Does Preston Garvey Like the Brotherhood of Steel? A Fallout 4 Deep Dive
The short answer is no, Preston Garvey does not like the Brotherhood of Steel. While he won’t necessarily abandon you if you choose to align with them, his affinity towards you will decrease, and he views their presence in the Commonwealth with suspicion and concern. He sees them as a powerful, encroaching force with unclear motives that potentially threatens the safety and well-being of the settlements he’s sworn to protect.
Preston Garvey’s Distrust Explained
Preston’s dislike stems from his core belief in protecting the common people. He views the Brotherhood of Steel (BoS) as a literal army, arriving in the Commonwealth with advanced technology and a seemingly unclear agenda. This clashes directly with Preston’s values, as he is primarily concerned with the safety and growth of settlements across the Commonwealth. Their technologically advanced weaponry intimidates him, as he is unsure of what is to come if they are to attack the commonwealth. From his perspective, their focus on hoarding technology and their rigid ideology pose a potential threat to the freedom and self-determination of the settlers he is dedicated to helping. He views their actions as potentially self-serving and questions whether they truly care about the well-being of the people of the Commonwealth, or are simply looking to secure valuable technology for themselves. It is therefore understandable why he dislikes the Brotherhood of Steel.
Preston’s core mission revolves around the Minutemen and their commitment to the Commonwealth. His dedication to the Minutemen also contributes to his aversion to the Brotherhood, as the Brotherhood does not place nearly as much concern on the safety of the Commonwealth.
Companion Affinities: Brotherhood Edition
Understanding companion affinities in Fallout 4 is crucial for maximizing their effectiveness and unlocking their unique perks. While Preston dislikes the BoS, other companions have differing opinions. Here’s a quick rundown:
- Likes the Brotherhood: Curie, Danse.
- Dislikes the Brotherhood: Cait, Piper, Nick Valentine, Preston Garvey, Strong.
- Neutral Towards Brotherhood: Some companions, depending on your actions and dialogue choices, may remain neutral.
Keep in mind that performing actions aligned with a companion’s values will increase their affinity, eventually leading to unique conversations and a special perk.
FAQs: Brotherhood, Minutemen, and Companions
Does joining the Brotherhood of Steel make Preston leave?
No, joining the Brotherhood of Steel will not cause Preston to leave you as a companion. However, it will negatively impact his affinity towards you. He will express his disapproval, but he remains loyal to the player.
Can I still complete Minutemen quests if I join the Brotherhood?
Yes, you can. In Fallout 4, the Minutemen are generally neutral regarding your allegiances with other factions until the endgame. You can complete quests for both the Minutemen and the Brotherhood simultaneously until the main questline forces you to choose a side.
Is the Brotherhood of Steel good or bad in Fallout 4?
The Brotherhood of Steel’s morality is complex. They are not purely good or evil. They protect people from threats, but they are also heavily focused on acquiring and controlling technology, which can be seen as self-serving. Their motives and actions often fall into a gray area, leaving players to decide their own perspective on the faction.
What happens if I side with the Brotherhood of Steel?
Siding with the Brotherhood of Steel leads to an ending where they control the Commonwealth, eliminating the Institute and potentially clashing with other factions like the Railroad. You’ll be promoted to the rank of Sentinel and gain access to a jetpack for your Power Armor.
Can you be allied with the Brotherhood and the Minutemen simultaneously?
Yes, you can maintain an alliance with both the Brotherhood of Steel and the Minutemen for a significant portion of the game. However, eventually, the main storyline will require you to choose one faction to support, potentially leading to conflict with the other.
What are the consequences of destroying the Brotherhood of Steel?
Destroying the Brotherhood of Steel results in the loss of their support and resources. You’ll also face their opposition in the Commonwealth. Some companions who like the Brotherhood, such as Danse and Curie, might disapprove of your decision.
What factions are mutually exclusive in Fallout 4?
The primary mutually exclusive factions are the Brotherhood of Steel, the Railroad, and the Institute. Choosing one of these factions to complete the main questline will inevitably lead to the destruction of one or both of the others.
Can Piper be persuaded to like the Brotherhood of Steel?
Piper is generally neutral to positive towards the Brotherhood. Her liking of the faction lies in whether they actually help the people of the commonwealth. While she acknowledges their potential good, she criticizes their technology hoarding and anti-synth policies. It’s challenging to significantly alter her opinion, as it’s rooted in her values and experiences.
What actions does Preston Garvey approve of?
Preston Garvey approves of actions that help settlements, such as defending them from raiders, providing resources, and completing quests that improve their living conditions. He also appreciates honesty and a commitment to the well-being of the Commonwealth’s citizens.
What actions does Preston Garvey disapprove of?
Preston Garvey disapproves of actions that harm settlements or exploit their inhabitants. He dislikes stealing, murdering settlers, and siding with factions that threaten their safety and freedom. He also dislikes decisions that prioritize personal gain over the common good.
What is the best ending in Fallout 4?
The “best” ending is subjective and depends on your personal values and goals. Many players consider the Minutemen ending to be the most morally aligned, as it focuses on protecting and uniting the Commonwealth. However, other endings may appeal to players with different priorities.
Can you avoid killing the Brotherhood of Steel in Fallout 4?
The ability to avoid killing the Brotherhood of Steel depends on the specific route you take through the main questline. With the Minutemen and Railroad, conflict with the Brotherhood is inevitable, but siding with the Institute can sometimes leave room for a temporary truce (until the very end).
What is the strongest faction in Fallout 4?
The strongest faction depends on various factors, including technology, resources, and strategic positioning. The Institute possesses the most advanced technology, while the Brotherhood of Steel has a powerful military force. The Minutemen, while lacking in advanced resources, have the potential to rally the support of the Commonwealth’s settlements.
Can you romance Preston Garvey?
No, Preston Garvey is not a romanceable companion in Fallout 4. While you can build a strong relationship with him and gain his loyalty, the game does not offer a romance option for this character.
How does Fallout 4 explore themes of factionalism and ideology?
Fallout 4 delves deeply into themes of factionalism and ideology, presenting players with difficult choices that force them to consider the consequences of their actions. Each faction represents a distinct set of beliefs and values, and players must navigate these conflicting ideologies to determine the future of the Commonwealth. To explore this theme further, you can check out resources at the Games Learning Society website, which examines the intersection of games, learning, and social impact: https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/.
Conclusion
Ultimately, Preston Garvey’s feelings towards the Brotherhood of Steel are rooted in his commitment to the Minutemen and his desire to protect the Commonwealth. While you can ally with the Brotherhood, it will impact your relationship with him. Understanding his motivations and the broader implications of factional alliances is crucial for navigating the complex moral landscape of Fallout 4.