Table of Contents

Is the Troll Knight’s Sword Good in Elden Ring? A Deep Dive

Yes, the Troll Knight’s Sword is a viable and potentially excellent weapon in Elden Ring, particularly for specific character builds and playstyles. While it may not boast the absolute highest raw damage of all Colossal Swords, its unique scaling, weapon skill, and relatively lower weight make it a compelling choice, especially for Intelligence/Strength hybrid builds. Its effectiveness depends heavily on how you build your character and how you utilize its special abilities.

Unpacking the Troll Knight’s Sword

The Troll Knight’s Sword stands out amongst the Colossal Swords in Elden Ring, offering a unique blend of attributes that cater to a specific playstyle. Unlike pure Strength-focused colossal weapons, this sword thrives on a combination of Strength, Dexterity, and Intelligence. This opens up interesting build possibilities, allowing players to weave magic into their melee combat.

Key Features

Scaling: The Troll Knight’s Sword scales with Strength (D), Dexterity (E), and Intelligence (D). This unique combination allows for a more diverse stat investment compared to other Colossal Swords.
Weapon Skill: Troll’s Roar: This skill unleashes a powerful roar that creates a shockwave, staggering enemies and creating space. The follow-up strong attack slams the sword down, dealing significant damage.
Weight: At 18.0 weight units, it’s lighter than some other Colossal Swords, allowing for better agility and equip load management.
Damage Type: Deals Standard and Strike damage, offering versatility against different enemy types.

Strengths

Hybrid Build Potential: Its Int/Str scaling makes it perfect for builds that want to incorporate magic into their melee combat. You can buff the weapon with spells or use Intelligence-based offensive incantations to supplement your attacks.
Crowd Control: Troll’s Roar is excellent for creating space and controlling groups of enemies, particularly useful in confined spaces or against swarming foes.
Stagger Potential: The shockwave from Troll’s Roar and the follow-up slam have a high chance of staggering enemies, allowing for critical attacks.
Unique Playstyle: The Troll Knight’s Sword encourages a more tactical and less purely aggressive approach compared to some other colossal weapons.

Weaknesses

Lower Raw Damage: Compared to weapons like the Greatsword or Grafted Blade Greatsword, the Troll Knight’s Sword has lower base physical damage.
Stat Investment: Requires investment in three stats (Strength, Dexterity, Intelligence), which can make it less effective in the early game.
Skill Cooldown: Troll’s Roar has a slight animation delay, leaving you vulnerable if mistimed.

Building Around the Troll Knight’s Sword

To truly maximize the potential of the Troll Knight’s Sword, you need to carefully craft your character build.

Key Stats

Strength: Enough to meet the minimum requirement to wield the weapon effectively, increasing as needed for damage scaling.
Dexterity: Enough to meet the minimum requirement to wield the weapon effectively, improving casting speed.
Intelligence: A primary stat for scaling the weapon’s damage and enabling the use of Sorceries or other Intelligence-based abilities. Aim for at least 50-60 Intelligence for optimal results.
Vigor: Essential for survivability. Aim for at least 40-60 Vigor.
Endurance: Allows for more attacks, dodges, and equipping heavier armor.
Mind: Increases FP for using Troll’s Roar and casting spells.

Talismans

Shard of Alexander: Greatly boosts the attack power of weapon skills, enhancing Troll’s Roar.
Godfrey Icon: Increases the charge attack power of skills and spells.
Cerulean Amber Medallion: Increases maximum FP.
Green Turtle Talisman: Increases stamina recovery speed.

Recommended Playstyle

Strategic Use of Troll’s Roar: Use Troll’s Roar to create space, stagger enemies, and set up follow-up attacks. It’s particularly effective against groups.
Weave Magic into Combat: Use Sorceries like Carian Slicer or Greatsword Phalanx to supplement your melee attacks and exploit enemy weaknesses.
Heavy Armor: Because Colossal weapons are slow to attack, you will be hit often, which will cause staggering unless you wear heavy armor.
Utilize Jump Attacks: Jumping Heavy Attacks can be deadly with colossal weapons.
Experiment: Be creative and try unique spell combinations!

Troll Knight’s Sword vs. Other Colossal Swords

While the Troll Knight’s Sword offers unique advantages, it’s essential to consider how it stacks up against other Colossal Swords:

Greatsword: Higher raw damage and simpler Strength scaling. A better option for pure Strength builds.
Grafted Blade Greatsword: High damage, but more Strength-focused. Its unique weapon skill provides buffs.
Starscourge Greatsword: Unique dual-wielding weapon skill that pulls enemies in. Scales with Strength, Dexterity, and Intelligence, but leans more towards Strength.
Ruins Greatsword: Scales with Strength and Intelligence. Its weapon skill deals Gravity damage.

