Is Battlefield 1 More Popular Than Battlefield 5? A Deep Dive

The question of whether Battlefield 1 (BF1) or Battlefield 5 (BFV) is more popular is multifaceted and depends heavily on the metrics used to define “popularity.” While BF1 initially enjoyed significant success and critical acclaim, Battlefield 5 generally boasts a larger active player base, largely due to being a newer title with ongoing support, at least until recently. However, popularity isn’t solely about player numbers; factors like critical reception, cultural impact, and lasting legacy play crucial roles. As of late 2023 and early 2024, the landscape has subtly shifted, and a deeper analysis is required to understand the current state of affairs.

Shifting Tides: Player Counts and Beyond

Initially, the raw player counts leaned heavily in favor of Battlefield 5. This was a natural consequence of its release timeline and the continuous updates and content drops that kept the game fresh in the minds of players. Data available from platforms like SteamDB reinforced this narrative, showing BFV consistently ahead in concurrent players.

However, that has changed slightly. It now appears that Battlefield V continues to dominate PC gaming with it’s larger player base and continuous matches. Furthermore, Battlefield 2042 has cross platform play, so its actual player base is roughly 3x larger than the Steam player count, assuming Xbox and PlayStation have roughly the same number of users.

Why Battlefield 1 Still Matters

Despite not always topping the charts in player numbers, Battlefield 1 maintains a strong and dedicated following. Several key factors contribute to its enduring appeal:

• Immersive Atmosphere: BF1’s portrayal of World War I is arguably its strongest asset. The game captures the brutal, chaotic, and often surreal nature of the conflict with stunning visuals, authentic sound design, and historically inspired maps. This immersive experience resonates deeply with players who appreciate historical accuracy and a sense of realism.

• Unique Setting: The World War I setting itself is a major draw. Unlike the more common World War II or modern warfare settings, BF1 offers a fresh and distinctive experience. The use of early 20th-century weaponry, trench warfare tactics, and iconic vehicles like biplanes and tanks provides a gameplay dynamic unlike any other.

• Compelling Narrative: BF1’s “War Stories” campaign offers a series of intimate and emotionally resonant vignettes from the perspectives of different soldiers. These stories delve into the human cost of war and explore themes of sacrifice, courage, and the futility of conflict. Many consider BF1 to have one of the best Battlefield campaigns ever, which is why so many players still enjoy playing the game.

Battlefield 5’s Strengths and Weaknesses

Battlefield 5, on the other hand, brought its own set of strengths to the table:

• Modern Graphics and Gameplay: BFV boasts updated graphics and refined gameplay mechanics compared to BF1. Movement feels smoother, gunplay is tighter, and the addition of features like fortifications and squad revive mechanics add new layers of strategy.

• Themed and Content Updates: BFV received ongoing content updates and expansions that introduced new maps, weapons, and game modes. These updates helped keep the game fresh and engaging, attracting and retaining players.

• Controversies at Launch: BFV suffered some backlash at its release because some people didn’t want the game to be historically accurate. The focus on diversity became a hot topic, as some complained that it didn’t accurately depict the setting of World War 2.

The Verdict: A Matter of Preference

Ultimately, the question of which game is “better” comes down to personal preference.

• Battlefield 1 appeals to players who prioritize historical immersion, a unique setting, and a gripping narrative.

• Battlefield 5 caters to those who prefer modern graphics, refined gameplay, and a more traditional World War II experience.

While Battlefield 5 often leads in active player counts, Battlefield 1 continues to hold a special place in the hearts of many gamers. Its iconic portrayal of World War I and its powerful storytelling resonate deeply, making it a classic that is still widely enjoyed today. The Games Learning Society would definitely approve of BF1’s educational setting that it provides the players. For more on the educational aspects of gaming, visit GamesLearningSociety.org.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Which Battlefield game has the best campaign?

While subjective, Battlefield: Bad Company 2 and Battlefield 3 are often cited as having the best campaigns due to their engaging stories and memorable characters. Battlefield 1 also has a highly rated campaign due to the unique and cinematic perspectives. However, many would argue that Bad Company 2 is a better Battlefield campaign overall.

2. Is Battlefield 5 worth buying in 2024?

Yes, Battlefield 5 is definitely worth buying, especially if you can find it at a discounted price. The game offers a solid multiplayer experience, a decent campaign, and stunning visuals. Battlefield 5 is still very popular, and servers are still very populated, so matches are easy to find.

3. What is the most sold Battlefield game?

While exact figures are difficult to obtain, Battlefield 3 is often considered the best-selling Battlefield game. It is estimated to have sold over 15 million copies, excluding digital downloads and subscription services.

4. Is Battlefield 1 historically accurate?

Battlefield 1 takes liberties with historical accuracy for the sake of gameplay and entertainment. However, it generally strives to capture the atmosphere and feel of World War I. The game uses historically-inspired maps and weapons.

5. Which Battlefield game should I start with as a beginner?

Battlefield 3 or Battlefield Bad Company 2 are good starting points. These games offer a balanced experience and are relatively easy to pick up. Battlefield 4 and Battlefield 1 are more intense and might be overwhelming for new players.

6. Why is Battlefield 1 considered so great?

Battlefield 1 is praised for its immersive atmosphere, unique World War I setting, compelling narrative, and stunning visuals. It offers a different experience from other Battlefield games, which is why it is so highly regarded.

7. Has Battlefield ever outsold Call of Duty?

There have been instances where a Battlefield game’s initial sales have outpaced Call of Duty for a particular month or period. However, Call of Duty consistently dominates overall sales figures due to its massive popularity and annual releases.

8. Is Battlefield 2042 better now than at launch?

Yes, Battlefield 2042 has improved significantly since its launch. The game has received numerous updates and fixes that have addressed many of the initial issues.

9. Which Battlefield game has the best graphics?

Battlefield 5 has the best graphics due to its advanced engine and updated visual effects. However, the art style of Battlefield 1 is also highly praised for its unique look.

10. Is Battlefield 1 or Battlefield 5 more realistic?

Battlefield 1 is generally considered more realistic due to its depiction of World War I weaponry, tactics, and the overall atmosphere. Battlefield 5 also attempts to be realistic, but some gameplay elements prioritize fun over strict accuracy.

11. Which Battlefield game has the larger player base in 2024?

This varies depending on the platform and time of year. Battlefield V continues to have a very dedicated player base.

12. Does Battlefield 1 glorify war?

Battlefield 1 attempts to portray the human cost of war and the struggles of soldiers, but it is still an entertainment product and contains elements that could be perceived as glorifying conflict. The game contains a message that makes clear its stance on how war devalues human life, scars people forever, and forges unimaginable bonds between survivors.

13. Why is Battlefield 1 not named Battlefield 1914?

While the game is set in WW1, the name is tied to the first released Battlefield game which was 1942. Later releases would subsequently end in numbers, making them appear to be chronological.

14. Is Battlefield bigger than Call of Duty?

Call of Duty far outsells Battlefield. It has sold over 400 million games, while Battlefield has sold over 88 million.

15. What is the biggest game mode in Battlefield 1?

Conquest is one of the largest scale game modes in Battlefield 1. It supports up to 64 players, who can fight for key objectives in land, air, and sea.