Did Anyone Know Arthur Was Sick?

The answer to the question of whether anyone knew Arthur was sick is a complex one, with various characters in the game exhibiting knowledge of Arthur’s tuberculosis (TB), although it is not explicitly stated how they became aware of his condition. In the game Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2), characters like Strauss, Micah, and Dutch display an understanding of Arthur’s fragile health, with Micah even going so far as to mockingly refer to him as “Black Lung”.

Understanding the Spread of TB

How TB Spreads

It is worth noting that TB is a highly infectious disease that can be spread through close contact with infected individuals, which raises questions about why other characters in the game did not contract the disease from Arthur.

Related FAQs

1. Why didn’t anyone catch TB from Arthur? The game does not provide a clear explanation for why other characters did not contract TB from Arthur, but it can be inferred that Arthur may have taken steps to avoid infecting others, such as covering his mouth when coughing.
2. Did Dutch really care about Arthur? Dutch’s actions throughout the game suggest that he did care about Arthur, but his own narcissism and ego often led him to prioritize his own interests over Arthur’s well-being.
3. Why didn’t Arthur cough on Micah? Arthur’s self-awareness of his illness may have led him to take steps to avoid coughing on others, including Micah.
4. Could Arthur have survived TB? Unfortunately, the chances of Arthur overcoming TB in the game are slim to none, given the limited medical understanding and treatment options available at the time.
5. Is there an ending where Arthur doesn’t get TB? No, there is no ending in which Arthur does not contract TB, as this is a pivotal plot point in the game.
6. Will there be a RDR3? While there has been no official announcement from Rockstar Games, there have been hints and teases that suggest a Red Dead Redemption 3 may be in development.
7. Could Arthur have beaten Micah if he wasn’t sick? Yes, it is likely that a healthy Arthur would have been able to defeat Micah in a physical altercation.
8. Why did Dutch shoot Micah? Dutch shoots Micah as a form of redemption for his past mistakes and as a way of honoring Arthur’s memory.
9. Could Arthur beat Micah without TB? A healthy Arthur would have had a significant advantage over Micah in a physical confrontation.
10. Why did Dutch turn bad? Dutch’s narcissism and ego contribute to his downfall, as well as the head injury he sustains.
11. Why does Dutch betray Arthur? Dutch’s betrayal of Arthur is motivated by his own desire for power and control, as well as his growing paranoia and distrust of those around him.
12. Did Dutch know Micah was a rat? Dutch suspects that Micah may be a traitor, but he is not certain until later in the game.
13. Why is Hosea coughing in RDR2? Hosea’s coughing is a symptom of a lung disease that he is suffering from, although the exact nature of his illness is not specified.
14. What happens if Arthur gets tuberculosis? If Arthur contracts TB, he will begin to exhibit symptoms such as coughing, weight loss, and fatigue, which will eventually lead to his downfall.
15. Why did Micah spare Arthur? Micah’s decision to spare Arthur’s life may be motivated by a desire to toy with him or to use him for his own purposes, rather than any genuine sense of mercy or remorse.