Table of Contents

How Do I Know if My Card Is Worth Grading?

Determining whether a trading card is worth the investment of grading is a crucial decision for any collector. It’s not just about potentially increasing value; it’s also about protecting your investment and authenticating your prized possessions. In short, a card is worth grading when the potential increase in value, combined with the benefits of authentication and protection, outweighs the cost of grading. Let’s break this down further:

Potential Value Increase: The core reason most collectors consider grading is the prospect of enhancing a card’s worth. Graded cards, particularly those achieving high grades (e.g., PSA 9, BGS 9.5 or higher), typically command higher prices than their ungraded counterparts. Therefore, if you own a card that is potentially valuable and in excellent condition, grading can unlock that potential.
Condition Matters: The condition of a card is paramount. Grading services assess various aspects like centering, corner sharpness, surface integrity, and edge quality. If your card suffers from significant flaws like creases, noticeable wear, or poor centering, the grading process may not substantially increase its value, and the cost of grading might outweigh any potential benefit. Compare your card to grading standards from services like PSA, checking for issues such as centering problems, dinged corners, and creases.
Cost-Benefit Analysis: Grading is not free. The cost can range anywhere from $10 to upwards of $600 per card, depending on the service, the turnaround time, and the card’s declared value. Therefore, before you submit a card, evaluate whether the potential value boost after grading will cover the cost and yield a reasonable profit or represent a worthy investment in the card’s long term protection and preservation.
Personal Value: While financial gains are often the driving force, personal reasons for grading are also valid. If a card holds sentimental value, or if you simply wish to protect it and permanently display it in a sealed case, grading can serve as a form of preservation and display.
Authentication: Grading companies like PSA, BGS, SGC, and CGC act as authenticators. They assess whether a card is genuine and unaltered, offering a layer of trust and confidence for both buyers and sellers. This is especially useful for potentially valuable cards where counterfeiting is a concern.

In essence, to determine if your card is worth grading, consider its potential value, its current condition, the cost of grading, your reasons for wanting to grade it, and the authentication benefits it may provide. If those factors suggest a positive outcome, the card is likely worth grading.

Understanding the Grading Process

What to Look for Before Grading

Before submitting your cards to a grading company, perform a self-assessment using these key criteria:

Raw vs. Graded: Start by determining if your card is already graded. If it’s not, move on to the next steps.
Centering: Examine if the images are perfectly centered both on the front and back. Misaligned cuts could negatively impact the grade.
Condition: Thoroughly check for damage. Are there creases, corner damage, or surface issues?
Value: Check the current market value for your card in similar condition (raw).

How to Estimate Card Value

To understand the potential value of your card, follow these steps:

Identify the Card: Note the player’s name, the manufacturer’s brand, and the year the card was printed.
Use Online Marketplaces: Platforms like eBay can help you gauge prices. Search by “sold for” to see actual sales prices, giving you a more accurate estimate.
Utilize Apps: Apps like CollX are useful for scanning your cards and checking their estimated values.

Factors Affecting Grading Costs

Be aware of what influences grading fees:

Turnaround Time: Faster services usually come with higher prices.
Number of Cards: Bulk submissions may qualify for discounts.
Grading Company: Different grading companies have varying price structures.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)