How do you keep villagers from moving out?

Keeping Your Animal Crossing Villagers: A Guide to Island Harmony

So, you’ve finally curated the perfect community on your Animal Crossing: New Horizons island. Each villager, with their unique personality and adorable quirks, feels like family. The thought of one of them packing their bags and leaving you for greener pastures can be downright heartbreaking! The good news? There are several ways to influence your villagers and persuade them to stay. Essentially, to keep villagers from moving out, you need to be an attentive and proactive mayor! Talk to your villagers daily, build strong relationships, and be aware of the subtle cues that indicate they’re considering a move. Neglect and prolonged absence can encourage villagers to spread their wings, while regular interaction and positive reinforcement encourage them to stay rooted on your island paradise.

Building Relationships: The Key to Retention

The most crucial factor in preventing villagers from moving out is building and maintaining strong relationships with them. The higher your friendship level with a villager, the less likely they are to consider leaving.

  • Daily Interaction: Make it a habit to speak to each of your villagers at least once a day. Even a simple “hello” and a quick chat can make a difference.
  • Gift-Giving: Giving gifts to your villagers is a fantastic way to boost your friendship level. Consider their personalities and favorite styles when choosing presents. Wrapped gifts are appreciated even more!
  • Running Errands: Villagers will occasionally ask you to run errands for them, such as delivering items or catching a specific bug. Completing these tasks strengthens your bond and earns you rewards.
  • Responding to Requests: Pay attention to your villagers’ conversations. They may hint at wanting a new piece of furniture or a specific outfit. Fulfilling these desires will make them feel valued and content.
  • Celebrate Birthdays: Remember to celebrate your villagers’ birthdays! Attend their parties, give them thoughtful gifts, and make them feel special on their big day.

Identifying the “Moving Out” Bubble

Be vigilant for the telltale sign that a villager is contemplating a move: a thought bubble above their head. This doesn’t always mean they want to leave, but it’s a good indicator.

  • Approach with Caution: When you see a villager with a thought bubble, approach them and initiate a conversation.
  • Listen Carefully: The villager will explain their feelings, and often express a desire to explore new horizons.
  • The Pivotal Choice: You’ll be presented with two options: encourage them to stay or encourage them to leave. Choose wisely!

Time Travel and Villager Moves

Time travel in Animal Crossing can be a useful tool, but it can also affect villager dynamics. While villagers in New Horizons won’t automatically move out just because you time travel, excessive time skipping can create opportunities for them to consider leaving.

  • Stay Vigilant: If you time travel extensively, be extra diligent about checking in with your villagers.
  • The 15-Day Rule: There is a 15-day rule that many Animal Crossing players swear by. If you have not spoken to a villager for 15 days, they are more likely to want to move away.
  • Avoid Long Absences: Avoid traveling too far into the future without interacting with your villagers.

The “Second Player” Trick (Use with Caution)

There’s a method involving creating a second player character to potentially “reset” a villager’s desire to move, but it’s generally considered less reliable and potentially risky. Some sources say that if you see a villager with the moving-out bubble, you can create a second character, find the villager with the thought bubble, and they may offer the move-out option to the second character instead. If the second character tells them to stay, the original player can still ask them to stay as well. This method is not always reliable. Use with extreme caution! This tactic is not for everyone.

Utilizing Amiibo Cards

Amiibo cards offer a guaranteed method of influencing your island’s population.

  • Invite to the Campsite: Use an Amiibo card to invite a specific villager to your campsite.
  • Convince Them to Stay: Talk to the villager multiple times and complete their requests. After a few days, they’ll agree to move to your island.
  • Replace an Existing Villager: If your island is full, you can choose which current villager the Amiibo villager will replace. This gives you direct control over who stays and who goes.

When a Villager is in Boxes

Unfortunately, once a villager is packed in boxes, there’s no way to convince them to stay through conventional means. They are committed to moving. Time travel will just make them move out faster and will likely auto fill another villager in.

Island Aesthetics

It’s important to maintain an attractive island to entice the villagers to want to stay. Do some landscaping, get rid of weeds, and overall take care of the island as mayor.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. How do you stop villagers from moving out of boxes?

Once a villager is packed in boxes, you unfortunately cannot stop them from moving out using in-game methods. Their decision is final. The only way to change this is to load a previous save file.

2. How do you get villagers to stay on your island indefinitely?

The key is to actively build and maintain relationships with your villagers through daily interactions, gift-giving, errand-running, and fulfilling their requests. Pay attention to their dialogue and respond positively when they express a desire to leave. As long as you maintain these relationships, they’ll be happy to stay.

3. Can I force a villager to stay on my island?

No, there’s no way to completely force a villager to stay against their will. Your influence comes through building strong relationships and encouraging them to remain.

4. Is it true that bullying villagers makes them want to leave?

While some players attempt to get rid of villagers by being mean to them (hitting them with nets, ignoring them), there’s no concrete evidence that this is the most effective method. It’s more likely that consistent neglect is a factor. However, constant negative interactions won’t make you very popular.

5. Can I ask Isabelle to make a villager leave?

Complaining to Isabelle about a villager’s behavior only resets their catchphrase or clothing. It doesn’t influence their decision to move out.

6. Does time traveling affect villagers moving out?

Time traveling doesn’t directly cause villagers to move out, but it can speed up the process if you neglect to interact with them during your travels. Check in with your villagers frequently to ensure they don’t feel forgotten.

7. Can I create vacation homes for all my villagers?

Yes, you can create vacation homes for all of your villagers in the Happy Home Paradise DLC! This doesn’t affect their residency on your main island, but it’s a fun way to interact with them.

8. What are the rarest villager types in Animal Crossing?

Some of the rarest villager species include octopus, non-animal, tiger, cow, bull, lion, rhinoceros, and alligator.

9. Will a villager come to my campsite if my island is full?

Yes, villagers can still visit your campsite even if your island is full. However, you won’t be able to invite them to move in unless you have an open plot or are willing to replace an existing villager with an Amiibo card.

10. How often do villagers ask to leave my island?

The frequency with which villagers ask to leave varies, but generally, if a villager has recently moved in or has expressed a desire to leave and been convinced to stay, it will be a while before another villager asks to move.

11. Why do all my villagers suddenly want to move?

It’s more than likely random. Maybe your town is in bad shape. You could have many weeds, fences broken down, and overall unkept island that is not enticing for residents.

12. Do villagers leave if I don’t play the game for a long time?

Yes, villagers can move out if you don’t play for an extended period. The length of time varies, but neglecting your island and your villagers can increase the likelihood of them leaving.

13. How long does a villager stay at my house when they visit?

A villager will typically stay at your house for around five minutes, longer if you have multiple rooms to explore.

14. Is there a punishment for time skipping in Animal Crossing?

The “punishments” for time skipping are minor, such as waking up with bedhead or finding cockroaches in your house. These are more like reminders of the passage of time than actual penalties.

15. Can villagers open doors in my house?

Villagers can only enter your house if you’re standing in your main room on the ground floor and have a standard wooden door. They can not open fence gates or iron doors.


By following these tips and tricks, you can create a happy and thriving community on your Animal Crossing: New Horizons island, and keep your beloved villagers content and committed to staying!

This article might be a great resource for educators to learn more about how games can be educational. I’d highly recommend visiting the Games Learning Society website at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/ to learn more about the intersection of education and digital entertainment.

Leave a Comment