Is Arthur Stronger than John RDR2?

Arthur Morgan is indeed considered stronger than John Marston in the context of Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2), possessing greater physical strength, versatility, and survival skills, which make him a more formidable character in various aspects of the game. The comparison between Arthur and John highlights their unique strengths and weaknesses, with Arthur’s superior combat abilities and leadership skills making him a more effective member of the Van der Linde gang.

Understanding the Characters

To delve into the question of whether Arthur is stronger than John in RDR2, it’s essential to understand the backstory and character development of both protagonists. Arthur Morgan, the game’s main protagonist, is a complex character with a tragic backstory, while John Marston, the protagonist of the first Red Dead Redemption, is a former outlaw trying to redeem himself.

Character Strengths and Weaknesses

Physical Strength and Combat Skills

Arthur’s physical strength and combat skills are unparalleled in the game, making him a formidable opponent in hand-to-hand combat and gunfights. In contrast, John Marston, while an experienced outlaw, relies more on his tactical thinking and experience to overcome challenges.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Who is the better gunslinger, Arthur or John? – Arthur is considered the better gunslinger due to his faster reflexes and accuracy.
2. Can John complete all of Arthur’s missions? – Yes, John can complete almost all of Arthur’s Stranger Missions, except for those related to Mary Linton.
3. Why can’t John Marston swim? – John never learned how to swim, making water a deadly hazard for him.
4. Who is the main antagonist of RDR2? – Micah Bell III is the main antagonist, a ruthless and psychopathic hitman.
5. Is Arthur smarter than John? – Arthur has better survival skills and fighting intelligence, but John’s life experience and tactical thinking make him a formidable opponent.
6. Could Arthur beat Micah without tuberculosis? – Possibly, as Arthur’s physical strength and combat skills would have given him an advantage over Micah.
7. Who is the most loved character in RDR2? – Arthur Morgan is often considered the most loved character due to his complex personality and tragic backstory.
8. Who betrayed Arthur Morgan? – Dutch Van der Linde ultimately betrayed Arthur, contributing to the gang’s downfall.
9. What is the secret ending of RDR2? – The secret ending involves Arthur staying alive, but this is not considered part of the main storyline.
10. How many kills does Arthur Morgan have? – Arthur racks up an outrageous 1,149 kills throughout the game.
11. Who would play the best Arthur Morgan? – Hugh Jackman is often suggested due to his charisma and physical resemblance to Arthur.
12. Who killed John Marston? – John was killed by a gang of U.S. soldiers and Ross in a tragic ending.
13. Who is the youngest character in RDR2? – Jack Marston is the youngest character, being only 8 years old.
14. Who is the oldest character in RDR2? – Hosea Matthews is the oldest member of the Van der Linde gang and a father figure to Arthur and John.
15. What were Dutch’s last words to John? – Dutch told John that “Our time has passed”, signifying the end of an era and their outlaw lifestyle.