Table of Contents

Is Thorns Worth It in Minecraft? A Deep Dive

The short answer: it depends. Thorns can be incredibly powerful, even game-changing, in specific situations, but it also comes with a significant drawback: increased armor durability loss. Whether it’s “worth it” hinges on your playstyle, how well-equipped you are, and what you’re trying to achieve. For players prioritizing raw damage output and aggressive tactics, and who have access to repair methods like Mending, Thorns can be a valuable asset. For more cautious players or those without reliable armor repair, the durability penalty might outweigh the benefits. Let’s break down the pros and cons to help you decide if Thorns is right for you.

Understanding the Thorns Enchantment

How Thorns Works

The Thorns enchantment adds a chance for your armor to reflect damage back at attackers when they physically strike you. This applies to both mobs and other players. Each piece of armor with Thorns has an independent chance to trigger the effect, but the damage dealt is capped. Higher levels of Thorns increase the chance of triggering the effect and the amount of damage reflected.

The Downside: Durability Loss

This is the crucial factor to consider. Every time Thorns triggers, it applies an additional durability penalty of 2 points to one piece of your Thorns-enchanted armor, chosen at random. This is on top of the durability damage you normally take from the attack itself. This means your armor will degrade significantly faster, especially if you’re constantly engaged in combat.

The Upside: Damage and AFK Farming

The main benefit of Thorns is the extra damage it deals to attackers. This can be surprisingly effective against hordes of mobs, significantly speeding up combat encounters. At higher levels, especially with Thorns III and combined with powerful armor like Protection IV Netherite, you can even achieve a level of passive mob farming. Mobs will essentially kill themselves attacking you, allowing you to remain relatively AFK (Away From Keyboard).

Assessing Your Situation

Before you commit to Thorns, ask yourself these questions:

Do I have access to Mending? This is the single most important factor. Mending allows you to repair your armor using experience orbs, effectively negating the durability loss from Thorns. If you have a reliable XP farm, the durability penalty becomes a minor inconvenience.
What type of armor am I using? Thorns is much more viable on durable armor like diamond or netherite, as these can withstand the increased wear and tear. Using Thorns on leather or iron armor is generally not recommended unless you have a specific reason.
What’s my playstyle? If you tend to avoid direct combat or prioritize dodging attacks, Thorns will be less effective. It’s best suited for players who are comfortable engaging in melee combat and taking hits.
What am I trying to accomplish? Are you looking for a way to passively farm mobs, or are you just trying to gain an edge in PvP combat? The value of Thorns will vary depending on your goals.

Optimal Thorns Setup

If you decide to use Thorns, here’s how to maximize its effectiveness:

Max Out Thorns: Aim for Thorns III on all your armor pieces. The increased chance of triggering the effect is worth the effort.
Prioritize Protection: Combine Thorns with other defensive enchantments like Protection IV, Unbreaking III, and, most importantly, Mending I.
Netherite is Ideal: Netherite armor offers superior durability and protection compared to diamond, making it the best choice for a Thorns build.
XP Farm Required: If you plan to rely heavily on Thorns, having a reliable XP farm is essential to keep your armor repaired.

Alternatives to Thorns

If you’re concerned about the durability penalty, consider these alternatives:

Sharpness/Smite/Bane of Arthropods: Focus on increasing your damage output with your weapon instead. These enchantments are more efficient at killing mobs quickly.
Knockback: Keep mobs at a distance to minimize the damage you take.
Fire Aspect: Light mobs on fire, dealing damage over time.
Enchantments focused on defense, such as Protection.

Thorns in Different Game Modes

Survival: Where durability is critical, Thorns is best used with Mending or on high durability armor.
Hardcore: The risk of permanent armor loss makes Thorns a more dangerous choice.
Creative: Durability is irrelevant, so Thorns can be freely used for its damage output.
Multiplayer/PvP: Thorns can be a decent deterrent, but opponents can play around it, and focus on dealing with it.

Conclusion: Is Thorns Right for You?

Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to use Thorns depends on your individual circumstances. If you’re willing to invest in Mending and have a reliable XP source, Thorns can be a powerful tool for aggressive players. However, if you’re more cautious or lack the resources to repair your armor, you may be better off focusing on other enchantments. Careful consideration is needed.

Keep up with the latest research on games, learning, and society at the Games Learning Society, or GamesLearningSociety.org, to stay informed about how games are changing education and beyond!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Does Thorns work on the Wither?

No, not effectively. The Wither primarily attacks with projectiles, so it rarely makes physical contact with your armor. The durability penalty from Thorns is unlikely to be worth the minimal damage reflected.

2. Can Thorns and Mending be combined?

Yes! This is the key to making Thorns viable. Mending allows you to repair your armor using experience orbs, effectively negating the durability loss from Thorns. You can combine enchantments using an anvil.

3. Should I put Thorns on all my armor pieces?

Yes, if you’re committed to a Thorns build. Each piece of Thorns-enchanted armor has its own independent chance to trigger, increasing the overall effectiveness. However, the durability penalty will also be applied more frequently.

4. Does Thorns 3 stack in Minecraft?

While you can wear multiple pieces of Thorns armor, the damage itself doesn’t stack, however, the independent chances of proccing stack, making for a more likely proc. The damage is capped, but each piece adds another chance to activate the effect.

5. Does Looting affect Thorns kills?

Yes. If Thorns deals the final blow to a mob while you’re holding a sword with Looting, the Looting effect will apply, increasing the drops you receive.

6. What is the best enchantment for pickaxe in Minecraft?

The best enchantments for a pickaxe depend on your priorities, but a good all-around setup includes:

Efficiency V: Increases mining speed.
Fortune III: Increases the chance of rare drops.
Silk Touch: Allows you to mine blocks without breaking them.
Unbreaking III: Increases durability.
Mending I: Repairs the pickaxe with experience orbs.

7. Is Thorns good in Minecraft Dungeons?

Yes, Thorns can be very strong in Minecraft Dungeons. The damage scaling is more significant than in the base game, making it a powerful defensive option.

8. Does Thorns affect arrows?

No. Thorns only triggers when an entity makes physical contact with your armor. Arrows will not activate the effect.

9. In what order should I enchant my armor?

A good enchantment order can maximize the levels you get out of your enchantments. Start by putting the more level-intensive enchantments together, and put them with cheaper enchantments in the anvil. A good order would be to combine the chestplate and Protection IV enchantments first, then add the Unbreaking and Mending.

10. Should I combine Mending and Unbreaking?

Absolutely! This combination is incredibly powerful. Unbreaking reduces the chance of durability loss, while Mending repairs the item using experience. Together, they make your armor virtually indestructible.

11. What is the best armor to fight the Wither?

Netherite armor is the best choice due to its high durability and protection. Enchant it with Protection IV on all pieces for maximum damage reduction.

12. Is Thorns good for the Ender Dragon?

Yes, but with caveats. While the Ender Dragon does make some physical contact during its attacks, Thorns is not the most effective enchantment for this fight. Focusing on damage output with your weapon is generally a better strategy.

13. Does Thorns work on all mobs?

Yes, Thorns will trigger when any mob makes physical contact with your armor. This includes common mobs like zombies and skeletons, as well as more dangerous creatures like creepers and endermen.

14. What are good alternatives to Thorns for PvP?

In PvP, Thorns can be useful, but other enchantments are often more effective. Consider these options:

Projectile Protection: Reduces damage from arrows and other projectiles.
Blast Protection: Reduces damage from explosions.
Feather Falling: Reduces fall damage.
Depth Strider: Increases movement speed in water.

15. Can I repair Thorns-enchanted armor in an anvil?

Yes, you can repair Thorns-enchanted armor in an anvil using the same material the armor is made of (e.g., diamonds for diamond armor, netherite ingots for netherite armor). However, using Mending is generally a more efficient and sustainable repair method, especially with Thorns’ increased durability consumption.

Is Thorns worth it in Minecraft?