s guidance. Millicent was the only one who remained behind.
15. Is Millicent’s questline worth it?
Yes, it’s highly worth it. Her quest not only provides significant lore details but also rewards players with very powerful talismans crucial for certain builds. It also unlocks one of the Elden Ring’s different endings.
Conclusion
Millicent’s fate in Elden Ring is entirely in the hands of the player. The inability to revive her once she’s killed underscores the significance of player choices and the consequences that follow. Understanding her questline and the rewards associated with each path is crucial for navigating her complex story and making informed decisions. The irreversible nature of her death serves as a stark reminder of the weighty consequences present in Elden Ring, making each choice all the more meaningful.