Can You Catch Legendary Fish Twice? Unraveling the Mysteries of RDR2 Fishing
The allure of Legendary Fish in Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2) is undeniable. These unique aquatic creatures offer a challenging and rewarding experience for anglers, but a common question often surfaces: Can you catch Legendary Fish twice? The straightforward answer is no, not in the conventional sense. Once you’ve successfully reeled in a particular Legendary Fish and mailed it to Jeremy Gill, that specific fish is gone for that playthrough. It cannot be caught again. However, the story isn’t quite as simple as that, and there are nuances to explore. You may be able to catch the same type of legendary fish again if you throw them back before mailing them.
The Unique Nature of Legendary Fish in RDR2
Unlike regular fish, Legendary Fish are one-of-a-kind specimens located at specific spots across the RDR2 map. Each one presents a unique fishing challenge, requiring the use of specialized lures and a keen understanding of the game’s fishing mechanics. The primary purpose of catching these fish is to fulfill the quest provided by Jeremy Gill, who tasks Arthur (or John) with locating and catching all 13 of these prized catches.
What Happens After Catching a Legendary Fish?
Once you successfully reel in a Legendary Fish, the game prompts you to store it on your horse. After that, the fish must be mailed to Jeremy Gill from the nearest post office. This action completes the capture of that specific Legendary Fish, rewarding you with money and contributing to the overall completion of the questline. Once mailed, that fish is considered “caught” and won’t respawn for the player to catch again in the current playthrough. This creates a sense of uniqueness to these prized catches. However, if you throw the legendary fish back before mailing it, you will be able to catch the same type of legendary fish again.
The Myth of Respawning Fish
There’s some confusion arising from the information that a lost legendary fish after catching it will respawn after two days. This refers to fish that you may have lost if the line snaps, or if you were killed or got too far away from your horse after catching them, not when the fish is in your possession. These fishes will return after a couple of in-game days. However, if you had previously caught and mailed a legendary fish, the same fish will not respawn.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Legendary Fish
To further clarify the details about Legendary Fish in RDR2, here are 15 frequently asked questions:
1. How many Legendary Fish are there in RDR2?
There are a total of 13 Legendary Fish to catch in Red Dead Redemption 2, each found in different bodies of water across the map.
2. Can I catch multiple Legendary Fish of the same type?
No, not after mailing them to Jeremy Gill. You can only successfully mail one of each type of Legendary Fish per playthrough. However, if you throw the fish back before mailing it, you can catch them again until you get a size that you like.
3. What happens if I lose a Legendary Fish?
If you lose a Legendary Fish before mailing it (for example, if it falls off your horse, if you are killed, or if the line snaps), it will respawn after approximately two in-game days at its original location. This allows you another chance to catch it.
4. What are the different types of special lures for legendary fish?
There are three types of special lures for Legendary Fish: the Special River Lure, the Special Lake Lure, and the Special Swamp Lure. Each is designed for a specific type of water and is purchasable at Lagras for $20 each.
5. Can you farm Legendary Fish?
No, you cannot “farm” Legendary Fish in the traditional sense. You cannot catch multiple instances of the same fish after they have been mailed to Jeremy Gill in a single playthrough.
6. Can Legendary Fish be placed in a Fish Pond?
No, Legendary Fish cannot be placed in a Fish Pond. They are a unique category and do not function like regular fish for this mechanic.
7. What is the hardest Legendary Fish to catch in RDR2?
The Legendary Bullhead Catfish is widely regarded as one of the most challenging to reel in, due to its size and the fishing location.
8. What is the easiest Legendary Fish to catch in RDR2?
The Legendary Smallmouth Bass is often considered one of the easiest to catch, located at Lake Owanjila, just west of Strawberry.
9. How do I start the Legendary Fish quest?
You can start the quest by speaking with Jeremy Gill at the fishing pier south-west of the Van Horn Trading Post. He will provide you with a map and task you to catch all the 13 Legendary Fish.
10. What happens after I catch all 13 Legendary Fish?
After mailing all 13 fish, Jeremy Gill will send you an invitation for one final fishing trip, which is considered the conclusion of the quest. This final part of the quest is also considered to be a challenging and fun fishing experience.
11. What do I do with Legendary Fish once caught?
Once caught, you must store them on your horse and then mail them to Jeremy Gill at the nearest post office for your reward. They cannot be sold to regular vendors.
12. What do you get for catching Legendary Fish?
Upon mailing each Legendary Fish, you receive a sum of money as a reward. You also progress towards the completion of the Jeremy Gill questline and receive a reward for the quest completion.
13. Can you catch Legendary Fish as John Marston?
Yes, John Marston can catch Legendary Fish after the main story has been completed and the player takes control of John Marston, if the player has not completed the quest as Arthur Morgan.
14. Are there any other legendary creatures besides fish?
Yes, there are also 29 Legendary Animals to hunt in RDR2, excluding the fish. These include various land-based and aquatic creatures, each presenting its own unique hunting challenge.
15. What is the difference between legendary fish and regular fish?
Legendary Fish are unique, one-of-a-kind specimens that require special lures and present a greater challenge to catch. They also are only for the Jeremy Gill quest. In contrast, regular fish can be caught repeatedly and are typically sold for profit, while legendary fishes cannot be sold for profit.
Conclusion: The Uniqueness of Legendary Fish
The mechanics of Legendary Fish in Red Dead Redemption 2 are designed to provide a distinct and engaging experience for players. While you can’t catch the same fish twice after mailing it to Jeremy Gill, the game’s subtle nuances allow for some leeway in gameplay. The challenge of locating and capturing each legendary fish, combined with the rewarding feeling of completing the quest, contributes to the game’s overall appeal. The ability to catch them repeatedly if you choose to throw them back before mailing them also adds to the freedom the game gives to the player. Understanding these details helps players navigate the world of RDR2’s angling with greater knowledge and enjoyment.