Table of Contents

Is Elden Ring Based on Bloodborne? Exploring Similarities and Differences

No, Elden Ring is not directly based on Bloodborne, but it undeniably shares DNA with it, as well as other FromSoftware titles like Dark Souls and Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice. While Elden Ring builds upon many of the core mechanics established in the Soulsborne games, it carves its own distinct identity through its open-world design, lore crafted with George R.R. Martin, and a different approach to combat. The games have a shared lineage, but Elden Ring is far from a simple reskin or direct sequel to Bloodborne. The connections lie in design philosophy, core mechanics, and thematic elements, rather than a direct narrative or world link.

Shared DNA: FromSoftware’s Signature Style

The most apparent connection between Elden Ring and Bloodborne lies in their development studio, FromSoftware. Their distinctive design philosophy permeates both games, resulting in several key similarities:

Challenging Combat: Both games are notorious for their demanding combat systems. Players must learn enemy patterns, master timing, and strategically utilize their abilities to survive. The difficulty is a defining characteristic, demanding patience and resilience from players.
Dark and Atmospheric World: Elden Ring and Bloodborne both create immersive and often unsettling worlds. While Bloodborne leans heavily into gothic horror, Elden Ring features a decaying fantasy landscape with moments of profound beauty and grotesque horror.
Indirect Storytelling: Neither game spoon-feeds the player the narrative. Instead, the story is revealed through environmental details, item descriptions, and cryptic dialogue. This indirect storytelling encourages player interpretation and creates a sense of mystery and intrigue.
Emphasis on Exploration: Exploring the intricate and interconnected worlds is a core gameplay element. Both games reward curiosity with hidden areas, valuable items, and challenging encounters.
Character Customization and Builds: Players have a degree of freedom in shaping their character’s stats, equipment, and abilities. This allows for diverse playstyles and encourages experimentation with different builds.
Multiplayer Interaction: Both games feature online multiplayer components, including cooperative play and player-versus-player combat. These interactions add another layer of depth and unpredictability to the experience.

Divergent Paths: Key Differences Between Elden Ring and Bloodborne

Despite their shared lineage, Elden Ring and Bloodborne diverge significantly in several key aspects:

Open World vs. Linear Structure: This is arguably the most significant difference. Bloodborne features a more linear, interconnected world, while Elden Ring offers a vast open world with numerous regions to explore at the player’s discretion.
Setting and Lore: Bloodborne is set in the gothic city of Yharnam, heavily inspired by Victorian-era England and Lovecraftian horror. Elden Ring is set in the Lands Between, a sprawling fantasy world crafted with lore from George R.R. Martin.
Combat Speed and Style: Bloodborne emphasizes fast-paced, aggressive combat with a focus on dodging and counter-attacking. Elden Ring retains a more deliberate and strategic approach, with a greater emphasis on blocking and spacing.
Weapon Variety: While Bloodborne features a smaller selection of unique weapons, they are highly transformative, offering different movesets and tactical options. Elden Ring boasts a significantly larger arsenal of weapons with diverse stats, skills, and scaling.
Magic System: Elden Ring features a more robust and versatile magic system, allowing players to cast a wide array of spells and incantations. Bloodborne’s magic system is more limited, primarily relying on quicksilver bullets and specialized weapons.
Customization: Elden Ring lets you customize your character, allowing you to choose your appearance, class, and stats. Bloodborne, on the other hand, only allows players to customize their gender, face, and origin.

The Impact of Bloodborne: A Foundation for Innovation

While Elden Ring isn’t directly based on Bloodborne, the latter undoubtedly influenced its development. Bloodborne’s success demonstrated FromSoftware’s ability to create compelling and challenging action RPGs with unique settings and combat mechanics. This experience paved the way for Elden Ring’s ambitious open-world design and its blend of fantasy and horror elements. Bloodborne served as a crucial stepping stone in FromSoftware’s evolution, allowing them to experiment with new ideas and refine their signature style.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here are 15 frequently asked questions about the relationship between Elden Ring and Bloodborne:

1. Is Elden Ring a sequel to Bloodborne?

No, Elden Ring is not a sequel to Bloodborne. They are set in completely different universes with distinct lore, characters, and settings.