Ultimately, the best Colossal Sword depends on your preferred playstyle and build. The Troll Knight’s Sword shines when you want to incorporate Intelligence into your melee combat and leverage its crowd control capabilities.

Conclusion

The Troll Knight’s Sword isn’t the absolute best Colossal Sword in Elden Ring, but it’s a strong contender that offers a unique and rewarding playstyle. Its scaling, weight, and weapon skill make it a compelling choice for Int/Str hybrid builds. If you’re looking for a weapon that allows you to weave magic into your melee combat and control the battlefield, the Troll Knight’s Sword is definitely worth considering. Just remember to optimize your build, practice using Troll’s Roar, and experiment with different spell combinations to unlock its full potential. Remember the principles of game design and learning by exploring the website of the Games Learning Society, GamesLearningSociety.org.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

H3 FAQ 1: Is the Troll Knight’s Sword good for beginners?

While its unique scaling offers versatility, the Troll Knight’s Sword might be less beginner-friendly than straightforward Strength-scaling Colossal Swords. Beginners might find it easier to manage a pure Strength build initially.

H3 FAQ 2: Where do you find the Troll Knight’s Sword?

The Troll Knight’s Sword is obtained by defeating the Troll Knight mini-boss near the Carriage at the Road of Iniquity in the Altus Plateau.

H3 FAQ 3: What are the stat requirements for the Troll Knight’s Sword?

The Troll Knight’s Sword requires 20 Strength, 18 Dexterity, and 22 Intelligence.

H3 FAQ 4: Can I use Ashes of War on the Troll Knight’s Sword?

No, the Troll Knight’s Sword has a fixed weapon skill and cannot be infused with Ashes of War.

H3 FAQ 5: How do I effectively use Troll’s Roar?

Use Troll’s Roar to create space, stagger enemies, and interrupt their attacks. Time it carefully to avoid getting hit during the animation. The follow-up slam deals significant damage.

H3 FAQ 6: What are some good spells to pair with the Troll Knight’s Sword?

Great Sorceries to pair with the Troll Knight’s Sword include Carian Slicer, Greatsword Phalanx, Loretta’s Greatbow, and Swift Glintstone Shard for quick damage and interrupt attacks.

H3 FAQ 7: Does upgrading the Troll Knight’s Sword increase its scaling?

Yes, upgrading the Troll Knight’s Sword with Smithing Stones will improve its scaling with Strength, Dexterity, and Intelligence, increasing its damage output.

H3 FAQ 8: Is the Troll Knight’s Sword viable in PvP?

Yes, but it requires practice and strategic use of Troll’s Roar to control spacing and punish opponents. The slow attack speed of Colossal Swords can be a disadvantage, so it’s important to be deliberate with your attacks.

H3 FAQ 9: What armor sets complement the Troll Knight’s Sword?

Armor sets that offer good poise and physical defense are ideal. Consider the Bull-Goat Set, Lionel’s Set, or the Black Knife Set.

H3 FAQ 10: Is the Troll Knight’s Sword better than the Troll’s Golden Sword?

Yes, the Troll Knight’s Sword generally has better scaling and damage potential than the Troll’s Golden Sword, making it a more desirable choice for most builds.

H3 FAQ 11: Can I dual-wield Colossal Swords effectively?

While possible, dual-wielding Colossal Swords requires high Strength and Endurance. It can be powerful, but also stamina-intensive. The patch 1.07 made Colossal weapons more viable, it can be a fun build.

H3 FAQ 12: How does the Troll Knight’s Sword compare to other Int/Str weapons?

Compared to weapons like the Moonveil Katana or Dark Moon Greatsword, the Troll Knight’s Sword offers a different playstyle focused on crowd control and stagger potential. It’s less reliant on fast attacks and more on strategic positioning and weapon skill usage.

H3 FAQ 13: What is the maximum upgrade level for the Troll Knight’s Sword?

The Troll Knight’s Sword can be upgraded to +10 using Somber Smithing Stones.

H3 FAQ 14: Does Troll’s Roar deal damage?

Troll’s Roar itself does minimal damage, but it staggers enemies and creates a shockwave that can knock them back. The follow-up slam deals significant damage.

H3 FAQ 15: What is the best way to farm runes to upgrade the Troll Knight’s Sword?

Popular rune farming spots include the Palace Approach Ledge-Road in Mohgwyn Palace, using the Sacred Relic Sword or other AoE attacks to quickly dispatch the Albinaurics.

Is Troll Knight Sword good?