Is FIFA 23 Better on Old Gen or New Gen? A Comprehensive Guide
The burning question for many FIFA fans revolves around the optimal platform for enjoying FIFA 23: is it better on old-gen consoles (PS4, Xbox One) or new-gen consoles (PS5, Xbox Series X/S)? The short answer is, it depends on what you prioritize, but objectively, new-gen consoles offer a superior experience, albeit with some nuances that might make old-gen more appealing to some players. This article dives deep into the differences, analyzing gameplay, features, and overall user experience to help you decide which version is right for you.
New Gen vs. Old Gen: Key Differences
The core distinction lies in the technology powering each version. New-gen versions of FIFA 23 benefit from HyperMotion2 technology, a significant leap in animation and realism. This feature is completely absent on old-gen consoles. Let’s break down the impact:
HyperMotion2 Technology
HyperMotion2 is the headline feature of FIFA 23 on new-gen consoles and PC. It employs machine learning and advanced motion capture to create more fluid, realistic animations and a more immersive matchday experience. This translates to more natural player movements, better responsiveness, and an overall smoother gameplay feel. On the other hand, old-gen versions of FIFA 23 lack HyperMotion, resulting in gameplay that, while still enjoyable, feels noticeably less advanced and more akin to previous iterations of the series.
Gameplay Feel and Responsiveness
The impact of HyperMotion2 is felt most acutely in the gameplay responsiveness. New-gen FIFA 23 feels significantly more fluid, with smoother transitions between animations and player actions. Players react more quickly to inputs, allowing for greater control over the flow of the game. Old-gen gameplay feels noticeably less refined, with a somewhat clunkier and less responsive feel. Some players actually prefer this more predictable style of play found on the older version. This is crucial point as many report that they find new-gen FIFA 23 gameplay to be inferior despite its improved graphics and animations.
AcceleRATE System
Another key difference is the AcceleRATE system, which is present on new-gen consoles and PC, but absent on old-gen consoles. This system categorizes players based on their acceleration style (Controlled, Explosive, Lengthy). This further complicates things, with many players on new-gen experiencing poor gameplay as their players don’t fit the meta.
Visual Fidelity and Graphics
New-gen consoles also offer significant improvements in visual quality. FIFA 23 on PS5 and Xbox Series X/S boasts higher resolutions, better textures, and more detailed player models, resulting in a much more visually impressive experience. Old-gen versions of the game, while still competent, appear less polished and detailed.
Matchday Experience
The matchday experience on new-gen is further enhanced with improved stadium details, crowd animations, and pre-match presentations. These elements contribute to a more immersive and authentic footballing atmosphere. Old-gen versions offer a simpler presentation, with fewer details and less dynamic animations.
Dual Entitlement and Upgrades
It’s crucial to understand that purchasing the Standard Edition of FIFA 23 does not include dual entitlement. This means that if you purchase the game on PS4 and later upgrade to a PS5, you’d need to purchase the PS5 version separately to enjoy the new-gen features. However, the Ultimate Edition does come with dual entitlement, allowing you to upgrade from PS4 to PS5 (or Xbox One to Xbox Series X/S) at no additional cost.
Player Preferences
While new-gen offers superior technology, many players still prefer the smoother, more predictable gameplay of old-gen. Some players feel that new-gen gameplay is too fast-paced and less intuitive, and that the changes are not an improvement. They may also find the animations to be a bit too chaotic, or that the gameplay feel is just not what they expect. Ultimately, preference is subjective.
Conclusion: Which Version Should You Play?
Objectively, the new-gen versions of FIFA 23 provide a superior technological experience with enhanced graphics, HyperMotion2 technology, and a more immersive matchday atmosphere. However, if you prioritize a more predictable, less responsive but potentially smoother, and more stable gameplay, the old-gen version might be your preferred choice.
If you value the latest advancements in gaming technology and want to experience football simulation at its finest, FIFA 23 on PS5 or Xbox Series X/S is the clear winner. However, if you are accustomed to the feel of previous FIFA iterations or prefer a more straightforward experience, the old-gen version on PS4 or Xbox One may be a better fit for you.
Ultimately, the “better” version depends entirely on your priorities and preferences.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Does FIFA 23 have cross-play between old and new gen?
Yes, but only within the same console family. You can play with players on the same generation of consoles. This means PS4 players can play with other PS4 players, and PS5 players can play with other PS5 players, but PS4 players can’t play with PS5 players. The same applies for Xbox One and Xbox Series X/S.
2. Can I play old-gen FIFA 23 on new-gen consoles?
Yes, you can play the old-gen version of FIFA 23 on your new-gen console via backward compatibility. However, you will not be able to benefit from the new-gen features such as HyperMotion2.
3. Is HyperMotion Technology available on old-gen consoles?
No, HyperMotion2 technology is exclusive to new-gen consoles (PS5, Xbox Series X/S) and PC. It is not available on PS4, Xbox One, or other old-gen consoles.
4. Does AcceleRATE work on old-gen FIFA 23?
No, the AcceleRATE system is only present on new-gen consoles (PS5, Xbox Series X/S) and PC. It does not affect player behavior in the old-gen versions.
5. What are the best career mode players in FIFA 23?
Some of the players with the highest potential in Career Mode are:
- Kylian Mbappé (Paris Saint-Germain) – 95 Potential OVR
- Erling Haaland (Manchester City) – 94 Potential OVR
- Pedri (FC Barcelona) – 93 Potential OVR
- Phil Foden (Manchester City) – 92 Potential OVR
- Gianluigi Donnarumma – Paris Saint-Germain – 92 Potential OVR
6. What is the most popular mode in FIFA 23?
Ultimate Team and Career Mode are considered the most popular game modes, but there are many other ways to enjoy FIFA 23, including various online and offline modes.
7. Can I upgrade from old-gen to new-gen FIFA 23?
Yes, but only if you purchased the Ultimate Edition. The standard edition does not offer a free upgrade, and you would need to purchase the new-gen version separately.
8. Is FIFA 23 worth buying on PS4 or Xbox One?
Yes, if you do not have access to a new-gen console, FIFA 23 on PS4 or Xbox One is a decent experience. It offers a solid football simulation with a robust set of features. However, it lacks the technological advancements and visual fidelity of the new-gen versions.
9. Why do some players prefer old-gen FIFA 23 gameplay?
Some players prefer old-gen because they find the gameplay smoother and more predictable, with less reliance on the new mechanics such as HyperMotion2. They might also find that the new gen has too many changes, making the game feel more chaotic than previous versions.
10. Is FIFA 23 harder on new-gen?
Some players have reported that FIFA 23 feels more challenging on new-gen consoles due to the faster pace and responsiveness, while others find it easier to control.
11. Does old-gen have lengthy players?
No, the new running styles and the associated “lengthy” player characteristic are not present on old-gen versions.
12. What is the best formation in old-gen FIFA 23?
The 4-2-3-1 formation is often considered a strong choice in old-gen FIFA 23 due to its balance and attacking options.
13. Is FIFA 24 available on old-gen consoles?
Yes, EA Sports FC 24 (successor to FIFA) is playable on PS4 and Xbox One, indicating a continuing support for older generation consoles.
14. What is the fastest acceleration player in FIFA 23?
Kylian Mbappé has the highest pace attribute in FIFA 23, making him the fastest player.
15. What is the most sold FIFA game?
FIFA 18 holds the record for the most units sold, with 26.4 million.