Should You Lie to Professor Sharp in Hogwarts Legacy? A Comprehensive Guide
The burning question for many Hogwarts Legacy players: do you lie to Professor Sharp after a certain classroom mishap? The short answer is: it doesn’t truly matter. Your decision to own up or deceive him has no significant impact on the overarching story, your character’s development, or your relationships with other characters. However, the choice does offer a small window into the role-playing possibilities within the game, so let’s delve deeper into what happens with either choice.
The Consequences of Honesty
If you choose to be honest and admit to whatever transgression Professor Sharp confronts you about, he will commend you on your integrity. He’ll acknowledge that you are taking responsibility for your actions and will praise your honesty. This interaction reinforces the notion that admitting your mistakes is a positive trait, but it ends there. You won’t gain any special rewards, and this event won’t be referenced later in the game.
The Consequences of Deception
Alternatively, if you decide to lie to Professor Sharp, he will not be fooled. Instead, he will express his disappointment in your attempt to evade accountability. He’ll admonish you for not owning up to your actions and will state you need to start taking responsibility. Again, this choice has no bearing on the main narrative. You don’t face any penalties, and it won’t affect your future interactions with Professor Sharp or any other character.
The Core Takeaway
The key to remember is that both choices offer purely role-playing opportunities. This moment is less about game mechanics and more about how you want your character to behave. The choice is entirely in your hands, and there’s no wrong decision. It’s an isolated event, meaning that there are no major story repercussions. You won’t have any long-term interactions with Professor Sharp. The incident is essentially forgotten and does not influence subsequent events.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some related FAQs to further clarify the mechanics and role-playing aspects of this choice in Hogwarts Legacy:
1. What happens if I lie to Professor Sharp?
As mentioned above, if you lie to Professor Sharp, he will express his disappointment and tell you that you need to take responsibility for your actions. However, this has no major impact on the game, it is just a role-playing moment.
2. What happens if I tell Professor Sharp the truth?
If you are honest with Professor Sharp, he will commend you for your honesty. It will be a minor interaction where he appreciates your integrity. It has no bearing on any other events in the game.
3. Does this decision affect my relationship with Professor Sharp?
No, it does not. You’ll still be able to interact with him for his assignments and main storyline progress. He won’t treat you differently in subsequent conversations due to this singular incident.
4. Does the decision to lie or tell the truth affect the main storyline?
No, it does not. The choice is entirely inconsequential to the main plot. You will not be locked out of anything or rewarded anything either way.
5. Does it change how the other students treat me?
Absolutely not. Other characters in the game won’t even know about this interaction. No student will reference it ever.
6. Is there any long-term consequence for lying to Professor Sharp?
No. There are no long-term consequences at all. It’s a very isolated incident within the game.
7. Does Professor Sharp’s reaction influence my morality in the game?
No, it does not. Hogwarts Legacy has a moral flexibility where choices do not lead to a canonical “good” or “evil” ending. This choice is just part of the game’s open narrative structure.
8. Will Professor Sharp ever mention the incident again?
No, he will not. The interaction is confined to that specific moment. He never references this particular encounter again.
9. Can I redo this decision?
No, you cannot. Like most dialogue choices in the game, the decision is permanent. This underscores the importance of making decisions that align with your preferred playstyle.
10. Does this choice influence any other side quests?
No, this decision does not influence any side quests within Hogwarts Legacy. This is solely tied to the moment within his classroom.
11. Is this moment a test of my character?
No, it is not meant to be a critical test. It is more of an opportunity for role-playing and experiencing the consequences of your choices, however insignificant.
12. Does this choice affect my ability to learn spells from Professor Sharp?
No, it does not. Whether you lie or tell the truth, you will still be able to learn all the required spells from him as you progress through the game. You will still get Depulso.
13. Does Professor Sharp remember what I chose to do?
While technically the game remembers your choice, the characters themselves do not. Professor Sharp will not mention it and treat you as he always has.
14. Can I be punished for lying?
The punishment from Professor Sharp is limited to his verbal admonishment in that moment. There are no further gameplay penalties for lying.
15. How does this choice fit into the overall theme of Hogwarts Legacy?
This choice demonstrates how Hogwarts Legacy prioritizes player agency and choice while not limiting the core gameplay experience. Even small, seemingly inconsequential choices can contribute to the player’s sense of their character’s personality.