Table of Contents

Should I Be a Paladin or Fighter? A Comprehensive Guide

Quick answer

This page answers Should I be a Paladin or fighter? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

▶

Choosing between a Paladin and a Fighter in Dungeons & Dragons (D&D) or similar role-playing games (RPGs) is a classic dilemma. The direct answer is this: the best choice depends entirely on your desired playstyle, preferred role within the party, and the kind of story you want to tell. If you crave versatility, divine magic, and a strong moral compass, the Paladin is your champion. If you prefer raw martial prowess, tactical flexibility, and a broader range of character concepts, the Fighter reigns supreme. Let’s delve deeper into what makes each class unique and ultimately help you make the right decision.

Fighters: Masters of the Martial Arts

Fighters are the quintessential warriors, excelling in combat through sheer skill and training. Their strength lies in their adaptability and customization.

Strengths of the Fighter

High Damage Output: With multiple attacks per round and various combat-focused feats, Fighters can consistently deal substantial damage.
Durability: Fighters possess high hit points and proficiency in armor, making them resilient in the thick of battle.
Customization: Fighters have access to more Ability Score Improvements (ASIs) and feats than most other classes, allowing for highly tailored builds. You can specialize in ranged combat, two-weapon fighting, or becoming an unkillable tank.
Action Surge: This iconic ability grants an extra action once per short rest, providing a significant burst of power when needed most.
Simplicity: Fighters are relatively straightforward to play, making them an excellent choice for new players. They don’t rely heavily on spellcasting or complex mechanics.
Roleplaying Freedom: A Fighter’s backstory can be anything you imagine. They are not bound by oaths or religious dogma, offering unparalleled flexibility in character creation.

Weaknesses of the Fighter

Limited Utility: Fighters primarily excel in combat and lack the utility spells or skills that other classes possess.
Dependence on Equipment: Fighters rely heavily on their gear to be effective. A Fighter without a decent weapon and armor is significantly weakened.
Can Be Bland: Some players might find the Fighter lacking in flavor compared to more specialized classes.

Paladins: Holy Warriors with Divine Power

Paladins are sacred warriors who swear oaths to uphold justice, protect the innocent, and vanquish evil. They are a potent blend of martial prowess and divine magic.

Strengths of the Paladin

Versatility: Paladins are effective healers, damage dealers, and tanks, making them incredibly versatile in combat.
Divine Smite: This ability allows Paladins to deal massive bursts of radiant damage, especially effective against undead and fiends.
Auras: Paladins provide powerful auras that benefit their allies, enhancing their survivability and combat effectiveness.
Healing: Paladins have access to healing spells, allowing them to patch up wounded allies and keep the party going.
Strong Narrative Hooks: The Paladin’s oath provides a built-in framework for roleplaying, giving them a strong sense of purpose and direction.
Charisma-Based: Paladins rely on Charisma for spellcasting and some class features, making them excellent party faces and social characters.

Weaknesses of the Paladin

Oath Restrictions: Paladins are bound by their oaths, which can sometimes limit their actions and create internal conflicts.
MAD (Multiple Attribute Dependent): Paladins need high Strength (or Dexterity), Charisma, and Constitution to be effective, making them MAD.
Less Customization: Paladins have fewer ASIs/feats than Fighters, limiting their customization options.
Alignment Restrictions (Sometimes): Depending on the setting and specific oath, Paladins may be expected to adhere to certain alignments, which can restrict character choices.

Paladin vs. Fighter: A Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	Fighter	Paladin
:————-	:——————————————	:———————————————
Role	Damage Dealer, Tank	Damage Dealer, Tank, Healer, Support
Complexity	Low	Medium
Customization	High	Medium
Versatility	Low	High
Damage Burst	Moderate	High (with Divine Smite)
Utility	Low	Moderate (healing, auras)
Roleplay Hooks	Flexible, Dependent on Player’s Imagination	Oath-bound, Strong Moral Compass
Stats	Strength/Dexterity, Constitution	Strength/Dexterity, Charisma, Constitution
Primary Resource	Hit Points, Action Surge	Spell Slots, Divine Smite

Making the Right Choice For You

Consider these questions when deciding between a Paladin and a Fighter:

What role do you want to play in the party? If you want to be a purely martial character focused on dealing damage and soaking up hits, the Fighter is a great choice. If you want to be a more well-rounded character who can heal, support, and deal damage, the Paladin is a better fit.
What kind of story do you want to tell? Do you want to play a character with a strong moral code and a clear sense of purpose? The Paladin’s oath provides a built-in narrative framework. Or do you prefer a blank slate that allows you to create any backstory you desire? The Fighter offers greater freedom in this regard.
How much complexity do you want in your character? Fighters are relatively straightforward to play, while Paladins have more abilities and spells to manage.
How important is customization to you? Fighters have more ASIs and feats, allowing for highly tailored builds. Paladins have less customization, but their class features provide a strong sense of identity.

