How to Become an Oathbreaker: A Paladin’s Fall from Grace

Becoming an Oathbreaker is a significant decision for any Paladin character in Dungeons & Dragons (D&D). It involves a deliberate departure from the tenets of your chosen oath, transforming you into a dark and formidable figure. Simply put, you become an Oathbreaker by violating the core principles and tenets of your Paladin Oath. This is often achieved through acts of cruelty, betrayal, or disregard for innocent life. The specific actions that lead to oathbreaking will depend on the initial oath taken by the paladin, the nature of the offense, and the DM’s interpretation of the paladin’s actions within the game world.

Understanding the Paladin Oaths

Before delving into the methods of breaking an oath, it’s crucial to understand the different Paladin Oaths and their core principles. Each oath has unique tenets that guide a Paladin’s actions and define their moral compass. Common oaths include:

• Oath of Devotion: Emphasizes honesty, courage, compassion, honor, and duty. Breaking this oath typically involves acts of dishonesty, cowardice, or cruelty.
• Oath of Vengeance: Focuses on punishing those who have committed grievous sins. Breaking this oath might involve showing mercy to the guilty, acting impulsively without justice, or becoming consumed by vengeance to the point of cruelty.
• Oath of the Ancients: Champions the forces of life, light, and preservation. Breaking this oath might involve desecrating nature, destroying beauty, or abandoning hope in the face of darkness.
• Oath of Conquest: Calls for the establishment of order and the crushing of chaos. Breaking this oath involves allowing chaos to flourish, showing weakness, or failing to seize opportunities for domination.
• Oath of Redemption: Seeks to redeem those who have strayed from the path of righteousness. Breaking this oath might involve condemning individuals outright without attempting redemption, resorting to violence as a first option, or giving up on the possibility of good in others.

Actions That Lead to Oathbreaking

Here are some general actions that might lead to becoming an Oathbreaker, though the final decision always rests with the Dungeon Master (DM):

• Killing an Innocent: This is one of the most direct routes to oathbreaking, particularly for Paladins of Devotion, Ancients, and Redemption. The definition of “innocent” can vary, so context matters.
• Betraying a Trust: Violating a sacred promise or deliberately deceiving someone you swore to protect can break oaths, especially those of Devotion and Vengeance.
• Acts of Cruelty: Torturing or inflicting unnecessary pain on others is a clear violation of most Paladin tenets, leading to oathbreaking.
• Disregarding Justice: Allowing evil to go unpunished or failing to uphold the law when you have the power to do so can break oaths, particularly for Paladins of Vengeance and Conquest.
• Desecrating Sacred Places: Defiling holy sites or engaging in sacrilegious acts is a direct violation of the oaths of Devotion and Ancients.
• Embracing Evil: Deliberately aligning yourself with evil forces or serving a dark power guarantees a fall from grace.

The Oathbreaker Knight and Mechanical Changes

Once you break your oath, the Oathbreaker Knight often appears (especially in video game adaptations like Baldur’s Gate 3), serving as a symbolic representation of your fallen status. In tabletop D&D, the DM takes on this role.

Mechanically, becoming an Oathbreaker usually involves:

• Losing Access to Original Oath Features: You lose access to some or all of the abilities and spells associated with your original Paladin Oath.
• Gaining Oathbreaker Features: You gain access to the features and abilities of the Oathbreaker subclass, as detailed in the Dungeon Master’s Guide. These features often focus on dealing damage, controlling undead, and instilling fear.

Playing an Oathbreaker

Playing an Oathbreaker offers a unique and compelling roleplaying opportunity. You can explore themes of redemption, corruption, or antiheroism. Are you a fallen hero seeking to regain your lost honor? Or have you fully embraced the darkness? The choice is yours.

Here are some points to consider:

• Alignment: Oathbreakers are often, but not always, evil. You can play an Oathbreaker who still retains some sense of morality or who seeks to use their newfound powers for good, albeit through unconventional means.
• Motivation: What drives your Oathbreaker? Are you seeking power, revenge, or simply trying to survive in a cruel world?
• Roleplaying: How does your Oathbreaker interact with others? Are you intimidating, charismatic, or secretive?
• Redemption: Can an Oathbreaker regain their original oath? This is a question best discussed with your DM, as it can lead to a powerful and meaningful character arc. It often involves atonement through acts of selflessness and sacrifice.

