Do You Keep the Secret Forever in Hogwarts Legacy? A Comprehensive Guide
The question of whether to keep the Ancient Magic secret forever in Hogwarts Legacy is a pivotal one, directly impacting the game’s ending and your character’s narrative. The short answer is: yes, to achieve the “good” ending, you must ultimately choose to keep the secret forever. However, the path to this decision and its nuances are more complex, involving dialogue choices and the game’s overall morality system. Let’s delve into the specifics of this crucial choice and what it means for your Hogwarts Legacy experience.
The Path to the “Good” Ending
The narrative in Hogwarts Legacy revolves around a powerful Ancient Magic and your character’s role as its keeper. Towards the game’s climax, you’ll face a critical decision point that dictates which ending you’ll experience. To get the “good” ending, you must choose to contain the Ancient Magic within the Repository and vow to keep it secret.
Specifically, this decision manifests in a dialogue sequence with Professor Fig. The correct dialogue choices to secure the best outcome are:
- “I intend to keep it contained here.” This initial choice signals your intention to control the magic.
- Following Fig’s positive reaction, he will ask about the duration of your secrecy. Here, you must choose: “I shall keep it secret forever.”
These choices assure Fig that you’re taking a responsible approach to the potent force. He believes that keeping it secret and contained is the only way to prevent a repeat of past mistakes, especially those of Isidora, who misused the magic. Choosing these options solidifies your position as the magic’s keeper and ensures that Professor Fig will remain by your side, showing his admiration for your responsible decision.
What if You Choose Differently?
While the “good” ending is achieved through the commitment to secrecy, other options exist. However, it’s crucial to understand that while there are three endings in total, they aren’t dramatically different from each other. The core narrative remains largely consistent. Choosing an option other than the described “good” ending will lead to variations in how the Ancient Magic is handled, but will not drastically change the main plot.
For example, selecting a dialogue option like “I intend to keep it hidden for now” instead of “I shall keep it secret forever,” will not have significant consequences. The game allows for some flexibility in your choices while still guiding you toward the ultimate ending based on your initial decision to contain the magic. It is primarily the first decision to contain it that is pivotal to getting the “good” ending.
The Illusion of Choice
It’s important to note that despite the presence of dialogue choices, Hogwarts Legacy does not have a traditional morality system. Unlike some RPGs that track your actions and allow you to become inherently “good” or “evil,” your choices in Hogwarts Legacy primarily influence dialogue and smaller elements of the story, not your character’s overall standing or the grand narrative conclusion.
This is evident when examining the consequences of lying to characters like Professor Weasley or using the Unforgivable Curses. While you might think these actions would dramatically shift the storyline or lead to different endings, they don’t. You can use Avada Kedavra without becoming an “evil” wizard in the game’s lore, and lying to Weasley has virtually no long-term effects.
This design choice means that while you have moments of decision-making, the overarching story pushes you towards the “good” ending if you opt to contain the magic in the Repository.
Impact on Other Characters
Your decisions throughout the game, including whether to tell your friends like Sebastian Sallow the truth about the Ancient Magic, have little bearing on the main story or the overall friendships. Specifically, regardless of whether you reveal the truth to Sebastian, the overarching story remains unaffected. This consistency is designed to keep players on a linear path toward the core narrative conclusion.
The game’s design also dictates the inevitable outcomes for some characters. For example, Sebastian’s confrontation with his uncle is unavoidable. The game allows you to decide whether to turn Sebastian in for his actions, but the events leading up to that point cannot be changed.
Post-Game Content and the Secret
Even after reaching the ending, the game continues to offer content. Hogwarts Legacy has plenty of post-game content, so the adventure continues even after the main story concludes. However, your decision to keep the magic secret remains your character’s established legacy, shaping their role in the game world regardless of whether you continue to explore after the main story.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. How many endings does Hogwarts Legacy have?
Hogwarts Legacy has three endings, but they are not vastly different from one another. They mainly depend on your choice about containing the Ancient Magic and keeping it a secret or not, though the overarching narrative remains similar.
2. Can I play Hogwarts Legacy after finishing the main story?
Yes, the game features a significant amount of post-game content allowing you to continue exploring the world and completing side quests after the main story concludes.
3. Does choosing to lie or tell the truth have consequences in Hogwarts Legacy?
In most cases, no. Choices to lie or tell the truth have little impact on the overarching story or relationships with characters.
4. Does using the Unforgivable Curses make you “evil” in Hogwarts Legacy?
No, using the Unforgivable Curses does not impact your character’s morality in the game or alter the main story. They function simply as tools in combat.
5. What happens if I tell Sebastian the truth about the Ancient Magic?
Telling Sebastian the truth about the Ancient Magic has no impact on the main storyline or your friendship with him.
6. Can you stop Sebastian from killing his uncle?
No, Sebastian’s confrontation and actions towards his uncle are predetermined. You can, however, choose whether or not to turn him in afterward.
7. Does choosing Natty or Sebastian impact the game?
Choosing either Natty or Sebastian for quests and exploration only affects the dialogue and conversations you have, not the overall story.
8. Can I get expelled from Hogwarts in Hogwarts Legacy?
While the thought of getting expelled might intrigue, you cannot be expelled from Hogwarts due to your actions in the game.
9. What is the “bad” ending in Hogwarts Legacy?
The “bad” ending involves your character absorbing the Ancient Magic instead of controlling it within the Repository. This option, still, doesn’t lead to drastically different gameplay or changes to the main story.
10. Can you go to Azkaban in Hogwarts Legacy?
Yes, a Hufflepuff-exclusive quest takes you to Azkaban. This area is exclusive to Hufflepuff house players, allowing them an opportunity to witness Dementors and the Patronus charm.
11. Is Professor Fig trustworthy?
While Professor Fig acts as your mentor and guide, the game does subtly suggest that Professor Fig does have a few secrets of his own, though these are not critical to the overall story. He can still be considered a trustworthy and beneficial presence throughout your game.
12. Can I learn Avada Kedavra without Sebastian?
You can obtain Avada Kedavra without Sebastian through the Dark Arts Battle Arena (if you own the Deluxe Edition or Dark Arts Pack DLC) or by allowing Sebastian to teach you the curse.
13. What happens if I turn Sebastian in?
If you turn Sebastian in, he will be expelled from Hogwarts, and you will no longer be able to interact with him in-game. You also lose the opportunity to learn the Unforgivable Curses directly from him.
14. How long is the Azkaban quest?
The Azkaban quest is a short side mission, but it does provide a unique experience with Dementors and the Patronus charm.
15. Do you go through all 7 years in Hogwarts Legacy?
No, Hogwarts Legacy takes place over a single school year, and your character begins as a fifth-year student. You do not age throughout the course of the game, with no current plans for additional Hogwarts years.
In conclusion, while the choice to keep the Ancient Magic a secret forever is crucial for achieving the “good” ending in Hogwarts Legacy, the game’s structure ensures that all players experience a similar overarching narrative with minor alterations based on the dialogue options selected. The focus is not on a binary good or evil morality system, but instead the players overall narrative experience.