Decoding Commander Tax: CMC, Costs, and Conundrums

Does commander tax count as CMC (Converted Mana Cost)? The straightforward answer is no. The commander tax, which is an additional cost of {2} for each previous time you’ve cast your commander from the command zone, does not affect the CMC of the card itself. The CMC remains as printed on the card, regardless of how many times you’ve cast it. Think of it this way: the commander tax is a surcharge, not a permanent alteration to the base price.

Understanding the Nuances of Commander Tax

The commander tax is a unique element of the Commander (EDH) format, designed to discourage endlessly recasting the same commander without consequence. It adds a layer of strategic depth to the game, forcing players to consider the long-term implications of letting their commander be removed from the battlefield. Understanding how the commander tax interacts with other mechanics and card abilities is crucial for mastering the format.

When determining the total cost of a spell, including your commander, remember the order of operations. First, you determine the mana cost of the spell. Then, you add any additional costs, like the commander tax. Finally, you apply any cost reductions, such as affinity or other abilities that lower the overall cost. The CMC is determined before any of these adjustments are made.

Cost vs. Mana Value vs. CMC: The Key Differences

It’s easy to get these terms mixed up, so let’s clarify:

• CMC (Converted Mana Cost): This is the total mana required to cast a spell, expressed as a single number. It is determined by adding up the mana symbols in the mana cost. For example, a card with a mana cost of {2}{U} has a CMC of 3. This value is inherent to the card and doesn’t change based on external factors like commander tax.

• Mana Value: This term is often used interchangeably with CMC, and for most practical purposes, they are the same.

• Cost: This is the actual amount of mana you pay to cast a spell. It can be affected by additional costs (like commander tax) and cost reductions (like affinity).

Why is Understanding CMC Important?

Many cards refer to CMC in their abilities. For example, a card might say, “Destroy target creature with CMC 3 or less.” In this case, the commander tax is irrelevant. You would look at the CMC printed on the commander card, not the amount of mana you actually paid to cast it.

Commander Tax FAQs: Clearing Up the Confusion

Here are some frequently asked questions to further clarify the intricacies of commander tax:

1. Does commander tax affect cascade?

No, cascade triggers are unrelated to the commander tax. When you cascade, you’re casting the revealed spell without paying its mana cost. The commander tax only applies when you’re paying to cast your commander from the command zone.

2. Does commander tax get reduced by affinity?

Yes! Cost reductions like affinity are applied after cost increases like commander tax. So, if you have a card with affinity for artifacts and you control several artifacts, it can significantly reduce the amount of mana you pay, even after the commander tax is added.

3. Does Rooftop Storm negate commander tax for Zombies?

No. Rooftop Storm lets you cast Zombie creature spells without paying their mana cost, but it doesn’t eliminate additional costs like commander tax. You’ll still have to pay the tax if you’re casting your Zombie commander from the command zone for the second, third, or subsequent time.

4. If my commander is Valki, God of Lies, does commander tax apply separately to Valki and Tibalt, Cosmic Impostor?

No. The commander tax is tied to the card itself, regardless of which face you cast. If you cast Valki and it dies, casting Tibalt later will cost you 7BR plus the commander tax (if applicable). The recasting of Valki will also incur the appropriate commander tax.

5. Does commander tax apply to Modal Double-Faced Cards (MDFCs)?

Yes, commander tax applies to MDFCs. If you cast one face of your commander, the next time you cast either face from the command zone, the commander tax will apply. The tax isn’t tied to a specific face but rather to the card’s overall identity as your commander.

6. Can I avoid commander tax by bouncing my commander back to my hand?

Yes. Bouncing your commander to your hand or reanimating it from the graveyard are effective ways to circumvent the commander tax. When you cast your commander from your hand (after bouncing), the commander tax resets. However, putting your commander in the command zone is often better, as the graveyard can be exiled.

7. Does affinity reduce commander tax?

Yes, affinity can reduce commander tax, since it is a cost reduction effect. It will directly reduce the amount of mana you pay.

8. Can you proliferate commander tax?

No. Proliferate only affects counters. The commander tax is not a counter but an additional cost.

9. Does Geode Golem bypass commander tax?

No. Geode Golem lets you cast your commander without paying its mana cost. However, it doesn’t bypass additional costs like the commander tax.

10. Does commander tax apply to the graveyard?

No. The commander tax only applies when you cast your commander from the command zone. If it goes to the graveyard, you can choose to put it into the command zone instead. You won’t be required to pay any additional costs.

11. Does a commander’s background have its own commander tax?

Yes, backgrounds in the command zone have their own commander tax. If a background leaves the battlefield, it is subject to its own commander tax should it be put into your graveyard, exiled, or otherwise leave the battlefield.

12. Is commander tax separate for partners?

Yes. If you have two partner commanders, they are treated individually for the commander tax. The tax applies separately to each commander based on how many times that specific commander has been cast from the command zone.

13. Does Fires of Invention ignore commander tax?

No, Fires of Invention doesn’t offset the commander tax. It lets you cast spells without paying their mana costs, but you still have to pay additional costs.

14. Can Powerstones pay for commander tax?

Yes, Powerstones can pay for the commander tax, but only if the commander spell itself is an artifact spell. The commander tax is part of the total cost, which you pay when casting the spell.

15. Does Commander tax apply to the Prismatic Bridge?

The commander tax is shared by both sides if Esika, God of the Tree is your commander. The commander tax will apply to both sides, so if you cast Esika, the Bridge will also cost 2 more mana for each previous cast of either face.

Strategic Implications of Commander Tax

The commander tax profoundly impacts gameplay in EDH. Players must carefully consider when to cast their commander, weighing the immediate benefit against the increasing cost of future castings. It also encourages players to include cards that can protect their commander from removal or return it to their hand, resetting the tax. Furthermore, it opens up strategic options such as intentionally letting your commander go to the graveyard to then reanimate it, circumventing the commander tax.

Understanding the intricacies of the commander tax, its relationship to CMC, and how it interacts with various card abilities is essential for success in the Commander format. Knowing when to pay the tax, when to avoid it, and how to mitigate its impact will give you a significant edge over your opponents.

This is just one small part of the vast and intricate world of Magic: The Gathering, and if you would like to learn more about games and how they are used to promote education, then check out the work being done at the Games Learning Society, located at GamesLearningSociety.org.