Do I Have to Evolve My Starter Pokémon? A Trainer’s Guide

The short answer is no, you absolutely do not have to evolve your starter Pokémon. The beauty of the Pokémon games lies in the freedom of choice. Whether you’re attached to the adorable form of your initial companion or have strategic reasons for delaying or even preventing evolution, the decision is entirely yours. However, understanding the implications of that decision is crucial for a successful and fulfilling Pokémon journey. This article will delve into the pros and cons, offer strategic insights, and answer your burning questions about Pokémon evolution.

Understanding Pokémon Evolution: More Than Just a Transformation

Evolution in the Pokémon world is often presented as a rite of passage, a natural progression toward greater power. While generally true, it’s not a universally beneficial process. Evolving a Pokémon fundamentally alters its stats, movepool, and sometimes even its type. Therefore, careful consideration is key.

• Stats: Evolved Pokémon typically boast higher base stats than their unevolved forms, translating to more potent attacks, greater resilience, and improved speed. This is the primary reason most players opt for evolution.
• Movepool: Evolution can significantly impact the moves a Pokémon can learn. Sometimes, the evolved form gains access to stronger moves earlier than its pre-evolution. Conversely, delaying evolution can allow a Pokémon to learn certain moves sooner than its evolved form.
• Type: Some evolutions result in a change of type, offering new strengths and weaknesses. This can be a double-edged sword, providing strategic advantages in some matchups while creating vulnerabilities in others.

The Benefits of Evolving Your Starter

For most players, the advantages of evolving their starter outweigh the drawbacks.

• Increased Power: As mentioned earlier, evolved Pokémon generally have superior stats. This advantage becomes increasingly important as you progress through the game and face stronger opponents, particularly in Gym battles and against the Elite Four.
• Access to Stronger Moves: Evolved forms often learn more powerful moves, allowing you to deal greater damage and cover a wider range of type matchups.
• Overcoming Challenges: Games are usually designed assuming you will evolve your Pokémon, therefore facing challenges using an unevolved Pokémon will be noticeably harder

The Allure of Remaining Unevolved: A Strategic Choice

While evolution is often the default choice, there are valid reasons to keep your starter in its initial form or delay evolution.

• Learning Moves Earlier: Some Pokémon learn specific, powerful moves at lower levels in their unevolved forms than they would in their evolved forms. By delaying evolution, you can acquire these moves sooner, giving you a temporary advantage.
• Nostalgia and Attachment: For some players, the aesthetic appeal of the unevolved form is paramount. They simply prefer the look of their starter and don’t want to change it. There’s nothing wrong with playing for personal enjoyment and attachment!
• The Eviolite Strategy: The item Eviolite, when held by a Pokémon that is capable of evolving, boosts its Defense and Special Defense stats. Some Pokémon, particularly those with naturally high defenses in their unevolved forms, can become incredibly bulky with the Eviolite, making them surprisingly resilient.
• Challenge Runs: Some players intentionally create challenges for themselves, such as completing the game with only unevolved Pokémon.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here are some frequently asked questions to further clarify the nuances of evolving (or not evolving) your starter Pokémon.

1. Should I stop my starter from evolving if I want a challenge?

Yes, definitely! Using an unevolved starter can significantly increase the difficulty of the game, forcing you to be more strategic in your battles and utilize items more effectively.

2. Are there any aesthetic reasons to not evolve my starter?

Absolutely! Personal preference plays a huge role in Pokémon. If you simply love the design of your starter’s unevolved form, there’s no shame in keeping it that way.

3. When should I evolve my starter?

Every starter from all eight generations first evolves at some point between levels 14 and 18. Based on the games’ level curves, this often puts them at their second stage shortly after or even before the first Gym.

4. Is there a benefit to not evolving Pikachu?

The Light Ball doubles Pikachu’s attacking stats, making it more offensively viable than Raichu, though its other stats are still markedly lower.

5. Does stopping a Pokémon from evolving make it weaker in the long run?

Delaying evolution does not cause a stat loss since the power-up gained by evolution is based on level and base stats. A level 100 Raichu will always be stronger than a level 80 Raichu, no matter if one was evolved at level 40 and the other one at level 20. In fact delaying your Pokémon’s evolution can even be good, because it allows them to learn moves quicker.

6. Do all starters evolve at the same level?

No. All Starter Pokémon are part of 3-stage evolutionary lines, triggering their first evolution between Lv. 14-18, and second evolution at Lv. 30-36.

7. Is there a benefit to not evolving Charmander?

The point of staying unevolved is getting moves early, and there are no drawbacks other than just at the time you’re still not evolved. But if your Charmander is strong enough to beat up whatever you’re fighting, and you’d still like to pick up Flamethrower early, there is no reason to evolve.

8. Should I level up my Pokemon before evolving it?

It doesn’t really matter unless you care about PVP. Cp is determined by base stats of a pokemon, the pokémon’s level, and its ivs. Because evolving a pokemon only changes the base stats not the level or ivs, it doesn’t matter if you power up a pokemon before evolving or after the cp it gets to won’t change.

9. Should I keep my starter Pokémon on my team throughout the whole game?

This depends entirely on your playstyle. Some trainers prefer to switch out their starter for Pokémon with better stats or type matchups later in the game. Others maintain a strong bond with their starter and keep it as a core member of their team.

10. Can you unevolve a Pokémon?

Unfortunately, no. Once a Pokémon has evolved, there’s no turning back (except via breeding, which results in a new, unevolved Pokémon).

11. Should I stop my Squirtle from evolving to learn a specific move?

Its Attack stats are on-par with Bulbasaur and with the exception of Speed, it beats out its Fire and Grass/Poison counterparts on all counts. It learns its last, and most powerful technique at level 42, so it’s a good idea to wait with evolving it into Wartortle until the last possible moment.

12. Is Charizard a bad starter evolution compared to Venusaur and Blastoise?

In the context of the original Generation I games, Charizard faced challenges due to the prevalence of Water-type Pokémon and its weakness to common Rock-type moves. However, Charizard’s popularity and powerful movepool have solidified its place as a strong and beloved Pokémon.

13. Are starter Pokemon rare?

Yes, starter Pokémon are indeed rare. You only get one opportunity to choose a starter at the beginning of each game, making them unique and valuable companions.

14. Is using an Everstone a good idea?

The Everstone prevents a Pokémon from evolving. This is useful if you want to keep a Pokémon in its unevolved form for strategic reasons (like move learning) or aesthetic preferences. The everstone has a use for breeding, actually. If you give a pokemon an everstone, then put it into the daycare, it will pass its nature onto its children. It’s a very useful item if you want to make battle perfect pokemon! It’s a valuable breeding item as a result.

15. Do any Pokémon get worse when they evolve?

In a few strange cases, some Pokemon are better off not evolving. In terms of competitive viability, there are several Pokemon that are more useful before they evolve than after. This is usually due to a change in stats, a change in typing or a change in what items the Pokemon can use post-evolution.

Making the Right Choice for You

Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to evolve your starter Pokémon rests with you. Consider your playstyle, your strategic goals, and your personal preferences. There’s no right or wrong answer, and the beauty of the Pokémon games lies in the freedom to forge your own path.

Remember that even if you don’t evolve your starter, it can still be a valuable member of your team. With careful training, strategic item usage, and a strong bond, you can overcome any challenge, no matter which form your starter takes.
For more information on gaming and learning, visit the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.

Happy Training!