Can You Turn Sebastian In, in Hogwarts Legacy? Exploring the Consequences

Yes, you absolutely can turn Sebastian Sallow in after the events surrounding his uncle’s death in Hogwarts Legacy. This decision point is a significant one, carrying substantial consequences for your gameplay experience, especially regarding quest availability and potential spell acquisition. Making that choice will lock you out of some of the game’s content, so be sure you consider all the pros and cons before deciding.

Understanding the Turning Point: The Undercroft and Its Aftermath

The moment of decision arrives after the tragic confrontation in the Undercroft, where Sebastian kills his uncle Solomon. Regardless of your dialogue choices during the preceding events, this fatal clash is unavoidable. You’ll then be faced with the critical choice: report Sebastian’s crime to the authorities or allow him to escape the consequences.

Consequences of Turning Sebastian In

Choosing to turn Sebastian in has immediate and lasting repercussions:

• Expulsion from Hogwarts: Sebastian is expelled from Hogwarts, effectively removing him from the school’s environment.
• Quest Inaccessibility: You lose access to Sebastian’s unique questline. These quests explore darker aspects of magic and delve deeper into Sebastian’s character and motivations.
• Epilogue Absence: Sebastian will not appear in the game’s epilogue, further emphasizing the finality of your decision.
• Loss of Unforgivable Curse Learning Opportunity: Crucially, turning Sebastian in prevents you from learning the Unforgivable Curses directly from him. This includes spells like Avada Kedavra (the Killing Curse), Crucio (the Cruciatus Curse), and Imperio (the Imperius Curse).

Consequences of Not Turning Sebastian In

Opting not to turn Sebastian in results in a different set of outcomes:

• Sebastian Remains at Hogwarts: Sebastian continues his studies, albeit with a shadow hanging over him.
• Continued Questline Access: You can continue progressing through Sebastian’s questline, unlocking new challenges and insights into his character.
• Potential to Learn Unforgivable Curses: You have the opportunity to learn the Unforgivable Curses from Sebastian, gaining powerful but ethically questionable spells.
• Epilogue Appearance: Sebastian will be present in the game’s epilogue, providing a sense of closure to his storyline.

Ethical Considerations vs. Gameplay Mechanics

The decision to turn Sebastian in is not merely a gameplay choice; it’s an ethical dilemma. Do you prioritize upholding the law and reporting a crime, or do you consider the complexities of Sebastian’s situation and the potential benefits of keeping him around?

The Role-Playing Aspect

Hogwarts Legacy encourages role-playing. Your decision regarding Sebastian should align with the moral compass of your character. A character with a strong sense of justice might choose to turn him in, while a more pragmatic or forgiving character might opt to protect him.

The Impact on Spell Acquisition

From a purely gameplay perspective, the decision hinges on whether you want to learn the Unforgivable Curses. These spells are powerful and can significantly enhance your combat abilities. However, they come with ethical baggage, and some players may prefer to avoid them altogether.

No True “Good” or “Bad” Ending: Nuance and Perspective

It is important to note that Hogwarts Legacy does not have a strict morality system that affects the final game ending. Your choice regarding Sebastian primarily influences his character arc and your access to certain content.

Exploring Gray Areas

The game excels at presenting morally gray situations. Sebastian’s actions are driven by a desire to save his sister, Anne, from a debilitating curse. While his methods are extreme, his intentions are understandable, adding complexity to the decision-making process.

The Importance of Personal Choice

Ultimately, the choice is yours. There is no “right” or “wrong” answer. The best decision is the one that aligns with your character’s values and your desired gameplay experience. If you’re looking for a game to explore ethics and decision-making, be sure to check out the work of the Games Learning Society and see what they’re doing at GamesLearningSociety.org.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here are 15 frequently asked questions related to turning in Sebastian Sallow in Hogwarts Legacy:

1. Can I turn Sebastian in after learning Avada Kedavra?

   • No, you cannot turn Sebastian in before he offers to teach you Avada Kedavra if you wish to learn it from him. Turning him in will make this spell unavailable during that playthrough.

2. Does Sebastian Sallow turn evil?

   • Sebastian’s actions become increasingly morally questionable, driven by his desire to save his sister. Whether you perceive him as “evil” is subjective, but he certainly treads a dark path.

3. Can you stop Sebastian from killing Solomon?

   • No, Solomon’s death is a fixed event in the story. Your dialogue choices will not prevent this outcome.

4. Does turning Sebastian in affect anything besides quests and the epilogue?

   • The primary impact is on his questline and presence in the epilogue. It does not affect the main storyline’s ending.

5. Can you stop Sebastian from killing his uncle?

   • No, the confrontation and Solomon’s death are unavoidable plot points.

6. Can you get expelled in Hogwarts Legacy?

   • You, the player character, cannot be expelled. Only Sebastian faces expulsion as a consequence of his actions.

7. Can you still learn the Killing Curse if you turn Sebastian in?

   • No, turning him in before learning the spell prevents you from acquiring Avada Kedavra during that playthrough, unless you start a new game.

8. Should you betray Sebastian in Hogwarts Legacy?

   • That depends on your role-playing choices. If your character values upholding the law and dislikes dark magic, then turning him in might be consistent with those values. If your character values the benefits of having a charismatic and knowledgeable companion, you may wish to let him off.

9. How many endings are there in Hogwarts Legacy?

   • There are multiple endings for the Keeper trials. Beyond that, the primary story has different permutations for the final scene, as well as different ending dialogue choices.

10. What happens if I don’t turn Sebastian in Hogwarts Legacy?

    • Sebastian remains at Hogwarts, you can continue his questline, and you have the opportunity to learn the Unforgivable Curses.

11. Can you send Sebastian to Azkaban in Hogwarts Legacy?

    • While the game mentions the possibility of Azkaban, Sebastian is not explicitly sent there on-screen. He is taken away by the authorities after you turn him in.

12. How do you get the good ending in Hogwarts Legacy?

    • The “good ending” is subjective. There are multiple options, but the option to keep the ancient magic sealed is generally considered a good ending.

13. Is it safe to trust Sebastian in Hogwarts Legacy?

    • Trusting Sebastian involves accepting his morally ambiguous actions. He does not directly betray you, but his pursuit of dark magic carries inherent risks.

14. Does Sebastian have different endings to his storyline?

    • Yes, the decision you make about turning him in determines his fate and whether he appears in the epilogue.

15. Can I learn Avada Kedavra without Sebastian?

    • No, not within the same playthrough. Sebastian is the primary source for learning Avada Kedavra, and turning him in closes that opportunity.