Should You Choose Natty or Sebastian for Your Hogsmeade Trip in Hogwarts Legacy?
The question of who to accompany to Hogsmeade is a recurring dilemma for Hogwarts Legacy players. Specifically, the choice between Natsai “Natty” Onai and Sebastian Sallow often sparks debate. The short answer? It doesn’t dramatically impact your overall game experience. Whether you choose Natty or Sebastian for your initial Hogsmeade visit, the core storyline and available gameplay elements remain consistent. However, the experience differs slightly in terms of dialogue and character interaction during the specific outing, which might influence your preference.
Ultimately, the decision should align with your personal role-playing choices and which character you find more engaging. There is no inherently “better” option in terms of gameplay advantages or disadvantages. This early-game choice is designed to personalize your experience, not to lock you into specific outcomes.
Choosing Based on Character Preference
Natsai Onai
Natty, a Gryffindor student who transferred from Uagadou, is known for her strong sense of justice and her dedication to protecting others. Choosing Natty means spending your Hogsmeade trip with a character grounded in good intentions and focused on fighting injustice. Her dialogue will often revolve around those themes, giving you a different perspective on the events surrounding your journey. If you prefer a character with a more heroic disposition and a strong moral compass, Natty is a solid option.
Sebastian Sallow
Sebastian, a Slytherin student, is a complex character drawn to the darker arts in his quest to save his sister, Anne. Choosing to go with Sebastian introduces you to his morally gray area and his intriguing backstory. His dialogue is laced with wit and a touch of danger. He presents a more rebellious and ambiguous figure, and his storyline delves into the consequences of dark magic. If you’re interested in a character with a more tragic arc and moral complexity, Sebastian is your man for Hogsmeade.
The Minimal Impact of Your Choice
The crucial takeaway here is that the Hogsmeade visit choice has no long-term ramifications for your game. It doesn’t influence which spells you learn, which quests you unlock, or which areas you can access. The fundamental gameplay structure remains the same regardless of your selection. The visit is designed as a character-building moment, allowing you to deepen your connections with the companion you choose for that specific quest. You will have ample opportunities to interact with both Natty and Sebastian throughout the game, so you are not locking yourself out of any significant content.
The Main Focus: Character Interaction
The main differences between the two Hogsmeade experiences lie solely in the dialogue and character interactions. Choosing Natty offers conversations focused on responsibility and bravery, while choosing Sebastian delves into the allure and danger of the dark arts. Both outings present a unique opportunity to understand the respective characters better, shaping your personal connection with them as you progress through the game.
No Locking of Storylines
The main narrative path of Hogwarts Legacy remains unchanged. You can still progress through all the main quests regardless of whom you accompany to Hogsmeade. Whether you go with Natty or Sebastian, both characters will remain a significant part of your journey. Therefore, your decision is less about gameplay strategy and more about personal preference and which character you connect with the most.
Choosing for Role-Playing Purposes
Your choice of companion for the Hogsmeade trip can also serve as an early indicator of your character’s values. Do you envision your witch or wizard as a noble Gryffindor, eager to stand up for what’s right? Then Natty might be the perfect companion for your first trip to Hogsmeade. Alternatively, if your character is more of a morally ambiguous Slytherin, intrigued by the dark arts and complexities of life, Sebastian is an intriguing choice. In this sense, the Hogsmeade decision can become a role-playing opportunity.
Your Character’s Personality
Selecting Natty aligns with the classic heroic archetype, whereas choosing Sebastian hints at a protagonist who leans towards the darker side of the wizarding world. However, it is important to note that you can still befriend both characters and learn from them throughout the game, regardless of your initial decision. Your character does not necessarily have to adhere to the initial role-playing choice you make. This is part of the game’s flexibility.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions related to the choice between Natty and Sebastian and their broader impact on Hogwarts Legacy:
1. Does choosing Natty or Sebastian affect the main storyline?
No. The core storyline remains the same regardless of whom you choose for the Hogsmeade visit. This is designed as a personalization option, not a critical plot point.
2. Can I still befriend both Natty and Sebastian if I choose only one for Hogsmeade?
Yes. You will have ample opportunities to interact and build relationships with both characters throughout the game, regardless of your initial Hogsmeade choice.
3. Does choosing Sebastian lock me into the dark arts path?
Absolutely not. You can still choose your own path and learn spells, regardless of whether you go with Sebastian. His arc is separate from your character’s overarching direction.
4. Can I romance Natty or Sebastian?
No. Romance options are not available in Hogwarts Legacy. While you build relationships with characters, there is no opportunity for romantic involvement.
5. Is it better to turn Sebastian in?
It depends on your goals. Turning him in will restrict your access to certain spells, particularly the Unforgivable Curses, but is aligned with a more righteous path. Not turning him in lets you learn these curses and keeps him in the game.
6. Can I learn the Unforgivable Curses if I go with Natty to Hogsmeade?
Yes. Your Hogsmeade choice has no bearing on your ability to learn the Unforgivable Curses. That is a separate storyline involving Sebastian.
7. Does my Hogsmeade companion choice affect the spells I learn?
No. Spells are unlocked through progression and side quests, and are not influenced by your Hogsmeade companion.
8. Does either choice affect the final ending of the game?
No. The main endings of Hogwarts Legacy are determined by later choices. The Hogsmeade visit has no impact on the final resolution of the game.
9. Can I avoid Sebastian killing his uncle?
No. The showdown with Solomon and his subsequent death is a fixed event in the game’s narrative. Your choices only impact whether you turn Sebastian in afterward.
10. Should I trust Sebastian Sallow?
This is up to you. Sebastian is a complex character with good intentions that lead to dark actions. Whether you trust him is based on your personal judgment and role-playing choice.
11. Does Sebastian’s choice to take the relic have any real consequence?
No. Sebastian will take the relic regardless of your dialogue choice. This is a set narrative event. Your opinion does not change the result, so feel free to make your decision based on RP.
12. Can you change your Hogsmeade companion choice later in the game?
No. Your Hogsmeade companion is a one-time choice. However, this choice doesn’t matter much as both characters appear often in the game.
13. What is the “bad” ending in Hogwarts Legacy?
The “bad” ending involves your character absorbing ancient magic, rather than containing it. This is determined much later in the game, not by the Hogsmeade choice.
14. Are there any exclusive items or rewards tied to either character?
No. There are no exclusive rewards tied to either character related to the Hogsmeade visit. The decision purely comes down to preference on interaction.
15. What happens if I tell Ominis about Sebastian?
Telling Ominis about Sebastian results in him being expelled. This is an outcome you choose after Sebastian kills his uncle, and this choice is not connected to your Hogsmeade trip.