Table of Contents

Should I Max Out Stamina or Hearts in Zelda? A Definitive Guide

The age-old Zelda dilemma: stamina or hearts? It’s a question that has plagued adventurers since the original Legend of Zelda, and the debate has only intensified with the sprawling open worlds of Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom. There’s no single right answer, as play style and personal preference heavily influence the optimal choice. However, for the vast majority of players, prioritizing stamina early on is the strategically superior decision. Why? Let’s delve into the reasons.

The Case for Prioritizing Stamina

While the allure of more hearts is undeniable – who doesn’t want to survive more hits? – stamina unlocks crucial exploration capabilities and enhances overall gameplay freedom in the long run. Here’s a breakdown:

Exploration Domination: Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom are built around exploration. Climbing towering cliffs, gliding across vast canyons, and swimming long distances are core activities. More stamina directly translates to accessing more of the world, discovering hidden secrets, and reaching objectives that would otherwise be inaccessible.
Early Game Advantage: Stamina provides a significant early-game boost. Activating Sheikah Towers in Breath of the Wild or navigating the Great Sky Island in Tears of the Kingdom becomes dramatically easier with extra stamina. This accelerated exploration leads to faster access to better gear, resources, and ultimately, more power.
Combat Maneuverability: While hearts determine how much damage you can take, stamina dictates your ability to dodge, sprint, and perform special attacks. Mastering these combat maneuvers is often more effective than simply absorbing damage, especially against challenging enemies.
Resource Management: Food and elixirs can temporarily replenish hearts, making them somewhat less scarce than stamina. While there are stamina-restoring options, they often come with trade-offs, making a larger stamina pool a more reliable and consistent advantage.
The Master Sword (BOTW): In Breath of the Wild, acquiring the Master Sword requires a minimum of 13 hearts. However, many players find it more beneficial to temporarily boost their hearts using food or elixirs to meet this requirement, allowing them to focus on stamina upgrades throughout the majority of the game.

The Case for Hearts (Eventually)

While stamina takes the early lead, hearts shouldn’t be neglected entirely.

Increased Survivability: Obviously, more hearts mean you can withstand more damage, which is crucial for tackling tough bosses and navigating dangerous areas filled with formidable enemies.
Gloom Resistance (TOTK): Tears of the Kingdom introduces Gloom, a hazardous substance that not only damages you but also permanently reduces your maximum hearts. Having a larger heart pool provides a buffer against this debilitating effect.
Late-Game Security: As you progress and enemies become more powerful, the damage they inflict increases significantly. Maxing out hearts towards the end of the game provides a much-needed safety net, allowing you to make mistakes without instantly dying.

The Optimal Strategy: A Balanced Approach

The most effective approach is typically to prioritize stamina in the early game until you have at least two full stamina wheels. This allows you to explore freely and efficiently. After that, begin investing in hearts to increase your survivability.

Ultimately, you will be faced with the final choice and, with all shrines completed, you cannot max both stats! You will have to make a sacrifice between extra health, or extra stamina.

Consider these points:

Early Game: Focus primarily on stamina to unlock exploration potential.
Mid Game: Start balancing between stamina and hearts. Aim for at least 15-20 hearts.
Late Game: Max out either hearts or stamina based on your preferred play style. If you favor aggressive combat, prioritize hearts. If you prefer exploration and tactical gameplay, prioritize stamina.
Food and Elixirs: Utilize stat-boosting food and elixirs strategically to compensate for any deficiencies in your build. For instance, use heart-restoring food before facing a tough boss or stamina-replenishing elixirs when embarking on a long climb.

Conclusion

Choosing between stamina and hearts in Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom is a complex decision with no definitive answer. By understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each attribute and adapting your strategy based on your play style and progress, you can create a build that perfectly suits your needs. Embrace the freedom of Hyrule, explore its wonders, and become the hero you were destined to be. For more insights into the world of gaming and learning, visit the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Can you max out both hearts and stamina in Tears of the Kingdom?

No, similar to Breath of the Wild, you cannot max out both hearts and stamina in Tears of the Kingdom. You will have to choose which stat to prioritize.

2. How many hearts should I have before fighting Ganon?

It’s generally recommended to have at least 8 hearts before facing Ganon. However, more hearts will always improve your chances of survival.

3. How much stamina do I need to pull the Master Sword in Breath of the Wild?

You need 13 full heart containers to pull the Master Sword in Breath of the Wild. Temporary hearts granted by food or elixirs do not count.

4. Can the Master Sword break?

In Breath of the Wild, the Master Sword cannot break permanently. Instead, it runs out of energy and needs to recharge after a certain number of uses.

5. Is Tears of the Kingdom harder than Breath of the Wild?

Many players find Tears of the Kingdom to be more challenging than Breath of the Wild, particularly due to the introduction of Gloom and the increased damage output of enemies.

6. What’s the best armor in Tears of the Kingdom?

The Zonaite Armor is considered one of the best armor sets in Tears of the Kingdom because it reduces the energy consumption of Zonai devices.

7. Is the Hylian Shield unbreakable?

The Hylian Shield is incredibly durable but not unbreakable. It can withstand a significant amount of damage before breaking.

8. How many shrines are needed for 13 hearts?

You need to complete 40 shrines to get 10 additional heart containers, giving you a total of 13 hearts (including the 3 you start with). Each shrine awards one Light of Blessing, and four Lights of Blessing can be exchanged for one heart container or one stamina vessel.

9. How much stamina do I need for Lord of the Mountain?

Taming the Lord of the Mountain requires a significant amount of stamina, at least two full stamina wheels.

10. What should I prioritize first in Tears of the Kingdom?

You should prioritize exploring the Great Sky Island and visiting Lookout Landing early in the game. This will give you a solid foundation for the rest of your adventure.

11. Can I use fake hearts to get the Master Sword?

No, temporary hearts granted by food or elixirs do not count towards the 13 heart container requirement for the Master Sword.

12. How many hearts do you start with?

You start with 3 hearts in both Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom.

13. How much stamina do you need in Breath of the Wild?

Three full wheels of stamina is generally plenty to get Link where he needs to go.

14. What to do after 120 shrines?

After completing 120 shrines in Breath of the Wild, you get a new side quest that sends you to the Forgotten Temple.

15. How much stamina does it take to pull the Master Sword?

The player needs two full Stamina Wheels to draw the Master Sword, which steadily drain throughout the midair struggle. As food and potions cannot contribute here, this means that Link will need to obtain five Stamina Vessels to add to the single Wheel he starts the game with.

Should I max out stamina or hearts?