Table of Contents

Can You Use Tipped Arrows with Infinity? A Comprehensive Guide

No, you cannot use tipped arrows or spectral arrows with the Infinity enchantment in Minecraft. The Infinity enchantment is specifically designed to work only with regular arrows. If you attempt to shoot tipped arrows or spectral arrows with a bow enchanted with Infinity, the arrows will be consumed as usual, negating the effect of the enchantment.

This limitation is a core mechanic of the game, preventing players from exploiting the Infinity enchantment with special arrow types that offer additional effects like poison or glowing. It forces players to make a strategic choice between the convenience of unlimited regular arrows and the tactical advantages offered by tipped arrows and spectral arrows.

Understanding the Infinity Enchantment

The Infinity enchantment is a highly sought-after enchantment for bows in Minecraft. It allows players to shoot an unlimited number of arrows, provided they have at least one arrow in their inventory. This eliminates the need to constantly craft or collect arrows, making it incredibly convenient for extended adventures and combat situations.

However, it’s crucial to understand the enchantment’s limitations. As mentioned earlier, Infinity only works with regular arrows. Attempting to use it with other types of arrows will result in those arrows being consumed from your inventory as they are fired.

The Advantages of Infinity

Unlimited Arrows: The primary advantage is the ability to shoot an unlimited number of regular arrows, freeing up inventory space and eliminating the need for constant arrow replenishment.
Convenience: Simplifies gameplay, allowing players to focus on other tasks without worrying about running out of arrows.
Cost-Effective (In the Long Run): While enchanting can be resource-intensive, the long-term benefit of not needing to craft arrows can save resources.

The Drawbacks of Infinity

Exclusivity with Mending: Infinity is mutually exclusive with the Mending enchantment, which repairs the bow’s durability using experience orbs. This means you have to choose between unlimited arrows and a bow that effectively repairs itself. More on this later.
Only Works with Regular Arrows: The biggest limitation is the inability to use tipped arrows or spectral arrows without consuming them.
Bow Durability Still Matters: The bow’s durability still decreases with each shot, even with Infinity.

Why Can’t You Use Tipped Arrows with Infinity?

The restriction on using tipped arrows and spectral arrows with Infinity is a deliberate design choice by Mojang, the developers of Minecraft. The main reasons behind this decision are:

Balance: Allowing Infinity to work with special arrows would make the enchantment too overpowered. Players could spam powerful effects like poison or weakness without any resource cost.
Strategic Choice: The limitation forces players to make a strategic choice between the convenience of Infinity and the tactical advantages of tipped arrows. This adds depth to combat and resource management.
Gameplay Variety: By restricting Infinity to regular arrows, the game encourages players to experiment with different arrow types and enchanting strategies.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Infinity and Arrows

1. Can you combine Infinity and Mending?

No, you cannot combine Infinity and Mending on the same bow. These enchantments are mutually exclusive, meaning you can only have one or the other. This is a design choice to prevent bows from becoming too powerful.

2. Does Infinity work with spectral arrows?

No, Infinity does not work with spectral arrows. Spectral arrows will be consumed when fired from a bow enchanted with Infinity.

3. Does Infinity work with diamond arrows?

No, there are no diamond arrows in Minecraft. Infinity works only with regular arrows.

4. Is Infinity good on a bow?

Yes, Infinity is generally considered a good enchantment on a bow, especially for players who frequently use arrows and want to avoid the hassle of crafting or collecting them constantly. However, it depends on your playstyle and access to resources. If you have a readily available skeleton farm for arrows and experience, Mending might be a better choice.

5. What arrows work with Infinity?

Only regular arrows work with the Infinity enchantment. Tipped arrows and spectral arrows will still be consumed when shot from an Infinity-enchanted bow.

6. What does Infinity not work with?

Infinity does not work with tipped arrows, spectral arrows, or the Mending enchantment. It also doesn’t prevent bow durability from decreasing.

7. Is Mending or Infinity better?

The “better” enchantment depends on your playstyle and resource availability. If you have an easy way to get arrows and experience like a skeleton farm, Mending is likely better. If you don’t have a good source of arrows but have plenty of experience to repair when needed or other sources for bows, Infinity is better.

8. Why can I not put Infinity on my bow?

There are a few reasons why you might not be able to put Infinity on your bow:

You already have Mending on the bow.
You don’t have a high enough level. Infinity requires a certain level to apply.
You’re trying to apply it through commands and haven’t bypassed the incompatibility.

9. Can you put Flame on an Infinity bow?

Yes, you can put Flame on an Infinity bow. Flame and Infinity are compatible enchantments. This allows you to shoot unlimited fire arrows.

10. How long does it take for Infinity arrows to despawn?

Arrows shot from skeletons and bows enchanted with Infinity do not despawn. Normally, arrows despawn after 5 minutes, but those shot from these sources are exempt.

11. What enchantments cannot go with Infinity?

The primary enchantment that cannot be combined with Infinity is Mending.

12. Can you repair an Infinity bow?

Yes, you can repair an Infinity bow in an anvil, but only with other bows, or through creative means. You also will lose the bow if you repair it too many times, as the anvil use cost will get too high.

13. What does Infinity 1 do on a bow?

Infinity 1 is the only level of the Infinity enchantment. It allows the bow to shoot an unlimited number of arrows as long as you have at least one arrow in your inventory.

14. Can you put Mending on armor?

Yes, you can put Mending on armor, and it’s highly recommended. Mending on armor will repair the armor’s durability using experience orbs you collect.

15. Can skeletons drop Mending bows?

Skeletons can drop bows, and those bows can be enchanted. However, a skeleton cannot normally drop a bow enchanted with both Infinity and Mending, because those enchantments are mutually exclusive.

Choosing Between Infinity and Mending: A Strategic Decision

The choice between Infinity and Mending often boils down to personal preference and resource availability.

Choose Infinity if:
- You don’t have a reliable source of arrows.
- You frequently use your bow and don’t want to worry about running out of arrows.
- You are able to easily obtain new bows, but not arrows.
Choose Mending if:
- You have a reliable source of arrows, such as a skeleton farm.
- You want to extend the lifespan of your bow indefinitely through experience-based repair.
- You have other methods for acquiring enchanted bows if your current one is not good enough.

Conclusion

While the Infinity enchantment offers the incredible convenience of unlimited regular arrows, it’s essential to understand its limitations, particularly the inability to use tipped arrows or spectral arrows without consuming them. By understanding these limitations, players can make informed decisions about their enchanting strategies and optimize their gameplay experience. Remember, the best choice depends on your individual playstyle, resource availability, and strategic goals within the Minecraft world.

To learn more about the intersection of games and learning, visit the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.

Can you use tipped arrows with infinity?