Vagabond vs. Hero in Elden Ring: Which Class Reigns Supreme?

The question of whether the Vagabond or the Hero is the “better” class in Elden Ring isn’t a simple one. It hinges entirely on your intended playstyle and what you prioritize in the early game. In a head-to-head comparison, the Vagabond offers a more versatile and well-rounded starting point, making it generally more forgiving for new players. The Hero, while potent, leans heavily into a Strength-focused build, which can be limiting if you later decide to explore other playstyles. Thus, for overall versatility and ease of use, Vagabond is generally the better choice, especially for newcomers.

Diving Deep: The Strengths and Weaknesses of Each Class

To understand this conclusion, let’s dissect the specific strengths and weaknesses of each class.

The Vagabond: A Jack-of-All-Trades

The Vagabond is often hailed as the best starting class for a reason. Its stat distribution is balanced, with high Vigor (for health), decent Strength, and Dexterity, and a relatively low Arcane stat (which is beneficial if you don’t plan on using incantations).

• Strengths:

  • High Vigor: The highest starting health pool provides substantial survivability, especially in the challenging early game.
  • Good Starting Armor: The Vagabond begins with decent armor and a 100% physical damage reduction shield, allowing you to block most attacks without taking damage.
  • Versatility: Its balanced stats allow you to comfortably experiment with different weapon types and combat styles. You can easily transition into a Quality build (focusing on both Strength and Dexterity), or even dabble in magic later on.
  • Forgiving for New Players: The added survivability and the ability to block effectively make the Vagabond a great choice for players unfamiliar with Elden Ring’s combat system.

• Weaknesses:

  • Not Specialized: While versatile, the Vagabond doesn’t excel in any particular area at the start. Other classes might offer a more powerful early game if you’re committed to a specific build.
  • Lower Damage Output: Compared to the Hero, the Vagabond’s initial damage output with its starting weapons might feel slightly lower, especially against heavily armored enemies.

The Hero: A Strength-Fueled Behemoth

The Hero class is all about raw power. It boasts a high Strength stat, making it ideal for wielding heavy weapons and dealing significant damage.

• Strengths:

  • High Strength: Allows you to immediately equip and effectively use powerful Strength-scaling weapons.
  • High Starting Damage: The Battle Axe deals substantial damage, particularly early in the game.
  • Good Vigor: The Hero also has a decent Vigor stat, though slightly lower than the Vagabond’s.
  • Easily Playable: Focus on Strength is very useful for players looking to learn the core mechanics of the game.

• Weaknesses:

  • Less Versatile: The high Strength stat comes at the expense of other stats, making it harder to respec into a different build later on.
  • Lower Dexterity: Can limit your options in terms of weapon variety, as many weapons require a certain level of Dexterity to wield effectively.
  • Armor and Shield: Slightly lower protection from armor and shields compared to the Vagabond at the beginning.

Making the Right Choice for You

Ultimately, the “better” class depends on your personal preferences and playstyle. If you value versatility, survivability, and a forgiving learning curve, the Vagabond is the clear winner. If you want to smash enemies with massive weapons from the get-go and are comfortable committing to a Strength build, the Hero might be more appealing. Remember, every class is viable in Elden Ring, and you can respec your stats later in the game, so don’t feel pressured to make the “perfect” choice at the start. The important thing is to choose a class that aligns with your initial goals and allows you to enjoy the game. Explore different weapons, spells, and combat styles to discover what works best for you. Understanding how games engage and teach players, as discussed by the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org, can even give you a unique perspective on character building!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Can the Vagabond use magic?

Yes, the Vagabond can use magic, but its starting stats aren’t optimized for it. You’ll need to invest heavily in Intelligence or Faith to cast powerful spells effectively. Its low Arcane stat also means it won’t benefit as much from certain spells and incantations that scale with that stat.

2. Is the Hero class good for beginners?

The Hero can be good for beginners who enjoy a Strength-focused playstyle. Its high damage output can make the early game easier, but it can be less forgiving than the Vagabond due to its slightly lower starting health and less versatile stat distribution.

3. What stats should I level up first as a Vagabond?

Prioritize Vigor to increase your health, followed by Strength and Dexterity to meet the requirements for your desired weapons. Endurance is also important for stamina management, allowing you to attack, block, and dodge more effectively.

4. What stats should I level up first as a Hero?

Focus on Strength to maximize your damage output with heavy weapons. Also, level up Vigor to improve your survivability and Endurance to increase your stamina.

5. Can I change my class in Elden Ring?

No, you cannot change your starting class in Elden Ring. However, you can respec your stats later in the game by using Larval Tears, allowing you to reallocate your attribute points and change your build significantly.

6. Which class has the highest starting level?

The Wretch class starts at level 1, making it the lowest. Other classes start at varying levels. Check online for the most up-to-date information.

7. Is the Samurai class better than Vagabond?

The Samurai is a strong choice, particularly for those interested in Dexterity-based builds and using katanas. It offers higher damage output early on compared to the Vagabond, but it is less versatile overall. Whether it’s “better” depends on your preferred playstyle.

8. What is a Quality build?

A Quality build focuses on leveling both Strength and Dexterity, allowing you to wield a wide variety of weapons that scale well with both stats. The Vagabond is well-suited for a Quality build.

9. What weapons are good for the Vagabond?

Many weapons are good for the Vagabond. Starting weapons like Longsword are a good base. Good options for early to mid-game are: Claymore, Lordsworn’s Greatsword, Bloodhound’s Fang. These weapons are useful for players with both Strength and Dexterity.

10. What weapons are good for the Hero?

Good weapons for the Hero class should be heavy and require high strength. These weapons are useful for early to mid-game: Great Axe, Greataxe, Greatsword, Lordsworn’s Greatsword.

11. Does arcane affect the Vagabond?

Arcane can affect the Vagabond, it has an impact on Item Discovery and certain Sorceries and Incantations. However, given that the Vagabond isn’t built to use a lot of magic, it’s not a priority stat.

12. Is armor important in Elden Ring?

Yes, armor is important in Elden Ring. It provides physical and magical defense, reducing the damage you take from enemy attacks. Heavier armor offers more protection but reduces your mobility.

13. Can I parry with the Hero class?

Yes, you can parry with the Hero class, provided you equip a shield capable of parrying. Parrying allows you to deflect enemy attacks and create an opening for a counterattack.

14. What is the easiest class to play in Elden Ring?

There is no definite easiest class in Elden Ring. However, the Vagabond is usually recommended for new players due to its good balance of survivability and versatility. For magic users, the Astrologer is a good fit for new players.

15. What is the difference between warrior and hero in Elden Ring?

The Warrior class is geared towards players that enjoy Dexterity scaling weapon, and the Hero focuses on Strength weapons. The Warrior focuses on fast attacks with the twin blades, and the Hero relies on heavy weapons with a high Strength stat.