Is There a Big Difference Between G29 and G923? A Deep Dive into Logitech’s Racing Wheels
The short answer? Not really, no. The Logitech G923 offers a slightly enhanced experience over the G29, primarily due to its Trueforce feedback system. However, the practical difference for many users, especially beginners, is minimal. The core mechanics, build quality, and overall feel remain remarkably similar. If you already own a G29, upgrading to the G923 probably isn’t worth the investment unless you’re a hardcore sim racer seeking every last nuance. The improvements are subtle, not revolutionary.
G29 vs. G923: A Detailed Comparison
Let’s break down the key areas where these two racing wheels differ and assess their impact on the sim racing experience:
Force Feedback: The Trueforce Factor
This is the main differentiator between the G29 and G923. The G923 features Logitech’s Trueforce technology, designed to provide a more realistic and detailed force feedback experience. Trueforce aims to connect you to the game’s physics engine, delivering vibrations and sensations based on engine sounds, road textures, and more.
In reality, the effectiveness of Trueforce is game-dependent. Some titles integrate it well, offering a noticeable improvement in immersion. Others, however, don’t fully utilize its capabilities, resulting in a less pronounced difference from the G29’s standard force feedback. Some users have even reported that Trueforce can feel more artificial and distracting than the G29’s more traditional force feedback. This is because it relies heavily on audio cues, which might not always accurately represent the forces acting on the car.
Design and Build Quality: Minimal Changes
Externally, the G29 and G923 are virtually identical. Both feature a leather-wrapped wheel, sturdy construction, and a similar button layout. The pedal sets are also nearly identical, although the G923 boasts a progressive spring on the brake pedal, aiming to provide a more realistic braking feel.
The G923’s progressive brake pedal is a welcome improvement, offering slightly more resistance as you press down, mimicking the feeling of a real brake pedal. However, the difference isn’t dramatic, and many users find it subtle. The G923 is also available in a single color scheme only, while the G29 is available in both Playstation and Xbox variants.
Noise Levels: A Concerning Issue
One area where the G923 arguably regresses is noise. Both wheels utilize a gear-driven force feedback system, which is inherently noisier than belt-driven alternatives found in more expensive wheels. However, some users have reported that the G923 is even louder than the G29, with the Trueforce vibrations adding to the clunking and rattling sounds. This can be a significant issue, especially if you live in a shared space or play late at night.
Price and Value: The Deciding Factor
The G29 is typically more affordable than the G923. Given the relatively minor improvements offered by the G923, the G29 often represents better value for money, especially for beginners. If you’re on a budget or unsure about committing to sim racing, the G29 is an excellent entry point.
Who Should Buy Which?
- Buy the G29 if: You’re new to sim racing, on a budget, or prioritize value for money. You prefer a tried-and-tested force feedback system without the potential drawbacks of Trueforce.
- Buy the G923 if: You’re a mid-tier sim racer looking for a slightly more immersive experience, particularly in games that well-implement Trueforce. Price is less of a concern, and you’re willing to experiment with new technology.
Ultimately, the choice between the G29 and G923 depends on your individual needs and preferences. Carefully consider the factors discussed above and weigh the pros and cons before making a decision. Explore the GamesLearningSociety.org website, to learn more about the intersection of games and the future of immersive experiences.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Is the Logitech G29 discontinued?
No, the Logitech G29 is not discontinued. While it has been succeeded by the G923, it remains available for sale and continues to be a popular choice among sim racers.
2. Is G29 a good first wheel?
Absolutely! The G29 is an excellent first wheel for anyone looking to get into sim racing. It offers a good balance of features, performance, and affordability.
3. Is the Logitech G923 worth it in 2023?
Whether the G923 is worth it in 2023 depends on your individual needs and priorities. If you’re looking for the absolute best value, the G29 may be a better choice. However, if you’re willing to pay a premium for the slightly enhanced features of the G923, it can be a worthwhile investment, especially if you like the Games Learning Society’s games.
4. Is G29 still worth it?
Yes, the G29 is still a very worthwhile purchase in 2023. It remains a competitive option in its price range, offering a solid force feedback experience and durable build quality.
5. Is the G923 quieter than the G29?
Unfortunately, the G923 is not quieter than the G29. In fact, some users have reported that it is even louder, due to the Trueforce feedback system adding to the existing gear-driven noise.
6. Are the G923 pedals better?
The G923 pedals are slightly better than the G29 pedals, primarily due to the progressive spring on the brake pedal. This provides a more realistic and responsive braking feel, although the difference is not dramatic.
7. What is better than G29?
While the G29 is a great wheel, there are better options available at higher price points. The Thrustmaster T300RS is an excellent alternative, offering stronger and smoother force feedback due to its belt-driven system. More advanced wheels like Fanatec offer higher-end options.
8. Why is Logitech G29 so expensive?
The Logitech G29’s price is justified by its high-quality construction, force feedback system, and included pedal set. While it may seem expensive compared to a standard controller, it offers a significantly more immersive and realistic racing experience.
9. Is G29 real leather?
Yes, the Logitech G29 wheel is covered in high-quality, hand-stitched leather. This provides a comfortable and premium feel.
10. Does G29 come with pedals?
Yes, the G29 includes a 3-pedal set, consisting of the throttle, brake, and clutch pedals.
11. Is the G923 discontinued?
No, the G923 is not discontinued. It is still being sold alongside the Pro Wheel, catering to different segments of the sim racing market.
12. Can you drift with g923?
Yes, you can drift with the G923. While it may not be the ideal wheel for drifting due to its gear-driven force feedback, it is certainly capable of providing a fun and engaging drifting experience.
13. Which one is better G29 or G920?
The G29 is generally considered better than the G920. The main difference is that the G29 includes a clutch pedal, while the G920 does not. The G29 is designed for PlayStation, while the G920 is designed for Xbox. If you plan to use the wheel on PC, the G29 is generally the preferred choice.
14. What is the best Logitech wheel?
The “best” Logitech wheel depends on your budget and needs. The Logitech G Pro Wheel is Logitech’s top-of-the-line offering, but it comes at a premium price. For most users, the G29 or G923 provide a good balance of features and affordability.
15. Why is the G923 so loud?
The G923 is loud due to its gear-driven force feedback system. This system relies on gears to transmit forces to the wheel, which can create rattling and clunking noises. The Trueforce feedback technology in the G923 can further amplify these noises.