Should You Play as Alexios or Kassandra in Assassin’s Creed Odyssey?

The question of whether to play as Alexios or Kassandra in Assassin’s Creed Odyssey is one that has plagued players since the game’s release. The short answer is: it’s primarily a matter of personal preference, but with a key caveat. While both characters experience the exact same narrative, quests, and world, Kassandra is canonically the protagonist, a fact cemented by the official novelization and her subsequent appearance in Assassin’s Creed Valhalla. This canonical status and the community consensus towards her voice acting and performance often tips the scales in her favor for many players.

However, the choice isn’t so black and white. Let’s delve deeper into the nuances and considerations to help you decide which Spartan warrior will lead your odyssey.

The Story Remains Identical, But the Experience Differs

At its core, the narrative of Assassin’s Creed Odyssey remains unchanged regardless of whether you choose Alexios or Kassandra. Both siblings are raised as outcasts, thrust into a world of political intrigue, mythical creatures, and personal vendettas. They are both the “Eagle Bearer,” a mercenary capable of superhuman feats. They both will explore Ancient Greece, engage in naval battles, and ultimately confront the mysteries of their past.

The difference lies in your personal connection to the character and their respective voice acting. Kassandra’s voice actor, Melissanthi Mahut, has been widely praised for her nuanced and emotive portrayal, often considered to be more convincing and relatable than Michael Antonakos’ performance as Alexios. Many players find that Kassandra’s interpretation of the dialogue and her reactions to the world feel more organic and compelling. On the other hand, some players simply prefer the more rugged and stoic approach that Alexios brings.

Canonical Considerations: Why Kassandra is the “True” Protagonist

The major distinction comes with the canonical role. In the official Assassin’s Creed Odyssey novel, Kassandra is the chosen protagonist. She is the one who undertakes the journey of the Eagle Bearer and faces the challenges, cementing her place as the definitive version of the hero within the Assassin’s Creed universe. Furthermore, the storyline sees Alexios as “Deimos” – the antagonist – if you play as Kassandra. This dynamic adds another layer to the narrative for those seeking to experience the story in its intended form.

While Assassin’s Creed games typically offer options to shape the narrative, the canonical selection of Kassandra suggests a specific vision from the writers. If playing the most authentic version of the story is important to you, then choosing Kassandra is the clear choice. The story implications of Alexios as the antagonist, “Deimos,” make for a more impactful narrative for many.

First Playthrough: Kassandra or Alexios?

The question of which character to choose for your first playthrough remains a common dilemma. If you value consistent and engaging voice acting, then the majority opinion leans towards Kassandra. Her performance is often lauded, and many players feel more invested in her personal journey. Her delivery often resonates well with the narrative of being an outcast trying to find her place.

However, if you find yourself more drawn to a male character, Alexios is still a perfectly viable option. The story itself won’t change, and you’ll still have access to all the content and gameplay. Ultimately, the “better” experience is the one that most resonates with you personally. There’s no objective disadvantage to choosing Alexios, aside from the canonical and community preference towards Kassandra.

Gameplay and Gender: Does it Matter?

Gameplay-wise, there’s no significant difference based on which character you choose. Both Alexios and Kassandra control identically, and possess the same skill trees, gear, and abilities. Some players have reported minor variations in combat animations, but these are hardly noticeable and don’t impact the overall gameplay.

The primary consideration is your preference. If you prefer playing as a female character, then Kassandra is the perfect choice. If you prefer playing as a male character, then Alexios provides an equally engaging gameplay experience. The key is picking the protagonist you will most enjoy spending dozens of hours playing as.

Romance and Relationships

One key area often questioned is how romantic options vary between the two characters. The answer is: they don’t significantly. Both Alexios and Kassandra can romance a variety of characters of both genders. You’re free to pursue any romantic interest regardless of your chosen character. The romantic subplot is a way to increase player immersion and has nothing to do with the gender of the protagonist. Therefore, romance options should not be a deciding factor in your choice of protagonist.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here are 15 frequently asked questions to further address any concerns or confusion about playing as either Alexios or Kassandra in Assassin’s Creed Odyssey:

1. Is the story different for Alexios and Kassandra?

No. The core narrative, quests, and events are identical for both characters. The only difference is the character model, voice acting, and canonical role.

2. Am I supposed to play as Kassandra?

Kassandra is considered the canon protagonist, according to the official novel. However, the choice is ultimately up to the player. The story works well with either character.

3. Who is Deimos if you play as Kassandra?

If you choose to play as Kassandra, Alexios will be the Deimos – the main antagonist in the story.

4. Can I switch between Alexios and Kassandra?

No, you cannot switch between them within a single playthrough. You choose one character at the start of the game. You will need to begin a New Game+ to play as the other twin.

5. Can I romance Kassandra?

Yes, Kassandra has several romance options, including both male and female characters, just like Alexios.

6. How many endings are there in AC Odyssey?

There are nine different endings, determined by choices you make throughout the game.

7. Does gender matter in Assassin’s Creed Odyssey?

Narratively, no. Both characters experience the same story. There are some negligible differences in combat animations, but no significant gameplay variations.

8. What happens if I say I killed Nikolaos?

Killing Nikolaos impacts the possibility of obtaining the “best” ending. Letting him live has a positive outcome for the family reconciliation story arc.

9. What do I say to Deimos in jail?

To earn goodwill, choose the following dialogue options: “It was the prophecy,” “The prophecy said you’d doom Sparta,” “Our mother searched for you,” “She thought you were dead,” and “I was thrown off, too.”

10. Can Deimos be saved?

Yes, Deimos can be saved. In the final confrontation, choose the option “I don’t want to fight you.” You must have had a good relationship with him beforehand.

11. Who can you romance as Alexios?

Alexios can romance both male and female characters, similar to Kassandra.

12. Which twin to choose at the beginning of the game?

You choose which character you want to play as, not which twin to save. You choose either Alexios or Kassandra and begin the game.

13. Who is the best love interest in AC Odyssey?

Many players favor Daphnae, Kyra, and Alkibiades as strong romance options. However, preferences vary significantly.

14. Is Kassandra in Valhalla?

Yes, Kassandra appears in Assassin’s Creed Valhalla as part of the “A Fated Encounter” questline.

15. Can you save Kassandra and Myrrine?

Yes, it’s possible to get an ending where both Kassandra and Myrrine survive, along with Alexios, Stentor, and Nikolaos.

Conclusion

While the choice between Alexios and Kassandra boils down to personal preference, Kassandra’s canonical status and widely praised performance make her a compelling choice for many players. However, Alexios also offers a robust experience, with the same story and gameplay at its core. Ultimately, the “right” character is the one that resonates most with you. Dive into Ancient Greece, experience a grand story, and forge your own legend as either Alexios or Kassandra.