Should You Lie to Professor Weasley in Hogwarts Legacy? A Comprehensive Guide
The world of Hogwarts Legacy is filled with choices, both big and small. One of the earliest, and perhaps most pondered, decisions players face revolves around a seemingly simple interaction with Professor Weasley: should you lie to her? The short and straightforward answer is: it doesn’t matter in terms of gameplay. Your decision to be truthful or deceitful has absolutely no impact on the overarching story, character progression, or any tangible rewards within Hogwarts Legacy. This choice is purely for role-playing purposes, allowing you to shape your character’s personality and experience the game through their unique lens. So, if you’re someone who embraces truthfulness, go ahead and tell her everything. If your character is a bit more mischievous, feel free to weave a tall tale.
The Illusion of Consequence
Many players come to Hogwarts Legacy expecting meaningful consequences for their choices, especially in interactions with authority figures. However, the game often steers clear of providing significant repercussions for dialogue selections, particularly in early-game scenarios. This is primarily to allow players to freely explore their character’s persona without the fear of locking themselves out of content or facing severe penalties.
A Matter of Character
The decision regarding Professor Weasley is a perfect example of this design philosophy. The dialogue choices you are presented with are carefully crafted to allow you to express your character’s intentions and values. Whether you want to play as an honest, rule-abiding student or a slightly rebellious one who bends the truth, Hogwarts Legacy provides that flexibility.
Beyond Professor Weasley
This pattern extends beyond just your encounter with Professor Weasley. Several other interactions throughout the game, with different professors and characters, offer similar choices with minimal gameplay impact. Lying to Professor Sharp, choosing to steal for Garreth Weasley, or even deciding whether to tell Sebastian the truth are all instances where your moral compass takes center stage, but your gameplay remains unaffected.
Focus on Role-Playing
The core intention behind these choices is to emphasize role-playing. You are not just controlling a student at Hogwarts; you are becoming that student. Therefore, the most important aspect of the decision about Professor Weasley is not what it unlocks or restricts within the game, but rather what it says about your character. Do you see them as naturally honest or prone to bending the rules? This decision is a vital piece in building that identity.
Embrace the Freedom
The lack of tangible consequence might feel underwhelming to some, but it allows you the freedom to make decisions that feel right for your character without the burden of game-related concerns. It’s a testament to the game’s focus on creating an immersive role-playing experience rather than relying solely on complex branching storylines driven by player choice.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
To provide additional clarity and address common queries, here are 15 frequently asked questions related to choices and consequences in Hogwarts Legacy:
1. Does lying to Professor Weasley affect my House reputation?
No, lying or telling the truth to Professor Weasley does not affect your House points or your reputation within your chosen House.
2. Does telling the truth matter in Hogwarts Legacy?
While honesty in some situations may earn praise from certain characters like Professor Sharp, it doesn’t impact the main storyline, character stats, or rewards in any significant way. These decisions are primarily for role-playing.
3. Should I lie to Professor Sharp?
You can either admit to misbehaving or lie to Professor Sharp. Honesty will earn you a commendation, while lying will earn an admonishment. However, this makes no difference to the rest of the game.
4. Is Professor Fig trustworthy?
Professor Fig appears trustworthy, fulfilling the Dumbledore mentor role. While he does employ methods to detect dark magic, it is presented as a protective measure. However, he does keep information to himself at times, and his motives and actions are later questioned by some characters in the story.
5. Does my choice with Sebastian or Natty matter in Hogsmeade?
The choice of who accompanies you to Hogsmeade only impacts the conversations you have there, having no consequences on the overall storyline or game outcome.
6. Should I steal for Garreth Weasley?
Stealing or not stealing the feather makes no difference to the lesson’s progression. If you steal it, Professor Sharp will tell you off; if you don’t, Garreth will figure out an alternate solution. The lesson outcome remains the same regardless of your choice.
7. Can I be evil in Hogwarts Legacy?
While you can make morally questionable choices and use Dark Arts spells, you cannot be canonically evil in Hogwarts Legacy. There is no ending where your character is recognized as inherently evil.
8. Does being good or evil matter?
No, whether your wizard is good or evil doesn’t make a major difference in the overall plot of your time at Hogwarts. Your good or evil actions do not have a significant impact on the world around you.
9. What is the final choice with Professor Fig?
For the good ending, you should answer “I intend to keep it contained here” and “I shall keep it secret forever.” This results in a positive reaction from Professor Fig.
10. How is Professor Weasley related to Ron?
Professor Weasley is likely Ron’s great-great-great-great aunt, although this specific relation has not been explicitly confirmed.
11. Can you stop Sebastian from killing his uncle?
No, you cannot stop Sebastian from killing his uncle. This event is a fixed part of his storyline.
12. What happens if you turn Sebastian in?
If you turn Sebastian in, he will be expelled and you cannot interact with him or learn any remaining Unforgivable Curses from him.
13. Can I get the killing curse if I turn Sebastian in?
No, you cannot learn Avada Kedavra if you turn Sebastian in. You need to choose “We must not turn Sebastian in” to learn it from him.
14. Can you mess up Sebastian’s questline?
You can alter very little in Sebastian’s questline. You can not alter key events and most choices are just roleplay options.
15. Should we snitch on Sebastian?
If you haven’t learned the Unforgivable Curses and want to, you should NOT turn Sebastian in. Turning him in means he’s expelled, and you lose the ability to learn those spells from him in the current playthrough.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the decision of whether to lie to Professor Weasley, or make similar choices throughout the game, is a personal one based on your preferred role-playing style. The absence of significant gameplay consequences allows you the freedom to shape your character’s personality without the fear of negatively affecting your game progression. Embrace the freedom, experiment with different responses, and allow yourself to fully immerse into the magical world of Hogwarts Legacy through the choices that resonate with your inner witch or wizard.