Ultimately, the best choice depends on your personal preferences. Both the Paladin and the Fighter are powerful and versatile classes that can contribute significantly to any D&D party.

If you want to learn more about game-based learning and the educational applications of role-playing games, visit the Games Learning Society at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/. You can also check out GamesLearningSociety.org for more resources.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Are Paladins good at fighting?

Yes! Paladins are excellent melee fighters. Their combination of martial prowess and divine magic makes them formidable opponents. They can deal significant damage, wear heavy armor, and heal themselves and their allies.

2. What fighting style is best for a Paladin?

The best fighting style for a Paladin depends on your preferred weapon and shield setup. Defense is a solid choice for added survivability (+1 AC). Dueling (when wielding a one-handed weapon and no other weapons) is good for consistent damage. Great Weapon Fighting (when wielding a two-handed weapon) is ideal for maximizing damage output.

3. Is Fighter a good multiclass for Paladin?

Absolutely. A two-level dip into Fighter for Action Surge is a popular and effective multiclass option for Paladins. It provides a significant burst of power, allowing them to cast more spells, inflict more Divine Smites, or perform other actions.

4. Which Paladin subclass is the strongest?

The “strongest” Paladin subclass is subjective and depends on the specific campaign and party composition. However, some popular and effective subclasses include the Oath of Vengeance (for damage dealing), the Oath of Devotion (for general utility and protection), and the Oath of Ancients (for support and nature-themed abilities).

5. What weapon should a Paladin use?

Paladins can use a variety of weapons effectively. Greatswords are popular for their high damage output, while one-handed weapons with shields offer greater protection. The Holy Avenger is a legendary weapon specifically designed for Paladins, granting bonuses to attack, damage, and radiant damage.

6. Can a Paladin become evil?

In most D&D settings, Paladins are expected to uphold their oaths and act in accordance with their alignment (usually good). However, it is possible for a Paladin to fall from grace and become an Oathbreaker. This can occur if they violate their oath or commit evil acts. The DM ultimately decides the consequences of a Paladin’s actions.

7. Is a knight a Paladin or a Fighter?

A knight can be either a Paladin or a Fighter, or even another class entirely. The term “knight” refers to a social status or rank, while Paladin and Fighter are specific character classes. A Paladin is a divine warrior who has sworn oaths to uphold justice, while a Fighter is a skilled martial combatant.

8. Do you have to be good to be a Paladin?

Traditionally, Paladins are associated with good alignments. However, depending on the edition of D&D and the DM’s interpretation, Paladins can be of any alignment. The key is that they must adhere to their chosen oath, which provides a moral compass for their actions.

9. Can Paladins use martial weapons?

Yes, Paladins are proficient with all martial weapons. This includes swords, axes, hammers, lances, and other weapons designed for combat.

10. What are Paladins’ weaknesses?

Paladins’ weaknesses include their dependence on multiple attributes (Strength/Dexterity, Charisma, and Constitution), their oath restrictions (which can limit their actions), and their limited customization options compared to Fighters. They also tend to be slower in movement when compared to other classes.

11. What is the best race for a Fighter?

The best race for a Fighter depends on the desired build and playstyle. Races with bonuses to Strength or Dexterity are generally good choices. Some popular options include Half-Orcs (for Strength and critical hit bonuses), Variant Humans (for a free feat), and Elves (for Dexterity and other benefits).

12. Can Paladins get drunk in D&D?

Yes, Paladins can get drunk. However, some players interpret a Paladin’s divine resilience as granting them resistance to the negative effects of alcohol. This is a matter of personal interpretation and DM discretion.

13. What is the best class for dual wielding?

The Fighter class is often considered the best for dual-wielding due to their fighting style options, multiple attacks, and access to feats that enhance dual-wielding combat. Ranger and Rogue can also be good choices, often incorporating multiclassing.

14. Why are Paladins so strong in D&D?

Paladins are strong due to their combination of martial prowess and divine magic. They can deal significant damage with weapons and spells, heal themselves and their allies, and provide powerful auras that enhance the party’s overall effectiveness. Their Divine Smite ability is especially potent, allowing them to deal massive bursts of radiant damage.

15. Do Paladins get two fighting styles?

Not normally. A Paladin gets one fighting style at 2nd level. However, multiclassing into a class like Fighter or Ranger (which also grants a fighting style at 2nd level) can give a character access to multiple fighting styles.