Table of Contents

Is CP or Stars More Important in Pokémon GO? Unraveling the Mystery

The age-old question plaguing Pokémon GO trainers: Is CP (Combat Power) or the Star Rating more important? The straightforward answer is that Star Rating, reflecting a Pokémon’s IVs (Individual Values), ultimately holds more long-term significance than CP. While CP determines a Pokémon’s immediate battle prowess, a high Star Rating indicates its potential for future strength and overall value. A Pokémon with high IVs can be powered up to achieve a significantly higher CP than a Pokémon of the same species with low IVs.

In essence, CP provides an immediate snapshot of a Pokémon’s strength, while Star Rating reveals its hidden potential. While a high CP Pokémon might be appealing in the short term for quick gym battles or raids, a Pokémon with a high Star Rating represents a more strategic investment for long-term success. It’s about prioritizing potential over immediate gratification.

Understanding CP and Star Ratings

Before diving deeper, let’s clarify what CP and Star Ratings represent in Pokémon GO.

CP (Combat Power): This is a numerical representation of a Pokémon’s overall strength. It’s influenced by the Pokémon’s species, level, and Individual Values (IVs). Higher CP generally translates to stronger performance in battles. However, CP alone doesn’t tell the whole story.
Star Rating (IVs): After appraising a Pokémon, the game assigns it a Star Rating – ranging from 0 to 4 stars (or a Perfect Pokémon, represented by a red stamp). These stars correlate to the quality of its IVs (Individual Values). IVs are hidden stats that determine a Pokémon’s potential in Attack, Defense, and HP (Hit Points). A 3-star or 4-star Pokémon has superior IVs, signifying a greater capacity for reaching a higher CP when powered up.

Why Star Rating (IVs) Prevails

Here’s why focusing on Star Rating, and therefore IVs, is more advantageous in the long run:

Potential for Higher CP: A Pokémon with high IVs possesses a greater potential to reach a higher CP cap compared to a Pokémon with low IVs of the same species and level. Investing in powering up a high-IV Pokémon is a more efficient use of Stardust and Candies.
Long-Term Investment: While a high-CP Pokémon might be useful immediately, its CP cannot be improved beyond its natural IV limitations. A low-CP, high-IV Pokémon, however, can be powered up over time to become a formidable asset. This is particularly important for Pokémon you plan to use frequently in raids, gyms, and Trainer Battles.
Rarity and Value: High-IV Pokémon are rarer than high-CP Pokémon found in the wild. A 4-star (Perfect) Pokémon is a valuable find and is worth investing resources into.
Performance in Raids and Battles: While CP plays a role, the underlying IVs contribute significantly to a Pokémon’s overall effectiveness in raids and Trainer Battles. A Pokémon with high Attack IVs, for example, will deal more damage.

The Role of CP in Immediate Gameplay

CP does have its place.

Quick Battles: High-CP Pokémon are excellent for quickly taking down gyms or participating in raids where immediate damage output is crucial.
Easy to Obtain: High-CP Pokémon are often readily available in the wild, making them convenient for filling out your team quickly.
Beginner Friendliness: For new players, focusing on CP is a simple way to understand and engage in battles.

However, relying solely on CP without considering IVs can lead to wasted resources and ultimately a less-effective team in the long run.

Making the Right Choice

The ideal approach involves considering both CP and Star Rating:

Early Game: In the early stages of the game, prioritize catching Pokémon with decent CP to build a team quickly. However, start appraising Pokémon and identifying those with high Star Ratings to invest in for the future.
Mid-Game: Begin focusing on powering up and evolving Pokémon with 2-star or 3-star ratings, especially if you have a good move set.
End-Game: Focus exclusively on 3-star and 4-star Pokémon. By this stage, you should have a strong understanding of IVs and the specific Pokémon you need for various battles.

Move Sets

Always consider the move set of a Pokémon. Even a perfect IV Pokémon might be less effective than a Pokémon with lower IVs but a more optimal move set for specific battles. Use online resources to research the best move sets for different Pokémon and battle scenarios. It is a great learning society of people discussing how to learn about the gaming nuances, as well as how GamesLearningSociety.org can improve learning in games.

