Can You Sell Stolen Stagecoaches in Red Dead Online?

The quick answer is: no, you cannot sell stolen stagecoaches in Red Dead Online. While the single-player campaign of Red Dead Redemption 2 allows Arthur Morgan to profit from hijacking stagecoaches and selling them to fences, this feature is absent from the online multiplayer mode. This can be a point of confusion for many players, as the single-player mechanics suggest this should be a lucrative activity in online mode too. However, in Red Dead Online, your options for selling stolen goods are more limited, and stagecoaches are not on that list. Let’s explore this further and discuss what you can do instead.

Why Can’t You Sell Stolen Stagecoaches in Red Dead Online?

The mechanics of Red Dead Online differ significantly from the single-player experience in many ways, particularly when it comes to economic activities. While the single-player game is designed to let Arthur experience the full spectrum of outlaw life, including hijacking and selling coaches, Red Dead Online focuses more on role-playing and persistent character development within a shared world.

The absence of the stolen stagecoach sale mechanic might be attributed to several reasons:

• Balance and Economy: Allowing players to repeatedly steal and sell stagecoaches could create significant economic imbalances in the game. It’s likely that Rockstar Games made the decision to streamline the economy to encourage various roles and activities.
• Focus on Roles: Red Dead Online promotes players to engage with the various roles – Trader, Collector, Bounty Hunter, Moonshiner, and Naturalist – which provide more structured gameplay and progression. The core loop isn’t built around random acts of banditry as much as the single-player game.
• Technical Limitations: Handling the consistent spawn and sale of stagecoaches with a large number of players online could present technical challenges. The system may not be as robust in an online multiplayer setting as in single-player.
• Reduced Griefing: Without the ability to profit from selling stagecoaches, one potential avenue for griefing other players is removed. A less chaotic environment fosters a more player-friendly online experience.

What Can You Sell in Red Dead Online?

Although you can’t sell stolen stagecoaches, Red Dead Online still provides several ways to make money by selling goods to fences and other vendors. Here’s what you can sell:

• Jewelry and Valuables: Fences across the map, marked by a bag icon with an ‘x’, will purchase jewelry, belt buckles, watches, and other valuables you find while looting and exploring. These can be found on NPCs, inside lockboxes, and while roaming the world.
• Animal Pelts and Carcasses: Hunters and trappers will find a lucrative source of income by selling animal pelts and carcasses at butchers throughout the world. This is a great way to make money, especially when combining it with the Trader role.
• Crafted Goods: As you progress through the game, you may craft various items that you can then sell or use.
• Bounty Targets: As you progress in the Bounty Hunter role, you can capture live bounty targets and deliver them to the sheriff for a reward.
• Collected Items: The Collector role involves locating and gathering various collectibles such as Tarot Cards, Antique Bottles, and Lost Jewelry that can then be sold to Madam Nazar.
• Moonshine: For those engaging with the Moonshiner role, you can brew and sell various types of moonshine, providing a substantial profit.
• Trader Goods: Trader role involves hunting, gathering resources and making delivery missions for a decent profit.

Understanding Fences

Fences are your go-to merchants for most stolen items. They can be found at specific locations:

• Emerald Ranch: A convenient early location.
• Rhodes: Located in the town’s main area.
• Saint Denis: In the marketplace to the east of the city.
• Thieves Landing: A shady option in the far west of the map.
• Van Horn Trading Post: A remote location in the east.

Each fence will pay for your stolen items, giving you a reliable way to dispose of your illicit gains and grow your wealth. Keep in mind the fences offer more money for valuables than regular merchants.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here are 15 frequently asked questions that might further help you understand selling options and how to make money in Red Dead Online:

1. Can I sell horses I catch in Red Dead Online?

While you can break and tame wild horses, you cannot sell them for profit. You can keep the horses you’ve tamed, stable them, and switch between them, but they do not provide a direct cash return. However, some horse breeds are better than others, and acquiring higher tier horses could indirectly aid in making more money.

2. How do I sell stolen goods in RDR2 Online?

To sell stolen goods, you need to locate a fence, which is marked by a small bag with an “x” on the map. Bring your jewelry, belt buckles, watches, tonics, and other valuables to them and sell them for profit.

3. Where can I find the best fence?

While the Saint Denis fence is often mentioned as being the best due to its location in the market, all fences offer similar prices. The “best” fence is the closest and most convenient fence to where you are currently playing.

4. Can I sell wagons in RDR2 online?

No, you cannot sell wagons in Red Dead Online. Despite wagons appearing throughout the world, there is no way to trade them for cash.

5. Can I rob trains in RDR2 Online?

Yes, you can rob trains in RDR2 Online. You can hop onto a train, loot passengers and crates, and even force the train to stop. However, like the single player, you can expect to face some opposition from lawmen.

6. Can I rob banks in Red Dead Online?

There is one mission-based bank heist in Red Dead Online, but it requires low honor to unlock. This isn’t something you can just do repeatedly. It’s an option related to a specific storyline and cannot be freely initiated at any point.

7. What are the best ways to earn money in Red Dead Online?

Some of the best ways to earn money include:

• Completing Missions: Story missions and Stranger missions offer decent rewards.
• Role Activities: Engaging with roles like Trader, Bounty Hunter, and Collector provides a consistent income.
• Daily Challenges: Completing daily challenges gives you gold, which can be used to buy items or convert to cash.
• Selling to Butchers: Hunting and selling pelts to butchers is a reliable way to generate income.

8. Is it better to steal stagecoaches during the day or night in single-player RDR2?

In the single-player campaign, there is no significant difference between robbing a stagecoach during the day or night. Follow the on-screen instructions and be prepared for a fight or chase if needed.

9. What is the stagecoach glitch in RDR2?

The stagecoach glitch refers to a bug where if you are a passenger in a stagecoach and NPCs run into it, the driver might flee. This will leave you stuck inside, unable to complete the journey. This is a rare occurrence.

10. Can I start a business in Red Dead Online?

Yes, you can start a business by purchasing a Butcher’s Table to engage with the Trader role. Additionally, the Moonshiner role allows you to establish a moonshine production business.

11. Can I go to jail in Red Dead Online?

Yes, if you commit crimes and accumulate a bounty, you can be arrested and sent to jail. You will lose your current bounty as well as any money on your person, and you will have to work through a bounty hunter mission to regain your freedom.

12. Can you sell skinned animals in Red Dead Online?

Yes, you can sell skinned animal pelts and carcasses at butchers located in the larger towns on the map.

13. Is Red Dead Online the same as the single-player experience?

While they share the same game world, Red Dead Online has significant differences, including the absence of stolen stagecoach sales, a focus on roles, and a player-driven economy.

14. Are there weekly bonuses in Red Dead Online?

Yes, Rockstar often provides weekly bonuses for certain activities. Keep an eye on the in-game news and social media channels for updates.

15. Is it easier to earn money in single player or online in RDR2?

While single player allows you to quickly amass funds, Red Dead Online is a longer-term experience with a focus on persistent character development. Both offer plenty of methods to make money, but are geared towards very different playstyles.

Conclusion

In conclusion, despite the allure of selling stolen stagecoaches in Red Dead Redemption 2’s single-player, this option is not available in Red Dead Online. However, the game offers numerous other ways to make money, such as selling valuables to fences, hunting, participating in role activities, and completing missions. Focusing on the available methods is key to thriving in the world of Red Dead Online. While it can be frustrating, remember that each activity plays a role in the broader, well-rounded gameplay loop.