How to Secure Sebastian Sallow’s Good Ending in Hogwarts Legacy

To achieve the “good ending” for Sebastian Sallow in Hogwarts Legacy, you must prioritize your friendship with him and refuse to learn the Unforgivable Curses. While you can still participate in his questline, never consent to learning Crucio, Imperio, or Avada Kedavra. Further, when given the opportunity during his final quest, “In the Shadow of the Relic,” actively discourage Sebastian from using the relic’s power. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, do not turn Sebastian in to the authorities at the end of his questline. This ensures he remains at Hogwarts, albeit a changed character, setting the stage for a more positive future for him.

Navigating the Shadow of the Relic Questline for a Positive Outcome

Sebastian Sallow’s questline, “In the Shadow of…,” presents a complex moral landscape. Your choices throughout this questline significantly impact his fate. The core of achieving his “good ending” revolves around maintaining your friendship and steering him away from the Dark Arts’ complete embrace.

Friendship and Dialogue Choices

• Be Supportive (But Cautious): Throughout Sebastian’s quests, support his efforts to help his sister, Anne. However, temper your support with concern about his methods. Question the potential consequences of his actions. Choose dialogue options that reflect this balanced approach.

• Prioritize Anne’s Well-being: Emphasize that Anne’s health and happiness should be the ultimate goal. This shows Sebastian that you care about his family and are not solely focused on the power or knowledge he seeks.

• Question the Unforgivable Curses (Without Judgment): While you should ultimately refuse to learn the Unforgivable Curses, you can still engage with Sebastian’s interest in them. Ask thoughtful questions about their impact and the potential consequences of their use. This demonstrates a willingness to understand his perspective without endorsing it.

Crucial Decisions and Actions

• Refuse to Learn Unforgivable Curses: This is the most critical step. Every time Sebastian offers to teach you Crucio, Imperio, or Avada Kedavra, politely but firmly decline. Learning these curses strengthens his connection to the Dark Arts and makes it impossible to achieve his good ending.

• “In the Shadow of the Relic”: This quest is the culmination of Sebastian’s questline and the final test of your friendship. When confronted with the relic, discourage Sebastian from using its power. Argue that it’s too dangerous and that there must be another way to help Anne.

• Do Not Report Sebastian: After the events of “In the Shadow of the Relic”, you’ll be given the option to report Sebastian. Choosing not to report him is essential for securing his “good ending”. While his actions have consequences, turning him in will severely damage your friendship and lead to a much darker outcome.

The Aftermath

If you make the correct choices, Sebastian will remain at Hogwarts, albeit in detention. He will reflect on his actions and, while changed, will retain a sense of hope for the future. This is the closest you can get to a truly “good ending” for Sebastian, given the circumstances.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Sebastian Sallow’s Ending

Here are some frequently asked questions to help you better navigate Sebastian Sallow’s questline and secure the most positive outcome:

1. Can I still be friends with Sebastian if I refuse to learn the Unforgivable Curses? Yes, refusing to learn the Unforgivable Curses does not preclude you from maintaining your friendship with Sebastian. While it may cause some tension, he will respect your decision if you explain your reasoning.
2. What happens if I learn an Unforgivable Curse from Sebastian? Learning even one Unforgivable Curse significantly reduces your chances of getting his “good ending.” It solidifies his path toward the Dark Arts and can lead to a more tragic outcome for him.
3. Does refusing to learn the curses lock me out of any content? You won’t be locked out of core story content. You will, however, miss out on the ability to use those specific Unforgivable Curses in combat and their related achievements/challenges.
4. Is there a truly “happy ending” for Sebastian? Unfortunately, a completely “happy ending” for Sebastian is not possible given the storyline’s tragic elements. However, choosing the “good ending” path allows him to remain at Hogwarts and potentially redeem himself.
5. What are the consequences of reporting Sebastian to the authorities? Reporting Sebastian will lead to a much darker ending for him. He will likely be expelled and potentially face more severe consequences, severing your friendship and leading to a less optimistic outcome.
6. Can I change my decision about reporting Sebastian later? No, once you make the decision to report or not report Sebastian, it is permanent and cannot be changed. Choose wisely!
7. Do my other housemates’ opinions affect Sebastian’s ending? While other housemates may have opinions about Sebastian’s actions, their opinions do not directly affect the final outcome of his questline. Your choices and dialogue with Sebastian are the primary determinants.
8. Is it possible to learn the Unforgivable Curses later in the game even if I refuse them from Sebastian? Yes. You can learn these curses later in the game from Professor Hecat during the assignment quest “In the Shadow of Discovery” even if you previously refused to learn them from Sebastian. Your choices in this assignment quest don’t affect Sebastian’s ending.
9. Does romancing any particular character affect Sebastian’s storyline? No. Hogwarts Legacy doesn’t have romance options that significantly impact the main storyline.
10. If I don’t complete Sebastian’s questline, what happens? If you do not complete Sebastian’s questline, you will miss out on valuable story content and potential rewards. While it won’t negatively affect the main story, you’ll lose out on a significant character arc and unique magical knowledge.
11. Are there any combat benefits to supporting Sebastian’s darker path? While learning the Unforgivable Curses does provide powerful combat abilities, it comes at the cost of Sebastian’s potential “good ending.” The choice between power and moral consequence is yours to make.
12. What specific dialogue choices are most important for achieving Sebastian’s “good ending?” Focus on dialogue options that emphasize concern for Anne’s well-being, question the ethical implications of Sebastian’s actions, and gently discourage him from embracing the Dark Arts.
13. Does my overall morality in the game affect Sebastian’s ending? While your overall morality isn’t explicitly tracked, your choices within Sebastian’s questline will have a direct impact on his fate. Even if you make morally questionable choices elsewhere, prioritizing friendship and discouraging the Dark Arts during his quests is key.
14. Is Sebastian Sallow a redeemable character? The extent to which Sebastian is “redeemable” is subjective and depends on your perspective. By achieving his “good ending,” you offer him the opportunity to reflect on his actions and potentially choose a different path in the future.
15. Can I re-play the game and make different choices to see different outcomes for Sebastian? Yes, you can replay Hogwarts Legacy and make different choices during Sebastian’s questline to see how it affects his ending. This is a great way to explore the moral complexities of the game and see the consequences of your decisions. Remember to create multiple save files to avoid overwriting your preferred outcomes!