Table of Contents

Is Asriel the Villain? A Deep Dive into Morality in Undertale

Asriel Dreemurr, both in his innocent goat form and his corrupted Flowey incarnation, presents a fascinating case study in morality within the world of Undertale. Whether he is the villain is a complex question with no easy answer. Initially, as Flowey, he embodies pure, nihilistic evil, driven by an inability to feel and a desire to experience something, even if that something is the pain and suffering of others. He manipulates, deceives, and attempts to reset timelines endlessly to satisfy his twisted curiosity. However, the game ultimately reveals that this malevolent being is, in fact, the resurrected form of a lost and traumatized child. Through the protagonist’s compassion, Asriel is able to confront his past, acknowledge his actions, and ultimately express remorse. Therefore, while Flowey is undeniably a villainous antagonist, Asriel’s true nature as a victim of circumstance, combined with his eventual redemption, complicates the label, leading to a conclusion where he is better understood as a tragic figure than a purely evil one.

Understanding Asriel’s Transformation

The Innocence Lost: From Asriel to Flowey

Asriel’s initial state is one of innocence and love. He befriends Chara, the first human child to fall into the Underground, and the two become inseparable siblings. Their plan to free the monsters from the Underground, however, ends in tragedy, with both Asriel and Chara dying. This trauma, combined with Alphys’s flawed experiment to bring Asriel back to life without a soul, is the catalyst for Flowey’s creation.

Without a soul, Asriel, now Flowey, is incapable of feeling empathy or love. He retains his memories but lacks the emotional capacity to process them properly. This absence of feeling leads him to experiment with the timeline, seeking any form of stimulation to break the monotony of his existence. His actions, fueled by this emotional void, are unequivocally villainous. He kills, manipulates, and torments others purely out of boredom and a desperate search for meaning in a meaningless existence.

The Path to Redemption

The turning point for Asriel comes during the final confrontation with Frisk, the protagonist. Frisk’s unwavering determination and compassion eventually break through Flowey’s defenses, allowing Asriel’s true self to resurface. He regains his memories and emotions, realizing the gravity of his actions as Flowey.

This moment of realization is crucial. Asriel expresses genuine remorse for his past deeds, acknowledging the pain he has caused others. He destroys the barrier separating the monsters from the surface, freeing them but knowing that he himself cannot cross over, as the power that sustains his form will dissipate once he relinquishes the absorbed souls.

His final act of releasing the souls and apologizing to Frisk solidifies his redemption. He is no longer the villainous Flowey, but the repentant Asriel, a child forced into a horrific situation and given a chance to atone for his mistakes.

Comparisons to Other Complex Characters

The complexity of Asriel’s character is reminiscent of other morally ambiguous figures in literature. The article mentions Lord Asriel from Phillip Pullman’s His Dark Materials trilogy. Lord Asriel, while fighting for a noble cause – the liberation of humanity from the oppressive Authority – often employs ruthless methods and demonstrates questionable ethics, particularly in his treatment of his daughter, Lyra.

Like Lord Asriel, Flowey/Asriel walks a fine line between hero and villain. Both characters are driven by a desire to change the world, but their methods and motivations are often morally questionable. However, unlike Lord Asriel, who remains largely unrepentant, Asriel experiences a genuine transformation, ultimately choosing compassion and self-sacrifice over power and control.

Conclusion: A Tragic Figure, Not a Villain

While Flowey’s actions are undeniably villainous, labeling Asriel as a villain is an oversimplification. He is a tragic figure, a victim of circumstance who was given a second chance and ultimately chose to do good. His journey from heartless flower to remorseful child is a testament to the power of compassion and the possibility of redemption, even for those who have committed terrible acts. Therefore, Asriel is better understood as a complex and sympathetic character whose actions are a product of trauma and circumstance, not inherent evil.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Asriel and Undertale’s Morality

Here are some frequently asked questions to further explore the nuances of Asriel’s character and the moral landscape of Undertale:

Does Asriel remember Chara when he is Flowey? Yes, Flowey retains all of Asriel’s memories, including his memories of Chara. However, due to the lack of a soul, he is unable to process these memories with the same emotional depth.
Why can’t Asriel leave the Underground after breaking the barrier? Asriel’s monster form is sustained by the power of the human souls and monster souls he absorbed. Once he releases these souls to break the barrier, he loses the power necessary to maintain his form and will revert back to dust.
Could Alphys have prevented Flowey’s creation? Arguably, yes. If Alphys had been more cautious and ethical in her experiments with determination, she might have avoided creating Flowey. Her desperation to bring someone back to life led to a flawed process with devastating consequences.
Is Chara evil? The nature of Chara’s morality is a subject of debate within the Undertale fandom. The game’s narrative leaves room for interpretation, suggesting that Chara’s actions are influenced by the player’s choices and their own internal struggles.
What is the significance of Asriel’s final boss battle? The final boss battle against Asriel is a metaphorical representation of Frisk’s ability to connect with and heal those who are suffering. It emphasizes the game’s themes of compassion, forgiveness, and the power of determination.
How does Flowey manipulate Frisk throughout the game? Flowey uses his knowledge of the timeline to manipulate events and guide Frisk towards specific outcomes. He presents himself as a helpful guide initially, but his true intentions are revealed as the game progresses.
What are the consequences of resetting the game in Undertale? Resetting the game wipes the timeline and allows the player to make different choices, but the characters retain a vague sense of déjà vu, hinting at the consequences of manipulating the timeline. Flowey, in particular, is aware of resets and uses this knowledge to his advantage.
Is Undertale a pacifist game? Undertale strongly encourages a pacifist playthrough, rewarding players who choose to spare their enemies. This reinforces the game’s themes of compassion and understanding.
How does Undertale challenge traditional video game tropes? Undertale subverts traditional video game tropes by allowing players to befriend their enemies, offering alternative solutions to conflict, and exploring the consequences of violence.
What role does determination play in Undertale’s story? Determination is a powerful force in the world of Undertale, allowing characters to resist death, manipulate the timeline, and overcome seemingly insurmountable obstacles. Frisk’s determination is the key to achieving the game’s best ending.
What is the significance of the name “Asriel”? The name “Asriel” is derived from “Azrael,” the angel of death in some religious traditions. This connection adds another layer of complexity to the character, hinting at his role as a bringer of both death and, ultimately, redemption.
Does Mrs. Coulter hate Asriel in ‘His Dark Materials’? According to the article, Asriel shot Edward (presumably Mrs. Coulter’s husband) with his own gun, which resulted in her wanting nothing to do with Asriel or her daughter Lyra.
Can Asriel be considered a hero in any way? Despite his actions as Flowey, Asriel’s final act of releasing the souls and destroying the barrier can be seen as a heroic sacrifice, as he puts the well-being of others before his own.
How does Undertale’s soundtrack contribute to Asriel’s character development? The music associated with Asriel evolves throughout the game, reflecting his changing emotional state. His theme is initially melancholic, then becomes distorted and chaotic as Flowey, and finally returns to its original form during his redemption, emphasizing his restored innocence.
Where can I learn more about the themes and messages in Undertale? Explore resources like the Games Learning Society at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/, which studies the educational and social impact of video games. You can also find insightful analyses and discussions within the Undertale fandom online.

Is Asriel the villain?