Table of Contents

How Many Creatures Should I Have in My MTG Deck? A Comprehensive Guide

The number of creatures you should have in your Magic: The Gathering (MTG) deck is not a fixed number, but rather a dynamic element that hinges on the format, your deck’s strategy, and your personal play style. A general starting point for a 60-card constructed deck is around 20-22 creatures, while draft decks usually aim for 15-16. However, this is merely a guideline; the perfect number is whatever maximizes your deck’s effectiveness within the constraints of the format.

Understanding the Creature Count Equation

Building an effective MTG deck is all about finding the right balance between different card types. Lands provide the mana you need to cast spells, creatures provide threats and board presence, and spells offer removal, card draw, and other utility. The optimal ratio of these card types varies significantly depending on the format and your deck’s goals.

Constructed Decks (60-Card Formats)

In formats like Standard, Modern, and Pioneer, you have access to a vast card pool and the ability to carefully craft your deck. This allows for more specialized strategies, which in turn, influences the ideal creature count.

Aggro Decks: Aggressive decks prioritize quickly overwhelming the opponent with creatures. These decks typically run a high creature count, often exceeding 25, focusing on low-cost, efficient creatures that can apply early pressure.
Midrange Decks: Midrange decks aim for a balanced approach, combining creatures with removal and disruption. A typical midrange deck might run 20-24 creatures, focusing on creatures that provide value and can scale into the late game.
Control Decks: Control decks focus on disrupting the opponent’s plans and eventually winning with a few powerful threats. These decks often run a low creature count, sometimes as few as 5-10, or even run completely creatureless, relying on planeswalkers or other non-creature win conditions.
Combo Decks: Combo decks aim to assemble a specific combination of cards that allows them to win the game in a single turn. Some combo decks run few or no creatures, focusing entirely on assembling the combo. Others might use creatures that contribute to the combo, such as creatures that generate mana or tutor for other combo pieces.

The mana curve is also important, and the curve refers to the distribution of mana costs in your deck. An ideal mana curve typically has a higher concentration of cards with mana costs of 2, 3, and 4, with fewer cards costing 1 mana or 5+ mana.

Limited Decks (Draft and Sealed)

In draft and sealed, you are limited to the cards you open in your booster packs, making deck building more about adapting to what you have available.

Draft: Most draft decks aim for 15-16 creatures in a 40-card deck. This allows for a good balance between creatures and other spells like removal and card draw.
Sealed: Sealed decks often require a slightly higher creature count, perhaps 16-18, as you may have less access to targeted removal.

The key to success in limited formats is to prioritize creatures that provide value, such as creatures with enters-the-battlefield effects (ETB), card advantage, or evasion.

Commander (EDH)

Commander (EDH) is a 100-card singleton format where each deck is led by a legendary creature known as the Commander.

Due to the larger deck size, creature count in Commander can vary significantly. A general guideline is to include around 30-40 creatures, but this can be adjusted based on your Commander’s ability and the overall strategy of the deck.
Creature-heavy decks, often built around tribal synergies or creature-based strategies, might run closer to 40 or more creatures.
Control-oriented Commander decks might run fewer creatures, relying more on removal, board wipes, and powerful spells to control the game.

Mana ramp is crucial in Commander, as it allows you to play your expensive spells ahead of schedule. Aim for around 8-10 sources of ramp in your Commander deck.

Factors Affecting Creature Count

Several factors influence the ideal creature count for your MTG deck:

Deck Strategy: As mentioned earlier, the overall strategy of your deck is the primary determinant of creature count. Aggro decks need lots of creatures, while control decks need fewer.
Mana Curve: The mana curve helps determine the right ratio of creatures to non-creature spells.
Format: Constructed decks, draft decks, and Commander decks each have their own unique requirements.
Meta-game: The meta-game, or the popular decks being played in your local game store or online, can also influence your creature count. If you expect to face a lot of aggro decks, you might want to include more early blockers. If you expect to face a lot of control decks, you might want to include more resilient creatures or creatures that generate card advantage.

Experimentation and Iteration

Ultimately, the best way to determine the ideal creature count for your MTG deck is through experimentation and iteration. Playtest your deck extensively, and pay attention to how often you are able to deploy creatures and how effective they are. Adjust the creature count based on your results. This helps you create a deck that reflects your own preferences and play style.

Remember that deck building is a continuous process of refinement and adjustment. By understanding the principles outlined above and diligently playtesting, you can find the perfect creature count for your MTG deck.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What is the “75% Rule” in MTG and how does it relate to creature count?

The “75% Rule” in Commander emphasizes building decks that are powerful and optimized but intentionally avoid being fully competitive. It focuses on fun, interactivity, and creating enjoyable game experiences for all players. With creature count, it could mean choosing creatures for interesting abilities rather than pure efficiency, leading to a higher or lower creature count than a fully optimized deck. It also could be based on budgetary issues.

2. Is there a perfect MTG deck ratio of land, creatures, and spells?

A common, general guideline suggests a 1/3 land, 1/3 creatures, and 1/3 spells ratio, with the majority of spells costing 4 mana or less. However, this is merely a starting point. Adjustments based on your deck’s strategy are crucial.

3. What is a good land ratio for a Commander deck?

While some players opt for around 35 lands, most Commander decks benefit from 38-40 lands. This ensures consistent land drops in the early game, which is vital for developing your board and executing your strategy.

4. How many lands should I have in a 60-card deck?

Traditional knowledge suggests 24-25 lands in a 60-card deck, representing a little over 40% of the total cards. This provides a good balance of mana consistency and spell availability.

5. What is the ideal mana curve for a Commander deck?

Focus on the two, three, and four-mana slots. A balanced mixture of cards in these cost ranges ensures you have plays to make throughout the game.

6. How many mana sources should I have in my EDH Deck?

The typical number of mana sources you should run in your EDH Deck is 43 to 55. Your land base should be between 33 to 40 lands and your Mana rocks should be 10 to 15.

7. How many enchantments should you have in an “Enchantress” MTG deck?

Enchantress decks typically need a high density of enchantments to function effectively. Most players should aim for 20+ enchantments, and some go as high as 30 or more.

8. What is Rule 0 in MTG?

Rule 0 allows players to mutually agree on exceptions or alterations to the official MTG rules before a game begins. It encourages customization and social contracts within playgroups.

9. Is it bad to have more than 60 cards in a Magic deck?

Generally, yes. Having more than 60 cards in a constructed deck dilutes your consistency, making it less likely you’ll draw your key cards when you need them. In almost all cases, the minimum deck size is optimal.

10. How much ramp should a Commander deck have?

A good starting point is 8-10 ramp spells. Adjust based on your Commander’s cost and your deck’s overall strategy.

11. What percentage of a 60-card deck should be lands?

Generally, a little over 40% of a 60-card deck should be lands. 24-25 lands are suitable for a deck.

12. How should I build a 40-card deck MTG?

For 40-card decks, the usual is 17-18 lands, which mean 23 or 22 spells to hit 40. Need a few 1-2 mana cards, bulk in 3-4 mana range, a few in 5-6 mana range.

13. How many turns should a game of Commander last?

The average game ends on turn 10.

14. What is the average commander deck in Magic The Gathering?

The average deck should have somewhere between 34-42 lands, depending on its level of mana ramp, and its synergy with lands specifically.

15. Does the GamesLearningSociety.org have useful resources for improving my MTG skills?

While the Games Learning Society focuses on the broader applications of games in education and learning (https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/), the principles of strategic thinking, resource management, and decision-making that are central to MTG can be related to concepts explored on the Games Learning Society website.

How many creatures should I have MTG?