Becoming an Oathbreaker is a complex decision with significant consequences. However, it can also be a rewarding and transformative experience, offering a unique perspective on the classic Paladin archetype. Remember to discuss your intentions with your DM and ensure that your decision aligns with the overall tone and direction of the campaign.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Oathbreakers

1. Does alignment automatically change when you become an Oathbreaker?

No, becoming an Oathbreaker doesn’t automatically change your alignment, but it often leads to a shift towards a more neutral or evil alignment. Alignment should reflect your character’s actions and beliefs. If your actions consistently violate your oath and embrace evil, your alignment should reflect that.

2. Can any Paladin Oath become an Oathbreaker?

Yes, any Paladin Oath can become an Oathbreaker by violating its tenets. The specific actions that trigger oathbreaking will vary depending on the oath.

3. Is the Oathbreaker subclass the only way to play a fallen Paladin?

No, the Oathbreaker subclass is just one way to represent a fallen Paladin mechanically. You could also multiclass into another class, or work with your DM to create a custom subclass that reflects your character’s specific fall from grace.

4. How does multiclassing affect oathbreaking?

Multiclassing doesn’t directly affect oathbreaking, but it can complicate matters. If you multiclass into a class with conflicting tenets, you’ll need to carefully consider how your actions align with both your Paladin Oath and your new class’s principles.

5. What are the typical features of an Oathbreaker Paladin?

Oathbreaker Paladins typically gain features that enhance their combat prowess, control undead, and instill fear. Common features include Spiteful Suffering and Dreadful Aspect.

6. Can an Oathbreaker Paladin regain their original oath?

Yes, it’s possible for an Oathbreaker Paladin to regain their original oath, but it usually requires significant atonement and acts of selflessness. The specifics of the redemption process are up to the DM.

7. What is the role of the Oathbreaker Knight?

The Oathbreaker Knight serves as a symbolic representation of your fallen status and often guides you through the process of becoming an Oathbreaker. In tabletop D&D, the DM plays this role.

8. How does oathbreaking work in video games like Baldur’s Gate 3?

In video games, oathbreaking is often more explicitly defined and mechanically enforced. Specific actions will trigger oathbreaking, and the game will automatically apply the changes to your character.

9. Can I choose to become an Oathbreaker, or is it always accidental?

You can choose to become an Oathbreaker by deliberately violating your oath’s tenets. However, it can also happen accidentally if you make a mistake or are forced to make a difficult choice.

10. Does breaking an oath always mean becoming evil?

No, breaking an oath doesn’t automatically mean becoming evil. You can play an Oathbreaker who still retains some sense of morality or who seeks to use their newfound powers for good, albeit through unconventional means. The definition of good and evil are also subjective and depend on the campaign setting.

11. What happens to my divine powers when I become an Oathbreaker?

Your divine powers change to reflect your new status. You lose access to some or all of your original oath’s features and gain access to the Oathbreaker subclass’s features, which often focus on darkness and corruption.

12. How does the DM determine whether an action breaks an oath?

The DM determines whether an action breaks an oath based on the specific tenets of the Paladin’s oath, the context of the situation, and the Paladin’s intentions. The DM may also consider the character’s history and previous actions.

13. Are there specific spells that automatically break a Paladin’s oath?

There aren’t specific spells that automatically break an oath, but using spells in a way that violates your oath’s tenets can lead to oathbreaking. For example, using animate dead might break the oath of a Paladin of Devotion.

14. How does oathbreaking affect my party’s relationship with my character?

Oathbreaking can significantly affect your party’s relationship with your character. They may distrust you, question your motives, or even turn against you if your actions become too evil. This provides an interesting role-playing opportunity.

15. Can a Paladin break their oath and then immediately regain it?

It’s highly unlikely that a Paladin could break their oath and then immediately regain it. The process of atonement usually requires time, effort, and significant acts of selflessness. The DM has the final say on whether and how a Paladin can regain their oath.

The study of games and the way we learn through them is evolving. Find out more about research in the field at the Games Learning Society! You can also visit GamesLearningSociety.org for more information.