Do You Keep the Secret in Hogwarts Legacy? Unraveling the Choices and Consequences
The burning question on many Hogwarts Legacy players’ minds is: do you keep the secret? The game presents you with a pivotal choice regarding the nature of ancient magic discovered throughout your journey. The answer, in short, is yes, but with nuances. Your decision centers around how you choose to handle this potent and potentially dangerous force. The game’s narrative leads you to a point where you decide whether to contain or reveal the existence of this powerful magic to the wizarding world. This decision is crucial, but it’s important to understand the game’s mechanics surrounding it.
Your ultimate decision stems from dialogue choices made during the final act of the game. The key dialogue options happen when speaking to Professor Fig after facing Ranrok. To achieve what many consider the “good” ending, you must respond to Professor Fig with “I intend to keep it contained here.” He will then inquire about how long you intend to keep this secret. Your correct answer is “I shall keep it secret forever.” This combination will trigger the intended narrative progression for the “good” ending.
However, it’s important to note that while this affects the narrative framing at the end, the core gameplay consequences are minimal. There is no in-game morality system that fundamentally alters your experience based on this choice. Unlike many games with moral choices that impact the game world, your decision to keep the secret here is more about personal fulfillment and how you wish to perceive your character’s actions within the context of the story. This choice contributes more to narrative closure than any major gameplay change. Regardless of your decision, you will face the same final boss, Ranrok, and experience the same ending events.
The Illusion of Choice and the Narrative Impact
Hogwarts Legacy cleverly plays with the illusion of choice. You’re led to believe that your decisions about the ancient magic will drastically alter the story, but ultimately, the main plot points remain consistent. This isn’t to say your choices are meaningless; rather, they shape your experience and understanding of the narrative.
The dialogue choices themselves are very specific when you are talking with Professor Fig after the battle with Ranrok. You will need to pick specific choices for the “good” ending which centers around keeping the ancient magic a secret. However, even if you choose the other dialogue options which include containing the ancient magic here but not keeping it a secret for ever or to control it instead of containing it, you will still get the same boss fight with Ranrok and Professor Fig will still die.
The decision about keeping the secret isn’t a binary one with drastically different outcomes. Instead, it’s about aligning your character’s actions with your personal values. Do you believe this power is too dangerous for general knowledge? Are you concerned about the potential misuse of such magic? Or, do you believe the wizarding world has a right to know? Your choice here is about how you frame the ending, not about an entirely different version of the story.
The Importance of Storytelling Over Strict Moral Choices
While Hogwarts Legacy doesn’t feature a strict moral system, it does offer rich storytelling. Your decision to keep the secret, while seemingly small on a gameplay level, plays a significant part in that narrative. It allows you to reflect on the themes of power, responsibility, and the balance between individual knowledge and the greater good.
Ultimately, the game doesn’t penalize you for wanting to see a different ending or choose different dialogue options. Every student will have access to all three endings regardless of your decision when talking to Professor Fig. The most crucial part of the game is the journey itself and the personal narrative that players create for their character.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are 15 frequently asked questions to further clarify the nature of choices in Hogwarts Legacy, particularly around keeping the secret, along with other relevant game mechanics:
1. Does the “good” ending truly change the gameplay?
No, the so-called “good” ending does not significantly alter the gameplay itself. The primary difference is in the narrative wrapping up the story. It does not provide any additional gameplay content or advantages.
2. What happens if I choose not to keep the secret?
Choosing not to keep the secret results in a different dialogue and narrative framing of the ending. However, it doesn’t change the main plot events or boss fight, and you still seal the magic.
3. Are there multiple ending options in Hogwarts Legacy?
Yes, there are three endings available to all players, irrespective of the choices they make during the game. The differences are in how your character reacts to and handles the magic at the end.
4. Can I go back and make a different choice?
While you can’t replay the very final moment, Hogwarts Legacy does not have a point of no return. You can explore and play after completing the main story.
5. Is there a hidden quest in Hogwarts Legacy?
Yes, there is a hidden quest requiring you to find three Hogwarts secrets and solve associated puzzles.
6. Does my choice about Penny matter?
No, your choice about whether to free Penny is inconsequential. She remains at your side regardless of your dialogue choices.
7. Can I keep the unicorn in Hogwarts Legacy?
Yes, you can keep multiple unicorns in your vivarium, which will provide you with unicorn hair for upgrading gear.
8. Can I get more than one Phoenix in Hogwarts Legacy?
No, you can only find one Phoenix in the entire game, and you cannot breed them.
9. Can I use the Elder Wand in Hogwarts Legacy?
You can use the Elder Wand briefly during a main story quest but cannot keep it after the mission is complete.
10. Can I visit Azkaban in Hogwarts Legacy?
Yes, you can briefly visit Azkaban as part of a quest, but only if you chose a specific House at the start of the game.
11. Where is my secret room in Hogwarts Legacy?
Your secret rooms, including the Room of Requirement and Map Chamber, can be accessed through the Floo Flame map section. Click on the sun icon over Hogwarts.
12. What is the hardest thing to do in Hogwarts Legacy?
The hardest challenge is likely San Bakar’s Trial, which requires taming a Graphorn, known as the Lord of the Shore.
13. Can I prevent Sebastian from killing his uncle?
No, you cannot prevent this event, but you can choose whether to turn Sebastian in after the fact. This choice mainly affects your own experience not the overall plot.
14. Does being evil affect the story in Hogwarts Legacy?
No, choosing to use dark magic or making “evil” choices doesn’t significantly change the main storyline.
15. What is the max level in Hogwarts Legacy?
The maximum level you can achieve in Hogwarts Legacy is level 40.
Conclusion: Choices and the Legacy You Create
In Hogwarts Legacy, the decision of whether to keep the ancient magic secret is more about personal interpretation and narrative closure than a substantial divergence in the game’s plot. While the game allows for different narrative endings based on your choices of dialogue in the final interaction with Professor Fig, it is important to remember that ultimately your experience will stay the same. While the game offers many choices it is ultimately not a game with many big branching decisions. The game is a fantastic experience with or without different choices, it is the overall journey that matters. Whether you choose to keep it hidden forever, or reveal it to the world, you can create your own unique narrative and play the game as you see fit.