Is a Rapier or a Shortsword Better for a Rogue?

The choice between a rapier and a shortsword for a rogue ultimately comes down to personal preference and playstyle, as both weapons have their unique advantages and disadvantages, with the rapier offering a better crit range and the shortsword being considered a light weapon. When deciding between these two weapons, consider the rogue’s proficiency, damage dice, and finesse capabilities, as well as the specific combat situation and the rogue’s character build.

Understanding the Rogue Class

Rogues are a versatile class in D&D 5e, exceling at stealth, deception, and melee combat. They are proficient with a variety of weapons, including rapiers, shortswords, and daggers. When choosing a weapon for a rogue, consider their ability scores, fighting style, and playstyle.

Rapier vs Shortsword

Both rapiers and shortswords are suitable weapons for rogues, but they have some key differences. Rapiers are finesse weapons that deal piercing damage, while shortswords are also finesse weapons that deal piercing damage. The main difference between the two weapons is their length and weight, with rapiers being longer and heavier than shortswords.

Frequently Asked Questions

Here are some frequently asked questions about rapiers and shortswords for rogues:

1. What is the best weapon for a rogue?: The best weapon for a rogue depends on their playstyle and character build, but rapiers and shortswords are both popular choices.
2. Can rogues use rapiers?: Yes, rogues are proficient with rapiers, which are finesse weapons that deal piercing damage.
3. What is the difference between a rapier and a shortsword?: The main difference between a rapier and a shortsword is their length and weight, with rapiers being longer and heavier than shortswords.
4. Can rogues dual-wield rapiers?: Yes, rogues can dual-wield rapiers with the Dual Wielder feat, which eliminates the requirement for the weapons to be light.
5. What is the best starting gear for a rogue?: The best starting gear for a rogue includes a rapier or shortsword, leather armor, and thieves’ tools.
6. Can rogues use two weapons?: Yes, rogues can use two weapons with the Two-Weapon Fighting style, which allows them to make an off-hand attack as a bonus action.
7. What is the most powerful rogue subclass?: The Soulknife is considered one of the most powerful rogue subclasses, due to its ability to deal psychic damage and move through enemy spaces.
8. What race works well with rogue?: Halflings are a popular choice for rogues, due to their high Dexterity score and sneak abilities.
9. What are rapiers good for?: Rapiers are well-suited for fencing and dueling, due to their long length and precise tip.
10. Can a rogue use a rapier and a dagger?: Yes, a rogue can use a rapier in their main hand and a dagger in their off-hand, with no penalties except for the off-hand damage bonus.
11. Does the rogue sword stack?: Yes, the rogue sword‘s ability stacks, making it a powerful choice for rogues with high Intelligence scores.
12. What rogue spec does the most damage?: The Outlaw Rogue is considered one of the highest DPS specs for rogues, due to its ability to deal consistent damage and control enemies.
13. How do you make a good rogue?: To make a good rogue, focus on Dexterity and Sneak Attack, and choose weapons and abilities that complement their playstyle.
14. Can rogues use longswords?: Yes, rogues can use longswords, but they are not finesse weapons, so they will not benefit from the rogue’s Sneak Attack ability.
15. What is the difference between a rapier and a shortsword in combat?: In combat, rapiers are better suited for keeping enemies at a distance, while shortswords are better suited for close combat and defending against multiple enemies.