Should I Let the Salarian Commando Out in Mass Effect? A Comprehensive Guide
The question of whether or not to release the Salarian commando during the Virmire mission in Mass Effect is a recurring dilemma for players. The short answer is: yes, you should let him out, regardless of your Paragon or Renegade alignment. While it initially appears to be a “good” versus “evil” choice, the tactical advantages gained by releasing the commando ultimately outweigh any perceived moral implications, particularly regarding the experience points (XP) awarded. Here’s a comprehensive breakdown of why, plus answers to frequently asked questions about the Virmire mission and its consequences.
Why Freeing the Salarian Commando is a Smart Move
Upon encountering the Salarian commando, you’re presented with a choice: leave him imprisoned or release him. A natural inclination, especially for Paragon players, might be to keep him locked up, fearing the potential consequences of unleashing him. However, the game cleverly subverts this expectation.
The Outcome: Releasing the commando triggers a chain of events. He releases the other Salarian prisoners, who, brainwashed by the Geth, immediately turn hostile and attack you.
The Benefit: XP Galore! This seemingly negative outcome is, in fact, a significant boon. Engaging and defeating these Indoctrinated Salarians provides a substantial amount of experience points. This XP boost can be invaluable for leveling up your character and squad, allowing you to better tackle the challenges that lie ahead, including the intense battles later in the Virmire mission and beyond. Moreover, killing these indoctrinated salarians does not have any lasting impact on your alignment or relationships.
Renegade Players, Take Note: Even for Renegade players, releasing the commando presents a more efficient way to gain XP than simply ignoring the situation. A Renegade playstyle is often about making pragmatic decisions, and this scenario falls squarely into that category.
Tactical Considerations: Following the initial firefight, you’ll encounter two additional Indoctrinated Salarians as you progress downstairs. This provides even more XP. Strategically, this encounter can be easily managed with proper squad positioning and the use of cover.
Virmire: More Than Just a Prisoner
The Virmire mission is a pivotal moment in Mass Effect. It not only tests your combat prowess but also forces you to make difficult choices with far-reaching consequences, including the fate of squadmates. The decision regarding the Salarian commando is just one small piece of a much larger, more complex puzzle. In situations like this, thinking critically and making difficult choices with long term strategies are important skills to master, a strategy that extends far beyond just playing games. Learning how to incorporate gaming into education can be a fun and interactive way for students to grow, and the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org is a great source for finding out more.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Virmire
1. Does it matter who I send with Captain Kirrahe?
No, the squadmate you send with Captain Kirrahe to divert the Geth forces does not impact the overall outcome of the Virmire mission. Both Ashley and Kaidan volunteer, and your choice simply determines who stays behind at the bomb site. Your choice does not change the outcome of Captain Kirrahe and his team.
2. Can I save both Kaidan and Ashley?
Normally, no. In the original Mass Effect, you are forced to choose between saving Kaidan or Ashley on Virmire. However, a mod exists in the remastered Mass Effect Legendary Edition that allows you to save both. Without the mod, one will inevitably die.
3. How do you convince Saren on Virmire?
To successfully persuade Saren during the Virmire confrontation, you need a high Charm or Intimidate skill. If you’ve used persuasion options effectively throughout the game, you may unlock special dialogue choices. If you haven’t utilized those skills prior to this moment, you will need the full 12 points available in either Charm or Intimidate. Successfully convincing Saren plants a seed of doubt in his mind, crucial for the final confrontation.
4. Does Saren fight on Virmire?
Yes, you encounter Saren in a boss fight on Virmire. He is atop a hovercraft and utilizes both biotic abilities and weapons, making him a challenging opponent. This is the first time you’ll encounter him directly in combat.
5. What happens if you don’t let the Salarian out?
If you choose to leave the Salarian commando imprisoned, you miss out on the experience points gained from fighting the Indoctrinated Salarians. It also highlights a missed opportunity for a potentially strategic, albeit morally ambiguous, decision.
6. Is Saren truly evil?
Saren is ultimately a tragic figure. While his actions are undeniably villainous, he is under the influence of Sovereign, a Reaper. Saren believes he is acting in the best interest of the galaxy, even if his methods are extreme and destructive.
7. Should I tell Saren to join me?
During the Virmire confrontation, using the “Charm” option to suggest that Saren join you plants a seed of doubt in his mind. This doubt becomes critical in the final encounter on the Citadel, potentially leading to him realizing the extent of his manipulation and ultimately taking his own life.
8. Can Saren be redeemed?
While it might seem counterintuitive, you can argue that Saren is redeemed, at least partially, if you convince him to commit suicide during the final confrontation. By breaking free from Sovereign’s control, he ultimately chooses to prevent further harm to the galaxy.
9. Did Saren find a Genophage cure?
Saren exploited his influence within Binary Helix to acquire the Genophage cure. He did not intend on actually curing the Genophage, instead he planned to build a Krogan army.
10. Who is the better choice to save: Ashley or Kaidan?
The choice between saving Ashley or Kaidan is highly subjective and depends on your personal preferences and roleplaying style. There is no truly “better” choice, as both characters offer unique perspectives and contribute differently to the story. Consider their personalities, beliefs, and how they fit into your overall narrative.
11. Is it worth it to sacrifice Ashley/Kaidan for strategic reasons?
Sacrificing Ashley or Kaidan for strategic gain doesn’t have a tangible in-game benefit. It’s purely a roleplaying decision with long-term narrative consequences. Your choice will affect squad dynamics and dialogue in subsequent games.
12. How can I maximize Krogan and Salarian support?
Achieving maximum Krogan and Salarian support involves careful decision-making. Keeping Wrex alive and making choices that align with his vision of a revitalized Krogan society is crucial. Regarding the Genophage cure, strategic choices are paramount, as outlined above.
13. Should I romance Liara over Ashley/Kaidan?
Romance choices are entirely personal. Liara, Ashley, and Kaidan each offer unique romantic storylines. If you are going to romance Liara, be aware that expressing interest in her will end your romance with either Ashley or Kaidan.
14. Why don’t other Turians look like Saren?
Saren’s unique appearance, specifically his lack of facial markings, is likely a design choice to distinguish him as a primary antagonist. While other Turians have variations in skin tone and facial markings, Saren’s stark appearance makes him more memorable and imposing.
15. Can you avoid fighting Saren?
Yes, you can avoid fighting Saren in the final encounter on the Citadel if you have successfully convinced him to doubt Sovereign on Virmire and possess sufficient Charm or Intimidate points. With the right dialogue options, he will commit suicide rather than continue serving the Reapers.
By understanding the consequences of your actions, you can navigate the complexities of the Virmire mission and make informed choices that align with your preferred playstyle and narrative goals. Ultimately, Mass Effect is about choice, and the decision regarding the Salarian commando, while seemingly minor, reflects the larger themes of morality, sacrifice, and the difficult choices that define the galaxy’s fate. Remember that critical thinking and strategic decision-making are important skills, whether you are leading a galactic alliance or preparing to enter the workforce. This article serves as a resource to guide you on your journey through Mass Effect and beyond.