Powering Up and Evolving

Evolve First, Then Power Up: As a general rule, evolve a Pokémon before investing Stardust in powering it up. This allows you to see its final move set and determine if it’s worth the investment.
Stardust Management: Stardust is a valuable resource, so use it wisely. Focus on powering up Pokémon that you plan to use frequently and that have high IVs and good move sets.

FAQs: Mastering CP and Star Ratings

1. What are IVs (Individual Values)?

IVs are hidden stats that determine a Pokémon’s potential in Attack, Defense, and HP (Hit Points). Each IV ranges from 0 to 15. A Pokémon with high IVs has a greater potential to reach a higher CP.

2. How do I check a Pokémon’s Star Rating (IVs)?

Use the in-game Appraisal feature. Tap the Pokémon, then tap the menu button (three horizontal lines), and select “Appraise.” Your Team Leader will provide information about the Pokémon’s stats and overall Star Rating.

3. Is a 0-star Pokémon always useless?

Generally, yes. 0-star Pokémon have very low IVs and limited potential. It’s usually best to transfer them to free up storage space.

4. Can I increase a Pokémon’s Star Rating?

No, a Pokémon’s IVs and Star Rating are fixed at the time of capture and cannot be changed.

5. Should I evolve a 0-star Pokémon if it has high CP?

It’s generally not recommended. While the evolved form might have a high CP initially, its potential is limited due to its low IVs. You’ll likely find a better Pokémon to invest in later.

6. Is it better to have a perfect Pokémon (4-star) with a bad move set or a 3-star with a good move set?

Move sets often trump IVs. A 3-star Pokémon with a great move set for its type will be more effective in battles.

7. Should I purify Shadow Pokémon?

Purifying Shadow Pokémon increases their IVs but changes their movesets, often replacing powerful moves with more standard ones. It also makes them cheaper to power up. Evaluate the Shadow Pokémon’s IVs and potential before purifying. Some Shadow Pokémon are more powerful than their purified counterparts due to their increased attack.

8. What’s the significance of HP (Hit Points)?

HP determines how much damage a Pokémon can withstand in battle. Higher HP is generally beneficial, especially for defending gyms.

9. Should I keep duplicate Pokémon?

Yes, especially if they have different Star Ratings and move sets. This allows you to build a diverse team for different battle scenarios.

10. Is CP the only factor in determining a Pokémon’s placement in a gym?

No. Placement is generally determined by when the Pokemon are put into the gym, but CP is still relevant.

11. How do I maximize a Pokémon’s CP?

Power up the Pokémon using Stardust and Candies. The higher the Pokémon’s level, the higher its CP. Also, a Pokémon with high IVs will reach a higher maximum CP.

12. What CP range is considered “high” in Pokémon GO?

This varies depending on the Pokémon species and your Trainer level. However, generally, any Pokémon above 2000 CP is considered reasonably strong, and those above 3000 CP are considered powerful.

13. Are Shiny Pokémon always good?

Not necessarily. Shiny Pokémon are visually different but have the same IV potential as regular Pokémon. Their value is primarily based on their rarity.

14. Should I power up before or after evolving?

Evolve first! That way you can see the final move set and decide if you want to commit the stardust to it.

15. How important is Pokémon level?

Pokemon level matters quite a lot. If a pokemon has low CP, then it could be easily defeated in battle, which can affect your game progress. However, you can always use it to take down some low-powered gyms and boost your XP.

Conclusion

While CP provides a quick indication of a Pokémon’s strength, the Star Rating, reflecting IVs, ultimately matters more in Pokémon GO. By focusing on high-IV Pokémon and investing in their long-term potential, you can build a team that excels in all aspects of the game.

Remember to consider move sets, Stardust management, and the specific needs of your team when making decisions about which Pokémon to power up and evolve. Happy catching!

Is CP or Stars more important in Pokemon go?