2. Are there any direct references to Bloodborne in Elden Ring?

While there are no explicit references to Bloodborne in Elden Ring’s narrative, some subtle design elements and enemy types evoke a similar aesthetic. These are more likely attributed to FromSoftware’s signature style than deliberate connections.

3. Which game is more difficult, Elden Ring or Bloodborne?

The difficulty is subjective and depends on individual playstyle and preferences. Some players find Bloodborne’s faster combat more challenging, while others struggle with Elden Ring’s vast open world and diverse enemy encounters.

4. Can I play Elden Ring if I haven’t played Bloodborne?

Absolutely! While experiencing Bloodborne might offer some insight into FromSoftware’s design philosophy, it is not a prerequisite for enjoying Elden Ring.

5. Does Elden Ring have trick weapons like Bloodborne?

No, Elden Ring does not feature weapons that transform into different forms like Bloodborne’s trick weapons. However, many weapons have unique weapon arts and skills that offer varied combat options.

6. Is there a Bloodborne remake coming to PC and PlayStation 5?

There have been rumors and speculations regarding a Bloodborne remake or remaster for PC and PlayStation 5, but nothing official has been announced by FromSoftware or Sony Interactive Entertainment.

7. Is the combat in Elden Ring faster than in Bloodborne?

No, Bloodborne’s combat is generally considered faster and more aggressive than Elden Ring’s. Elden Ring favors a more deliberate and strategic approach.

8. Does Elden Ring have a sanity meter like Bloodborne?

No, Elden Ring does not feature a sanity meter or insight system similar to Bloodborne.

9. Is Elden Ring’s world as interconnected as Bloodborne’s?

Bloodborne’s world is more tightly interconnected, featuring branching paths and shortcuts that loop back on themselves. Elden Ring’s open world is less interconnected in that specific way, prioritizing vastness over intricate level design.

10. Which game has better boss fights, Elden Ring or Bloodborne?

This is subjective. Both games feature challenging and memorable boss fights. Some prefer Bloodborne’s grotesque and aggressive bosses, while others favor Elden Ring’s larger scale and more diverse boss encounters.

11. Is there a cure for the Frenzied Flame in Elden Ring similar to the Bloodborne cure?

While there are parallels in themes of bodily and mental corruption, Elden Ring’s Frenzied Flame ending has specific solutions tied to the game’s lore and characters, not a direct “cure” in the same way as some ailments in Bloodborne.

12. Is the lore in Elden Ring as deep and mysterious as Bloodborne’s?

Yes, both Elden Ring and Bloodborne feature incredibly deep and mysterious lore. Both require players to piece together the narrative through environmental details, item descriptions, and character interactions.

13. Does Elden Ring borrow any enemy designs from Bloodborne?

While there are no direct copies, some enemy designs in Elden Ring share aesthetic similarities with enemies from Bloodborne, reflecting FromSoftware’s recurring design motifs.

14. Is Bloodborne 2 in development?

As of the current date, there is no confirmed Bloodborne 2 in development. Despite high demand from fans, FromSoftware has not announced any plans for a sequel.

15. Which game should I play first if I’m new to FromSoftware games?

This depends on personal preference. Elden Ring might be more accessible due to its open world and diverse gameplay options. However, Bloodborne’s tighter focus and more streamlined experience can also be a good starting point. Ultimately, choose the game that appeals to you the most.

In conclusion, while Elden Ring and Bloodborne share a common ancestry through FromSoftware, they are distinct games with unique identities. Elden Ring is not based on Bloodborne in a direct, narrative sense, but it benefits from the lessons learned and the foundation laid by its predecessor. Both games offer challenging, rewarding, and unforgettable experiences for players who enjoy action RPGs with deep lore and demanding combat.

Is Elden Ring based on Bloodborne?